IS Meenal better than poonam and sumedha - Page 2

Originally posted by: simpleguy

Meenal cannot shows any expression not even in Indian Idol that also said by Farah Khan ...she is like to me a Dead Singer with no expression she will be out soon ....👏

if expressions are more important than singing then i ask u one imaginary question ...suppose if LATA MANGESHKAR sings on stage do u think she wud need to perform also to get points.... nahi naa...arey thats y the show has dancers to perform and singers to sing....its like asking a doctor to teach and a teacher to do diagnosis for a disease....well meenal is a singer and shud be voted only based on her singing😳😛😛

Originally posted by: simpleguy

Meenal cannot shows any expression not even in Indian Idol that also said by Farah Khan ...she is like to me a Dead Singer with no expression she will be out soon ....👏

Meenal is very good singer and if i have to compare with sumedha then i ll give them equal rating.however poonam is class apart. she is far better than both of them, Infact i havent seen anyone of her calibre is voi, II and saregama of last year.

Sumedha has a good voice, i have heard singing slow songs in saregamapa she sings them good. I am not sure too much about meenal, havent heard her a lot.

Originally posted by: aneek paul

Meenal is very good singer and if i have to compare with sumedha then i ll give them equal rating.however poonam is class apart. she is far better than both of them, Infact i havent seen anyone of her calibre is voi, II and saregama of last year.

Originally posted by: ~LovleyStar~

well in that case, Sumedha is no Less either infact sumedha haz gotten a lot of praising as well
especially from vishal-shekhar, one of the top music directors of today 😉

plz check out her SRGMP performances Shez much better than meenal..n againn the topic
waz on oppionzz..so anywaiz

Well sumedha got praising from vishal shekhar only during the reality show....meenal got so much admiration from Anu malik,sonu nigam and others during indian idol....but the important thing to notice is that meenal got praised by A.R.Rehman who never met her in any reality show...and have u heard her album MEHRAM...just go thru this link.... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f9gpwX2lo8g and see her prfrmance also in this vdo...u will get to know the class of the singer
👏
👏

Originally posted by: RAJNISHMJF1

Well sumedha got praising from vishal shekhar only during the reality show....meenal got so much admiration from Anu malik,sonu nigam and others during indian idol....but the important thing to notice is that meenal got praised by A.R.Rehman who never met her in any reality show...and have u heard her album MEHRAM...just go thru this link.... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f9gpwX2lo8g and see her prfrmance also in this vdo...u will get to know the class of the singer
👏
👏

Better???? Meenal is far better than both of them👏

I never watchd SRGMP thts y never heard much of Sumedha & Poonam but according to their EKSBK.. performances.....they are average singers...

Originally posted by: *Alishba*

Better???? Meenal is far better than both of them👏

I never watchd SRGMP thts y never heard much of Sumedha & Poonam but according to their EKSBK.. performances.....they are average singers...