{| SPK: Episode Discussion thread #3 |} - Page 17

Poll

Which in your opinion was the WORST Mahabharat depiction?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

470

Views

57.7k

Users

31

Likes

907

Frequent Posters

ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
So that is what happened when Arjun shot that Astra called Tvashtra on Samsaptakas. Due to the power of that Astra Arjun's rivals saw Arjun or Krishna in their own people only and killed one another. None other than Arjun used this ever. And when this happened Karna is in the battle field. He did not counter it at all. There is no Astra called Satya Kirti Astra. And it can not nullify Tvashtra .When Karna doesn't know that how can Vrishasen know that? So distortion of facts and over glorification of SIDPutr and his son. That's all. Khud Parasurama and Bheeshma admitted no one possessed the astras like Arjun did.Accept the fact SIDT. If seeing this post even if one person realises the truth,it is enough for me.
Vinnas,you always give a very good account of what happened in the Episode and whether it is good or bad. I always read your brief and decide whether to watch or not, But today I can't control myself on seeing the. Messed up facts and just posted this. I hope you will read it and decide for yourself whether the Episode is good or not.
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
The Critical Edition is also telling the same thing. But I did not give the citations since English version is more accessible to every one.
vinnas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ltelidevara

So that is what happened when Arjun shot that Astra called Tvashtra on Samsaptakas. Due to the power of that Astra Arjun's rivals saw Arjun or Krishna in their own people only and killed one another. None other than Arjun used this ever. And when this happened Karna is in the battle field. He did not counter it at all. There is no Astra called Satya Kirti Astra. And it can not nullify Tvashtra .When Karna doesn't know that how can Vrishasen know that? So distortion of facts and over glorification of SIDPutr and his son. That's all. Khud Parasurama and Bheeshma admitted no one possessed the astras like Arjun did.Accept the fact SIDT. If seeing this post even if one person realises the truth,it is enough for me.

Vinnas,you always give a very good account of what happened in the Episode and whether it is good or bad. I always read your brief and decide whether to watch or not, But today I can't control myself on seeing the. Messed up facts and just posted this. I hope you will read it and decide for yourself whether the Episode is good or not.

thanks alot for giving right info dear .I dnt know much about anything.i used to read your posts in navi AT ..you doing great job ..

thanks for appreciating my efforts ..
I watch it as it shows but dnt believe wat it shows ..abt wat I said it's a good epi to watch is becoz of the war atmosphere and no ott ..navi .vrish .abhi performances. apart from this nothing is value to mention ..

thanks for clarification .keep post here to your views ..
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ltelidevara

So that is what happened when Arjun shot that Astra called Tvashtra on Samsaptakas. Due to the power of that Astra Arjun's rivals saw Arjun or Krishna in their own people only and killed one another. None other than Arjun used this ever. And when this happened Karna is in the battle field. He did not counter it at all. There is no Astra called Satya Kirti Astra. And it can not nullify Tvashtra .When Karna doesn't know that how can Vrishasen know that? So distortion of facts and over glorification of SIDPutr and his son. That's all. Khud Parasurama and Bheeshma admitted no one possessed the astras like Arjun did.Accept the fact SIDT. If seeing this post even if one person realises the truth,it is enough for me.

Vinnas,you always give a very good account of what happened in the Episode and whether it is good or bad. I always read your brief and decide whether to watch or not, But today I can't control myself on seeing the. Messed up facts and just posted this. I hope you will read it and decide for yourself whether the Episode is good or not.



This show is way more distorted than what you're describing. Days 1-10, when Karna wasn't around, neither was his sons. The first mention of Vrishasena fighting anybody was on day 11 or beyond, when he took on all of Draupadi's sons, since he was more than a match for Prativindya. He fought Abhimanyu on day 13, and was one of the many warriors defeated by him.

So not only couldn't Vrishasena have known those weapons - he couldn't even have fought during the time Bheeshma was active. Karna's exclusion wasn't personal - his family or his kingdom was excluded as well.
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
"Bhishma said, 'Both the brothers Achala and Vrisha are Rathas. Invincible (in battle) they will slay thy foes. Endued with great strength, those tigers among men, those foremost of Gandharvas, are firm in wrath. Young and handsome, they are possessed of great strength. As regards this thy ever dear friend, this one who is always boastful of his skill in battle, this one who always urgeth thee, O king, to fight with the Pandavas, this vile braggart, Karna, the son of Surya, this one who is thy counsellor, guide, and friend, this vain wight who is destitute of sense, this Karna, is neither a Ratha nor an Atiratha. Without sense, this one hath been deprived of his natural coat of mail. Always kind, he hath also been deprived of his celestial ear-rings. In consequence of the curse of Rama (his preceptor in arms) as also of the words of a Brahmana (who cursed him on another occasion), owing also to his deprivation of the accoutrements of battle, he, in my judgment, is only half a Ratha. Having approached Falguni (in battle), he will not certainly escape with life!' Hearing this, Drona, that foremost of all wielders of weapons, said, 'It is even so as thou hast said. That is not untrue! He boasteth on the eve of every battle, but yet he is seen to retreat from every engagement. Kind (out of season) and blundering, it is for this that Karna, in my judgment, is only half a Ratha!'
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
is true the scriptures teach that the words of the old should be listened to. That, however, doth not refer to those that are very old, for these, in my judgment, become children again. Alone I will exterminate the army of the Pandavas! The fame, however, of such a feat will attach to Bhishma, O tiger among kings, for this Bhishma, O monarch, hath been made by thee the commander of thy forces, and the renown always attacheth to the leader and not to those that fight under him. I will not, therefore, O king, fight as long as Ganga's son liveth! After Bhishma, however, hath been laid low, I will fight with all the Maharathas of the enemy united together!'
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
I agree with you Vrish,Vrishasen fought after ten days only. He excelled Prati and others but was defeated by Abhi. But Karna khud withdrew from entering the battlefield as he was hurt by Bheeshma's categorisation of himself as Artharathi. So we can not. call it Exclusion since it is voluntary . So Karna on his own kept himself away . Naturally his army and family will follow him only.
Edited by ltelidevara - 9 years ago
vinnas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
full of comedy circus today 😆 never ever imagined 😉 will update after some tym 😳 nw busy in ROFL 😆 ..
vinnas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
sony should give precaution scroll like it's fully fictional nothing related to epic at anywhere.watch with your own risk .dnt believe any bit of it ..

now coming to epi ---as usual starts with gg .then aswath .dussy and all came out from illusion. starts fight with real enemies..

the great vrish tired alot still offer poor abhi .dnt stop fight you have more arrows in pocket . abhi starts the tym dussy attacked abhi from back and starts fight .

vrish tired alot n leans on horse just then the telepathy starts btn fath n son .karn tells don't tire n retire son in war you have to face my encounters in this kurushetra .get up n fight .bhoom vrish ready for fight ..

after defeating dussy poor abhi have another to fight I think it's shalya who have the boon of dragging the energy from the ones who stands in front of him with anger ..ther fight continue ..omg abhi tired soo much .he need glucose first ..

dron fights with NS .ther mini convo is really nonsense to write like ther fight ..

bhishm .I feel by watching his expression in this war like he enjoying a picnic with his grand kids .nothing seriousness in his portrayal..

bhishm arj fights ..arj felt its becoming difficult to fight with pitamah .(like really ..)
kri says arj the amount of tym u fight with bhishm .that amount is credits for bhim to capture dury ...

bhim comes to dury n starts instigate how much tym u stand safe ther come n fight .I dnt know for this napunsak I take those oaths. blah .blah .

dury comes to fight .dhrut worries alot .dury beats bhim .black n blue n starts instigate more with shaku ..

finelly bhim getups and about to throw a big stone on dury .orders dury either surrender to yudi or ready to die ..shaku shouts bhishm for help ..

here comes the main comedy circus .
one by one comes like a climax in movie .

bhishm targets bhim .arj targets bhishm

dron targets NS
dd targets aswath

vrish targets yudi ..

all in one place in a circle I think ..instead of pistols thy using knives .arrows ...

precap --N says in pandav sibir ..vrish is the main obstacle in k army .have to do something to eliminate him ...


guenhwyvar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
Vrish is the main obstacle, not Bhishma or Drona 😆😆
Just have Abhi fight with him until Vrish tires out and goes into telepathic convo mode; and then DISHKIYAOON 😃 or ... TWANG
Edited by shyam09 - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".