A take on the show

Page

Next Last

-kri-

@-kri-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 7 years ago

Well... to start with, i am new to this Show's forum but not to India-Forums...

This show impressed me at the first point due to the intriguing promo... The makers are clearly showing two faulty, guilty, deceitful, mentally corrupt persons as leads of the show... When such is the message from the initial promo, why this noise in the forum?

As a viewer, you vouched for this... It was clearly about a addictive extra marital affair right from the beginning... I am amazed at the posts that i see here. Nandini is the chudail, nagin and what not...Kunal happens to kamzor person,etc... I mean makers never said it the other way...😆

They are wrong and they know it too. In Indian soaps, its always about how good female lead or male lead is and how the whole conspires against them...But for once, we have two faulty persons who are responsible for their own issues. I am really looking forward to see what they are bringing out here...

Why is this forum even trying to analyse who is the better of the worst...😕 It would have been better if discussions are made on the human emotions that makers are trying to bring out. There is no point pointing out a mistake to be a mistake...

I am really looking forward to mature discussions... I had to bring this out of me since it was pricking me for long... Now, i am done. I am not commenting anywhere else apart from this post till i see mature discussions happening...

I am sorry had i offended anyone...

Quote

Frequent Posters

*Reemz*

@*Reemz*

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 7 years ago

You said they know they're wrong. But they seem so happy about it? There is no remorse or guilt. Sometimes Kunal makes that guilty face but he's back to smiling.

Kunal and Nandini don't CARE that they are wrong. I'm fine now with how the show is going because this week at least they clearly built up the impact the affair will have on Mauli. Their carelessness, their lack of basic respect towards the woman whom loves them the most has been so callous!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

akniti

@Nepofan

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

See you said you not new to india forum its a public forum any member can state his or her opinions..if anything wrong then Dm wl take actions..then why r complaining about noise on the forum? Its their opinion they discuss and you too have your own opinions.

Each show is interpreted in different way by different viewers..its not like makers mind and viewers mind same if so then many other show would not have gone offair. .like in sony tv show about 10year boy and 18 year gal love story..makers were trying to tell about responsibility of the gal towards boy but viewers didn't accept concept and show went offair within a month

Its forum members rights to criticise characters but withoit using derogatory comments...so if name calling of nandini as chudail etc is wrong then dm there to take action ..

See dear u said indian show s about full of goody goody female lead or male lead ..show like beyhadh were female lead was grey character but she was very much loved by viewers why coz she is not a worst female lead like nandini...so u cant say indian viewers cant take female lead as grey...but nandini amd kunal character is worst like never been such disgusting leads in tv shows...

U r questioning forum members right? Like who are they to analyse right or wrong? U r an experienced member of this forum...u know na members have right for all tht...

See i just answered for all your questions ...didnt mean to hurt your views...

Quote

-kri-

@-kri-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: *Reemz*
You said they know they're wrong. But they seem so happy about it? There is no remorse or guilt. Sometimes Kunal makes that guilty face but he's back to smiling.

Kunal and Nandini don't CARE that they are wrong. I'm fine now with how the show is going because this week at least they clearly built up the impact the affair will have on Mauli. Their carelessness, their lack of basic respect towards the woman whom loves them the most has been so callous!

That is the whole point of the show... They are in happy space since the victim of their actions is unaware of the same... i am no way justifying the leads... But i am looking forward to how the track opens up...

But forum is dominated with posts trying to prove how wrong Kunal Nandini are... That they are... I really want progressive posts apt to the show's mature concept. That's the point of my post...

Quote

amortentia15

@amortentia15

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Yes but who vowed not to criticise the characters for what they are!!! I dont think we were meant to wax lyrics on just how divine and beautiful their illicit relationship was... And the trajectory the lead characters have taken has become a major sore point for neutral viewers...

The promo did not show Nandini as Mauli's soul sister... So you see why we feel it all the more strongly...neither did the promo mention just how amazing Mauli was in all aspects...

Keeping aside the fact that the characters were portrayed as grey in the promos which is not the case here since they show zilch remorse or self reproach to have betrayed the person who has only been a benign influence on them, and are hapoily fooling her I think we have the right to call out something wrong when we see it...

I save a my best friend from getting killed...she repays me by sleeping with my husband...

I do everything that a wife should do in a marriage out of love, out of the commitment i have...My husband repays me by sleeping with my best friend... And continues with the affair deceiving me...

You see how I will feel... This is why the backlash... Because people synpathise with the character and no where did we vouch not to emoathise with Mauli's plight...

Thats exactly what is happening here...

Quote

amortentia15

@amortentia15

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: -kri-

That is the whole point of the show... They are in happy space since the victim of their actions is unaware of the same... i am no way justifying the leads... But i am looking forward to how the track opens up...

But forum is dominated with posts trying to prove how wrong Kunal Nandini are... That they are... I really want progressive posts apt to the show's mature concept. That's the point of my post...

The writers have not dealt with it in a mature way... There have been other shows whete EMA has been shown but the writing was top notch...

Here the characters are pretty despicable with no rhyme or reason as to why they are behaving the way they are...

Execution is shoddy...

Quote

-kri-

@-kri-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: akniti
See you said you not new to india forum its a public forum any member can state his or her opinions..if anything wrong then Dm wl take actions..then why r complaining about noise on the forum? Its their opinion they discuss and you too have your own opinions.

Each show is interpreted in different way by different viewers..its not like makers mind and viewers mind same if so then many other show would not have gone offair. .like in sony tv show about 10year boy and 18 year gal love story..makers were trying to tell about responsibility of the gal towards boy but viewers didn't accept concept and show went offair within a month

Its forum members rights to criticise characters but withoit using derogatory comments...so if name calling of nandini as chudail etc is wrong then dm there to take action ..

See dear u said indian show s about full of goody goody female lead or male lead ..show like beyhadh were female lead was grey character but she was very much loved by viewers why coz she is not a worst female lead like nandini...so u cant say indian viewers cant take female lead as grey...but nandini amd kunal character is worst like never been such disgusting leads in tv shows...

U r questioning forum members right? Like who are they to analyse right or wrong? U r an experienced member of this forum...u know na members have right for all tht...

See i just answered for all your questions ...didnt mean to hurt your views...

To make it clear, it was not a complaint... It was my take i.e., my opinion.

And my god... i am not questioning anyone... i am stating that they are analysing a proven fact which is leads are wrong...

Seriously, i am not questioning the right to post or right to comment. i have stated my general observation... The reason is cos this show gives ample space to have productive discussions... Dot

Quote

-kri-

@-kri-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: amortentia15
Yes but who vowed not to criticise the characters for what they are!!! I dont think we were meant to wax lyrics on just how divine and beautiful their illicit relationship was... And the trajectory the lead characters have taken has become a major sore point for neutral viewers...
The promo did not show Nandini as Mauli's soul sister... So you see why we feel it all the more strongly...neither did the promo mention just how amazing Mauli was in all aspects...
Keeping aside the fact that the characters were portrayed as grey in the promos which is not the case here since they show zilch remorse or self reproach to have betrayed the person who has only been a benign influence on them, and are hapoily fooling her I think we have the right to call out something wrong when we see it...
I save a my best friend from getting killed...she repays me by sleeping with my husband...
I do everything that a wife should do in a marriage out of love, out of the commitment i have...My husband repays me by sleeping with my best friend... And continues with the affair deceiving me...
You see how I will feel... This is why the backlash... Because people synpathise with the character and no where did we vouch not to emoathise with Mauli's plight...
Thats exactly what is happening here...

I like the way you put it there... This is called discussion which i missed here...

Coming to your reply, Nandini is doing a grave mistake. No doubts... But, somewhere, all three parties have been instrumental in this EMA.

Mauli is building a clinic at the cost of breaking her own house... Irrespective of Kunal and Nandini, Mauli is not the perfect wife too... Which makes the triangle interesting...

All three of them are flawed...

Kunal never felt otherwise before Nandini's entry because he never knew another facet of how a wife could be apart from Mauli... Given two choices, he leaned towards Nandini leading to this silsila. This is a classic situation... Unless you are put in a situation, you can never judge a person.

Kunal is not a bad human but he's a bad husband...

Nandini... So called weak character... She is the strongest... Who faced a heartbreak and is indulging in an affair which could again lead to a heartbreak... She will either lose Kunal or Mauli at the end or both... Her desperate need to be loved is driving her nuts...

Quite interesting. I hope makers do justice to the storyline

Quote

-kri-

@-kri-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: amortentia15

The writers have not dealt with it in a mature way... There have been other shows whete EMA has been shown but the writing was top notch...
Here the characters are pretty despicable with no rhyme or reason as to why they are behaving the way they are...
Execution is shoddy...

Little early to comment on execution for me. EMA has been dealt with before but not as here... They are the leads... It is quite a huge burden on their shoulders... They are good humans yet deceitful partners... Quite a catch 22 situation...

Flaws are bound to happen. Maybe, i can decide when the story unravels further...

Quote

amortentia15

@amortentia15

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: -kri-

I like the way you put it there... This is called discussion which i missed here...

Coming to your reply, Nandini is doing a grave mistake. No doubts... But, somewhere, all three parties have been instrumental in this EMA.

Mauli is building a clinic at the cost of breaking her own house... Irrespective of Kunal and Nandini, Mauli is not the perfect wife too... Which makes the triangle interesting...

All three of them are flawed...

Kunal never felt otherwise before Nandini's entry because he never knew another facet of how a wife could be apart from Mauli... Given two choices, he leaned towards Nandini leading to this silsila. This is a classic situation... Unless you are put in a situation, you can never judge a person.

Kunal is not a bad human but he's a bad husband...

Nandini... So called weak character... She is the strongest... Who faced a heartbreak and is indulging in an affair which could again lead to a heartbreak... She will either lose Kunal or Mauli at the end or both... Her desperate need to be loved is driving her nuts...

Quite interesting. I hope makers do justice to the storyline

I will respectfully disagree with your opinion on Kunal, Mauli and Nandini...

Nandini- according to me she is nowhere the atrongest character among the three... Mauli was the propelling force of positivity in her life...she is the reason N is out of the mess. If Mauli did not make an appearance in her life at the time she did Nandini would still have been shivering and quivering in fright because of Rajdeep... And now the same abused and tormented woman is having sex with her bestie's husband...leaves a very bitter taste...

For me she woukd have neen the strongest if she did not give in to her libido with her best friend's spouse...

Kunal- i would not blame him for falling out of love...though i domt exactly understand his reasons... My problem with him is because of the nincompoop he is... He is the antithesis of anything good in a human being... A bad husband cannot be a good human being... If you are atrocious to the person you've pledged to stay honest to and you cant i dont comsider him a good human being...

Mauli- you say she is building the clinic at the cost of her own marriage? I dont understand this point you are making so i dont know how to respond to that...

My outlook is that Kunal wanted to do philanthropic work which is why he left his thriving career and now Mauli is bearing the expenses of the entire household... Whereas he is having sex with her best friend... The clinic is right now nowhere in his mind... Speaks a lot about the person he is...

Mauki wanted to give kunaal a surprise...now since he apparently did not have mercenary issues at play when he quit I dont think how enabling him to achieve his dream of helping the poor and the needy could be a reason of her marriage crumbling...

Mauli is by far the strongest and the best character here according to me... I domt say she is not flawed its just that i find it so infinitesimal compared to these two cheating conniving people that I cant seem to understand the reasons why anyone would want to defend Nandini or Kunal...

Quote

1 2

A take on the show

Related Topics

Explore Topics