A bit over the top?

Page

Next Last

mjtruelegend

@mjtruelegend

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

Hi as I was wathing that scene where Dadaji was scolding Ishwar. He is right to be angry and has every right to rebuke him but I found that part where he said "I mourne you every year" a bit too over the top. I know what Ishwar did was wrong but to actually say that I found to be very harsh and not needed. He could have said that, he's forgotten him because of what he did and that he can not forgive and forget, but instead he said "haar saal main thera shrad mana ta hun". I found that to be too much. I am not saying whether its right or wrong, but I just can't digest that part. Now tell me mo you agree?

Quote

Frequent Posters

Shwetha

@Shwets1502

Achiever

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

it was harsh...and for me...Ishwar deserves it sheemu...
we dont know what the family went thru when Ishwar left...
dadaji must have gone thru so much humiliation

yes...dadaji stressed that a lot...bt thats how he feels towards Ishwar...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

keenu gill

@Keenu.G

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

i dun no di, but i think dadaji was angry at tht time. toh shayad gusse main nikal gaya hoga... 🤔

or mayb dadaji wanted to tell him how big his mistake is so he mourns tht he had son like him! so honestly i think he deserved such harsh response..

pata nahin.. but I guess i didnt notice it much.. so I dun think it bothered me much..

Edited by Keenu.G - 14 years ago

Quote

111192

@111192

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: mjtruelegend
Hi as I was wathing that scene where Dadaji was scolding Ishwar. He is right to be angry and has every right to rebuke him but I found that part where he said "I mourne you every year" a bit too over the top. I know what Ishwar did was wrong but to actually say that I found to be very harsh and not needed. He could have said that, he's forgotten him because of what he did and that he can not forgive and forget, but instead he said "haar saal main thera shrad mana ta hun". I found that to be too much. I am not saying whether its right or wrong, but I just can't digest that part. Now tell me mo you agree?

I disagree on this with you sheemu...dadaji was justified in his anger and in my opinion he was the star of the day for slapping BP and saying "main har saal tera shrad to karta tha par afsos ki main teri chita ko aag nahi laga saka"👏

Edited by 111192 - 14 years ago

Quote

Pratamesh

@Pratamesh

Sparkler

Posted: 14 years ago

Ya it was a bit harsh also BM must b hurt by this as it happend spontaenously infrnt of her

Quote

*Resham*

@*Resham*

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

Sheemu...I disagree with you on this..sorry dear...but we still dont know what pains did Kashyaps faced after Ishwar left them stranded...their hurts are justified..and so is babuji's anger...whatever he said he was right in his own way, IMO

Quote

428419

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

Sheemu di,I HAVE seen examples of Ishwar in daily life and how their parents treat them.Its always like the mother has a soft corner towards him but the father allthough has a soft corner towards him but appears to be rough and tough and say everything not out of anger but out of sadness and frustation.I am sure Dadaji is happy to see his beta after so many years..but after realizing what he has done..he has not left BM and their two children alone..he left his OWN parents and didnt have any attachment towards him(like the pen scene)..I guess whatever he gives Ishwar(what a sarcastic name😳)..chata laafa anything..I wont mind!😉but please dadaji...dont throw mangoes at him!😆

Quote

zackey_boy

@zackey_boy

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

dats the most harsh comment...I guess he said it so that Ishwar gets the point that he has no place in the Kashyap house

Quote

mjtruelegend

@mjtruelegend

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

I know what he did was wrong and bad, please I am not saying anything for Ishwar, I just looking at a point of view that when a person is still alive, isn't it too much to say "haar saal shrad mana ta hoon?". Yes what he did was terrible, but if he believed Ishwar to be Dead, then why does he allow BM to still adorn herself as Married lady. Isn't that contradictory?

Quote

mjtruelegend

@mjtruelegend

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: Shwets1502
it was harsh...and for me...Ishwar deserves it sheemu...
we dont know what the family went thru when Ishwar left...
dadaji must have gone thru so much humiliation

yes...dadaji stressed that a lot...bt thats how he feels towards Ishwar...

Of course I get all that. For me the best part was the slap. Now that he definitely deserves 👏, but I don't know I just thought that to be a too much.

Quote

1 2 3 4

A bit over the top?

Related Topics

Explore Topics