Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
I just wanted to post this topic because, as an avid Aneek Dhar fan, I am concerned about the way he has been treated in this show (ESBE.)
Firstly, I don't think he is receiving the marks from the judges that he deserves. He is giving consistently good performances throughout the show, and others, who are doing beautifully but not as well with the technicalities of their song, are getting higher scores from the judges. When i say he does well i mean it simply based on the principles (technicalities) of music/singing, not opinion.
Secondly, I didn't like the way one of the esbe contestants made rather vulgar statements about Aneek on the Jul 26th episode of esbe, videos available right here on IF. If those comments were made to boost trp, then I'm sorry both for placing the blame on that contestant and that the channel would do this for ratings.
*** Please no offensive comments ***

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

3.5k

Users

20

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

bellevue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

I just wanted to post this topic because, as an avid Aneek Dhar fan, I am concerned about the way he has been treated in this show (ESBE.)

Firstly, I don't think he is receiving the marks from the judges that he deserves. He is giving consistently good performances throughout the show, and others, who are doing beautifully but not as well with the technicalities of their song, are getting higher scores from the judges. When i say he does well i mean it simply based on the principles (technicalities) of music/singing, not opinion.
Secondly, I didn't like the way one of the esbe contestants made rather vulgar statements about Aneek on the Jul 26th episode of esbe, videos available right here on IF. If those comments were made to boost trp, then I'm sorry both for placing the blame on that contestant and that the channel would do this for ratings.
*** Please no offensive comments ***

Lucky jade, I am also wondering about why Aneek till today hasn't received a ten from the judges. As far as his singing is concerned he has done a stupedous job with each and every song so far he has sung. You mentioned something about the way he has been treated in the show. I found most of the time unnecessarily they have been using him to raise trp. Even if he is young there is no reason to poke fun at him ( they are forgetting he deserves same respect as any one else) by saying, abe main udhar aou, or khabardaar agar tu mujhe chuna toh, and many more examples that we all know. I don't think any one made fun of other contestants as much as him. No one questions about that (humiliation that he is facing) here and now a contestant (whom I admire deeply for his singing and positive attitude) is questioning his integrity. But let me tell you, inspite of being so young Aneek respectfully said in his defence and for that I am so glad to be his fan. This young man knows how to handle such humiliating situation by staying calm and doing what he does best that is sing beautifully.
sapnamg thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
Raja's attitude that is shown towards the end of the video is shocking. I mean I did not know Raja could or would behave like this.
munda4207 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Ok both are right...Raja shouldnt blame aneek..and aneek shouldnt blame raja...both should blame both judges...they are making easier for aneek to get votes....there creating attraction toward aneek...to make show interesting they are making random stories about aneek..and thats what i dont like...and raja should know this..so do aneek.

munda4207 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
by the as people above mentioned...this show is a drama...aneek didnt get 10points because he doesnt need it...and when he's in shani zone..he'll get ten watch...preplanned situation...secondally raja doesnt get 10 points either how would compare that with aneek's case? as long as i know both are extremely good singers..but i know whats the problem first of all judges are not good...and judge expect too much from them....
diplomats101 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
haha i loved rajas attitude and how he cursed..but i agree with raja they are giving too much attention to aneek..aneek is overrated
xxangelxx thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: diplomats101

haha i loved rajas attitude and how he cursed..but i agree with raja they are giving too much attention to aneek..aneek is overrated



i totally agree wit u. aneek is taking 2 much attention. i luved it wen raja got all pissed wit aneek cuz aneek waz getting on mi last nerves 2. aneek deserved everything raja told him. and he deserved 2 get cursed at. aneek is a awesum singer and i luv his voice but he is sortof kissing up 2 the judges and is always jk a little 2 much. if they can cut out comments 4 laughter then im totally wit raja.


srry if this waz offensive towards any1..i didnt mean 2 😆
munda4207 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

now I am expecting more drama from Judges point of view tomorrow...hopefully these stories of raja and aneek are revealed to judges lolol...let see how they mix sugar with mirchi haha

bellevue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: munda4207

Ok both are right...Raja shouldnt blame aneek..and aneek shouldnt blame raja...both should blame both judges...they are making easier for aneek to get votes....there creating attraction toward aneek...to make show interesting they are making random stories about aneek..and thats what i dont like...and raja should know this..so do aneek.

When did Aneek blame Raja, may be I missed it. I agree they should not blame each other because they are in the same boat. You may think they are making it easier for aneek to get votes, but I think all that teasing may backfire on him. May be people will start to think that Aneek is trying to steal all the lime light from others which is not a fact for sure. Any way, let's enjoy all these talented contestants performances.
munda4207 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10
yeah actually aneek did not directl blame raja...but both were reacting (fake reactions) like they were blaming or fighting each other instead of blaming judges...if i was the director of the show..i would have saved this drama till the end man...because more people watch the show when its about to end or final result is about to end...more TRPs haha

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".