Ishaan - Selfless, Mahan or something else?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

jhil

@jhillyarya

Sparkler

Posted: 6 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: chirpyhapibird

Audience ,mauli and malhotras know na he is a cheater.

But you told cheater father..

He must have cheated and worst person but as a father he never cheated. Even for misty also he did whatever was possible for him. So please don't tag him as cheater father.

Quote

looseseal

@looseseal

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: sweet_tania

I want to blame only mauli here . She failed to say No means No.

True.

Also people keep forgetting that she herself didn't want to tell Kunal the truth like Radhika suggested.

While Ishaan being so cool with everything bit too much but it is wrong to say he made her do it.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

FruitToasty

@FruitToasty

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: looseseal

I stated a trend (which is most people make excuse of Pari to bring MouNal together) and I think you also know that what I am saying is not untrue. So my point or (rhetorical) question was how is Mouli looking after her sautan's child and her cheating ex is any more real than Ishaan wanting to help Kunal (who is basically his sautan)? And how come one is not just accepted but also desired and demanded while the other unaccepted and even found shady by the same people?

Mauli's sautan = Nandini

Ishaan's sautan = Kunal

Ishaan accepting his sautan's daughter as his own is fine

Mauli accepting her sautan's daughter is as her own is fine too

Mauli is not helping Nandini, she broke all of her relationships with her sautan friend, but Ishaan takes his sautan Kunal's help to woo his future wife, he is very cordial with him... That's what I find weird, Mauli's reaction to Nandini vs Ishaan's reaction to Kunal...just think about it...

Lastly, if Ishaan wants to help his sautan, he should do it that's what I have written in my post that he should help him in his capacity not ask Mauli to do it, it's Mauli helping her ex husband not Ishaan... And if it's not possible for ishaan to help his sautan, he shouldn't expect Mauli to do it, it's not in his capacity to desire something like this

Edited by FruitToasty - 6 years ago

Quote

FruitToasty

@FruitToasty

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: sweet_tania

I want to blame only mauli here . She failed to say No means No.

Fair enough!!

She should stop being a pushover

Quote

looseseal

@looseseal

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: FruitToasty

Mauli's sautan = Nandini

Ishaan's sautan = Kunal

Ishaan accepting his sautan's daughter as his own is fine

Mauli accepting her sautan's daughter is as her own is fine too

Mauli is not helping Nandini, she broke all of her relationships with her sautan friend, but Ishaan takes his sautan Kunal's help to woo his future wife, he is very cordial with him... That's what I find weird, Mauli's reaction to Nandini vs Ishaan's reaction to Kunal...just think about it...

Lastly, if Ishaan wants to help his sautan, he should do it that's what I have written in my post that he should help him in his capacity not ask Mauli to do it, it's Mauli helping her ex husband not Ishaan...

Thats because Kunal didn't betray him like Nandini betrayed Mouli. Even the day he found out he was cordial with him because Mouli was cordial with him. Ishaan didn't didn't go looking for Kunal's friendship. Kunal offered and insisted that Ishaan take his help. Ishaan was indifferent towards him. Mouli was filled with pain, sadness and anger by Mandini's betrayal and yet her dying made such impact on her that she said she forgave her for everything. Other than the fact that Ishaan is in love with Mouli and its very weird for him to send her to her ex, him helping Kunal makes full sense, its only human thing to do.

Yes, he should have shown bit more pain and frustration that they have to do this, because apparently telling the truth isn't an option. but doing it in itself makes total sense for both Mouli's character and Ishaan's.

Quote

FruitToasty

@FruitToasty

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: looseseal

Thats because Kunal didn't betray him like Nandini betrayed Mouli. Even the day he found out he was cordial with him because Mouli was cordial with him. Ishaan didn't didn't go looking for Kunal's friendship. Kunal offered and insisted that Ishaan take his help. Ishaan was indifferent towards him. Mouli was filled with pain, sadness and anger by Mandini's betrayal and yet her dying made such impact on her that she said she forgave her for everything. Other than the fact that Ishaan is in love with Mouli and its very weird for him to send her to her ex, him helping Kunal makes full sense, its only human thing to do.

Yes, he should have shown bit more pain and frustration that they have to do this, because apparently telling the truth isn't an option. but doing it in itself makes total sense for both Mouli's character and Ishaan's.

Bold 1 - Ishaan knows Kunal through Mauli, he knows that kunal cheated on Mauli, Kunal doesn't have to hurt him, Kunal hurt someone he loves so much so its human to dislike people who hurt people you love. When KuNan cheated on Mauli, Radhika, Dida, Sweety disliked KuNan, they went on to sunao them for hurting her, KuNan didn't harm any of them, they harmed someone they love or like, it's human nature, even Sandhya disliked Nandini when she heard what they did. Chalo Ishaan does not dislike Kunal for what he did but taking his help to woo Mauli? I don't think this is real in any sense...

Bold 2 - Ishaan did take Mauli to the table Kunal was sitting in to have lunch after camp, Mauli was uncomfortable there too... Taking Kunal's help or not was Ishaan's decision, like it's Mauli's decision to help Kunal right?

To help someone is Mauli's nature but what struck me was that Dida practically begged Mauli to help Kunal on humanitarian ground and Mauli denied firmly, it's not her nature to deny helping someone on humanitarian ground then Ishaan took her to the side and convinced her. She did deny, she denied everyone, it must have been very difficult for her but she didn't stand her ground in front of Ishaan...

Quote

Charu

@Krinya

Trailblazer

+ 8

Posted: 6 years ago

#47

The most bizarre twist which leaves no room for any analysis. They must end the serial . Silsila badalte rishton ka was over with nandinis death. This is silsila daily soap twists ka.

Quote

Charu

@Krinya

Trailblazer

+ 8

Posted: 6 years ago

#48

Hypothetically speaking , it should be totally maulis call. Ishan may be her fiance but he cannot call the shots when it comes to mauli, she is still, not his wife. And suppose if he and mauli were married and kunal lost his memory, then too, ishan didnt have the right to tell her because its "maulis past" and she is the one to take decision . Ishan could have said " do as your heart say"

Quote

-poloenigma-

@-poloenigma-

Voyager

Posted: 6 years ago

#49

Originally posted by: FruitToasty

Mauli's sautan = Nandini

Ishaan's sautan = Kunal

Ishaan accepting his sautan's daughter as his own is fine

Mauli accepting her sautan's daughter is as her own is fine too

Mauli is not helping Nandini, she broke all of her relationships with her sautan friend, but Ishaan takes his sautan Kunal's help to woo his future wife, he is very cordial with him... That's what I find weird, Mauli's reaction to Nandini vs Ishaan's reaction to Kunal...just think about it...

Lastly, if Ishaan wants to help his sautan, he should do it that's what I have written in my post that he should help him in his capacity not ask Mauli to do it, it's Mauli helping her ex husband not Ishaan... And if it's not possible for ishaan to help his sautan, he shouldn't expect Mauli to do it, it's not in his capacity to desire something like this

Kunal is not Ishaan's sautan because Kunal has no relationship with Mauli. He is her ex husband, not current lover. Mishti is not ishaan's 'sautan's ' daughter for Ishaan because Ishaan has been in Mishti's life as a father since she was 3. Kunal came in Mishti's life yesterday. Kunal and Mishti don't have a father-daugter relationship. Mishti calls Ishaan her 'popsi' and calls Kunal, Dr Kunal.

Mauli accepting Pari is a big deal because Pari is the product of her ex husband and ex best friend's betrayal.

Ishaan met Mauli as a single mother and loved Mishti as his own daughter when Kunal was not even in the picture. Ishaan and Mishti have a relationship independent of Mauli. Kunal doesn't even come into picture because for Mishti, Ishaan is her father. On the other hand Mauli, is 'Mauli aunty' for pari, her friend's mother.

Mauli has sympathy for Pari.

Ishaan has fatherly love for Mishti.

That's the difference.

Edit : I think the relationship between Pari and Mauli is kind of like the relationship between Mishti and Kunal.

Mishti admires Kunal now only because he helped bring her mamma and popsi together.

Pari admires Mauli because as a motherless child she sees a motherly figure in Mauli and the CD from her mother plays a big role behind her behavior.

Basically Kunal-Mishti & Mauli-Pari don't have an authentic unconditional relationship.

The only unconditional, authentic relationships in this show are Kunal-Pari, Mauli-Mishti & Ishaan-Mishti

Edited by -poloenigma- - 6 years ago

Quote

FruitToasty

@FruitToasty

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#50

Originally posted by: -poloenigma-

Kunal is not Ishaan's sautan because Kunal has no relationship with Mauli. He is her ex husband, not current lover. Mishti is not ishaan's 'sautan's ' daughter for Ishaan because Ishaan has been in Mishti's life as a father since she was 3. Kunal came in Mishti's life yesterday. Kunal and Mishti don't have a father-daugter relationship. Mishti calls Ishaan her 'popsi' and calls Kunal, Dr Kunal.

Mauli accepting Pari is a big deal because Pari is the product of her ex husband and ex best friend's betrayal.

Ishaan met Mauli as a single mother and loved Mishti as his own daughter when Kunal was not even in the picture. Ishaan and Mishti have a relationship independent of Mauli. Kunal doesn't even come into picture because for Mishti, Ishaan is her father. On the other hand Mauli, is 'Mauli aunty' for pari, her friend's mother.

Mauli has sympathy for Pari.
Ishaan has fatherly love for Mishti.

That's the difference.

Edit : I think the relationship between Pari and Mauli is kind of like the relationship between Mishti and Kunal.

Mishti admires Kunal now only because he helped bring her mamma and popsi together.

Pari admires Mauli because as a motherless child she sees a motherly figure in Mauli and the CD from her mother plays a big role behind her behavior.

Basically Kunal-Mishti & Mauli-Pari don't have an authentic unconditional relationship.

The only unconditional, authentic relationships in this show are Kunal-Pari, Mauli-Mishti & Ishaan-Mishti