Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

3.5k

Users

20

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

bellevue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: malaysiangirl

@sonnia & bellevue-I am happy the way both of you have replied so positively.I do not bother much what other people gonna say negatively about aneek but the main point is aneek have response so positively and I am happy with him.Aneek didnt ask judges to tease him or make some funny comments in order to gain votes or get more attention.Aneek is an excellent singer and people are voting for his singing and I will keep supporting his good singing. Aneek always been very direct and honest. I will not comment about other singers because I respect all of them and god bless them always with loads of success and as being fan of aneek I am proud of him and I know aneek's attitude very well.Keep the great work going aneek!

God bless all the singers.
We do not know the truth and dont just jump into conclusion.Just enjoy the show and forget the other dramas.
with best wishes,
Malaysiangirl

Mgal I remember the first time I heard Aneek, I became the fan of this cultured, extremely polite, respectful, witty, singer. Escpecially after I have talked to you, I know you had a chance to meet him and talked to him in the past. From what little you have told me about this young man I am really happy that he is genuinely a sincere, creative, hard working, an honest human being. That doesn't mean I don't like any of the other singers. I really thought all of singers that come to these reality shows are definitely talented enough to make it this far (considering the number of people I see all over India standing in line to participate in these reality tv shows). Yesterday's episode really should not have taken place but unfortunately it did happen we need to just forget about it not become so judgemental about any one of them.
Malaysian_Girl thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: bellevue

Mgal I remember the first time I heard Aneek, I became the fan of this cultured, extremely polite, respectful, witty, singer. Escpecially after I have talked to you, I know you had a chance to meet him and talked to him in the past. From what little you have told me about this young man I am really happy that he is genuinely a sincere, creative, hard working, an honest human being. That doesn't mean I don't like any of the other singers. I really thought all of singers that come to these reality shows are definitely talented enough to make it this far (considering the number of people I see all over India standing in line to participate in these reality tv shows). Yesterday's episode really should not have taken place but unfortunately it did happen we need to just forget about it not become so judgemental about any one of them.

@Bellevue-Well said my dear friend.I know how much love you have towards music and I love the way you analyze good singing.The reason I said that dont jump into conclusion is was for the members who said negatively about aneek.Aneek didnt ask the judges to tease him or make fun of him.I am happy seeing the way you and sonnia have responded so positively.Keep it up!
God Bless!
Cheers,
Mgal
bellevue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#23
@Mgal, thanks for your kind words. I am glad you keep emphasizing about getting one's facts checked before criticising any one. It is disappointing to see so many people making such rude comments about Aneek. Frankly I failed to see where Aneek went wrong, from what I saw the judges were saying things to him. What is he suppose to do just look at them and say well, I should not talk because my answers might anger certaing group of people or the contestants? I think he should be told to concentrate on his singing and not worry about what people will say!
RAJNISHMJF1 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#24
omgg i m shocked to see that u have written 'INJUSTICE WITH ANEEK'
infact i felt like he has been done justice more than wat he deserved...judges are really pampering him like he is his son... why other contestants are not given the same frndly treatment....😔
~LovleyStar~ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#25
one thingg is for sure that judges are on crack lol their marks dont make much sense
RAJNISHMJF1 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#26
the worst judges i have ever seen in any reality show...they are unbelievably unpredictable...they dont have any usool's. They are so confused that they dont know wat they are saying and wat are they doing
bellevue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: RAJNISHMJF1

omgg i m shocked to see that u have written 'INJUSTICE WITH ANEEK'
infact i felt like he has been done justice more than wat he deserved...judges are really pampering him like he is his son... why other contestants are not given the same frndly treatment....😔

I have always supported Aneek for his outstanding singing. I am sorry you feel that Aneek has been pampered by the judges. I am not sure why you feel that way. If he is getting more footage, how is that his fault? If you were there in his place would you have refused to answer the judges? What do you expect from him? Is he asking the judges and paying the cahnnel to give him the most footage? May be you know something that I don't know. I think each and every one of those contestant are there with the hope that they will win, I like wish all the contestants the best.
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: bellevue

I have always supported Aneek for his outstanding singing. I am sorry you feel that Aneek has been pampered by the judges. I am not sure why you feel that way. If he is getting more footage, how is that his fault? If you were there in his place would you have refused to answer the judges? What do you expect from him? Is he asking the judges and paying the cahnnel to give him the most footage? May be you know something that I don't know. I think each and every one of those contestant are there with the hope that they will win, I like wish all the contestants the best.

My reason for starting this topic as "injustice" toward Aneek is that he is constantly giving flawless performances, keep in mind i make these statements based on his style of singing inrelation to principles of singing/music, not emotions. Yet, he is never given the high scores (ten) that reflect his singing while other singers do well but do not do as well in the technicalities of singing get full points. Secondly, the judges are always teasing him picking on him and embarrassing him on international television. Do you see any other contestant being ridiculed the way Aneek is? I don't think ridiculing someone is pampering him. It wasn't fair to make Aneek pick Ahmed to get scores from him when all singers choose Abhijeet and dancers choose Ahmed. Then, this most recent controversy just adds to all this.
Those of you who feel Aneek is being pampered, please explain your reasoning, for the sake of healthy discussion.
Edited by LuckyJade - 17 years ago
Malaysian_Girl thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

My reason for starting this topic as "injustice" toward Aneek is that he is constantly giving flawless performances, keep in mind i make these statements based on his style of singing inrelation to principles of singing/music, not emotions. Yet, he is never given the high scores (ten) that reflect his singing while other singers do well but do not do as well in the technicalities of singing get full points. Secondly, the judges are always teasing him picking on him and embarrassing him on international television. Do you see any other contestant being ridiculed the way Aneek is? I don't think ridiculing someone is pampering him. It wasn't fair to make Aneek pick Ahmed to get scores from him when all singers choose Abhijeet and dancers choose Ahmed. Then, this most recent controversy just adds to all this.

Those of you who feel Aneek is being pampered, please explain your reasoning, for the sake of healthy discussion.

Well said sonnia and Bellevue👏
I was wondering from which angle does our dear friend RAJNISHMJF1 have seen the judges pampering aneek like their son:) .Well I do know very well what is going on the set very much dear but I just dont want to say anything because at the end all of us are music lovers and just try to take things positively and keep supporting your favourites.Lets enjoy the music and singing and leave all the drama created by the channel or judges.RAJNISHM I respect your point of view dear and I am very proud with my friends who have replied your comments in a healthy way and without pin pointing any of the singers because they respect all the singers and music.
Have a nice day friends.
Keep supporting your favourites and enjoy the show.
with best wishes,
Malaysiangirl
sreya_cp thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#30
Aneek is a great singer.He mesmerised us with his divine singing since SRGMP Bangla and SRGMP Challenge 2007.And as he deserved he won both of the compititions.Now in ESBE Aneek is again giving superb performances consistantly.But he is not getting 10 points😡..This discrimination should not at all be done.Those who dont sing better are getting 10.This have really made me angry..
Aneek is very adorable,sweet guy.And it is very well shown that all of the judges,be it HR,Vishal shekhar,abhijeet..they all love him..he is loved by everyone for the person he is and for his innocent behaviour.But at the same time,i m not liking those pranks played by the judges on Aneek.some fun is always welcome,but they are repeatedly pulling his leg..this has a limit...they should not embarass him in front of the camera.
And as far as the comments made by a contestant against Aneek.i dnt knw whether it was scripted and if it was not scripted,then this was not expected from that contestant.Aneek and Raja are like brohers..they enjoy each others performances,Aneek respects his Rajabhaiya a lot..this is well shown.i m really very happy by the way Aneek handled the situation,being diehard Aneek fan,i m always with him.these controversies are made to entertain people.and its not aneek's fault why the judges picks on him,did he ever said or started those pranks??the answer is obviously NO...so if anyone blames Aneek,they are purely mistaken..they better stop discouraging anyone.
Aneek is proving his talent once again,so we should all support this amazing singer.Although i dont know him personally,i can blindly say that he is a nice,honest and genuine human being..this shows clearly by his humble behaviour..and i hope he stays like this forever.
I really pray for aneek to win esbe,as he deserves..i m sure aneeek will give more wonderful performances and if luck supports him,he would get 10 from both of the judges..all the best aneek..keep up the good work!.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".