Does he deserve forgiveness? - Page 4

Originally posted by: madhu_d

Keenu you came up with an interesting discussion...

Thank you di 😃
Rounak and BP are 2 different personalities..

BP is more selfish..he has taken jhoot ka rasta to achieve what he wanted in his life. 4 him money is all and b coz of him d joint family was forced to suffer a lot , were forced to curtail all the enjoyments in their life.. if alok had not taken up the responsibility and had rano not a good natured person what would b the state of inder-panna & ilesh.??? when he is in state of loneliness he remembered his family that too after 20 years..i just cant stand this person..he does not deserve 2 b the member of Kashyap family..and i dont want him to b accepted by any one when he comes back.

Rounak is very different..he want everything to b perfect and he used to get all he wanted in life on his terms and conditions..he has not failed in any of attempts before...but when the situation reversed he couldn't bear his failures...moreover he was unable to c the suffering of panna as he loves her very much..and when panna told him that she is unable 2 show her effection in 2 same way as before..he crumbled...thought he has b com as an waste..and left d house... wanted to come back only after emerging victorious...and moreover he had savings which the family can get along to some extent..i think he had done mistake which can b rectified..but what BP did is unrectifiable...

Madhudi great explanation👏 i agree that raunak and BP are two different personalities and the reason behind them leaving their families were different too. BP was more selfish where Raunak's was frustation and anger on himself as he felt he's worthless! I too agree that only person who can have little chance of forgivness is him, lekin commitin suicide he's being selfish as well.. he didnt think of anyone in family did he.. ? and wht im thinking is the reason behind him realising the guilt of wht he did, is only because piya and her father.. wonder if they were not there, would he still have felt the same and return home to his family?

I dun know but it is rather open talk i think, its interestin to read thoughts of different people! 😃

Originally posted by: venture

Excellent post very thought provoking in an environment these days when cv,s are PROVOKING us to break our tv sets and laptops!!!!!

Thank you di atleast its reasonable thought provokin question😳[ i m glad] 😆
I am kind of disappointed here as Raunak and Panna,s track deserved some respect, some lime light, but on the contorary with this silly lead character, s funda it has bee treated like a filler where this track had some substance to it.

We all agree with this tht's CV's wasted this track when it was even better than Suhana BT and Ishaan's Amnesia track, it could have garnered lots of TRPs!
Any ways with what ever we got so far one thing for sure, Raunak and Eshwaar both would NOT change as they both are egoistic male - - g-!! for sure. Even if they are forgiven they will see it as there RIGHT , that's in my opinion seeing the characters behaviours so far.

Raunak, s situation was slightly different , agreed, but the impact is no less then BP ,s departure, but having said that an example comes into my mind where a CHORI is a chore wether for 10 rupees or 10,000 rupees in the eyes of laws, but the consequences could be different as a poor person, s last 10 rupees for his roti is way more important than a rich man, s 10,000.
Reasons were wrong in both cases , but BP , s reason had greater impact on more people directly attached to him. If Raunak would have killed himself then yes the devastation would be huge but atleast Panna would not have to live with this that Raunak ditched her and her children in the middle so casually as if some body get rids of junk from his drawer.
So if it was me in Panna,s place, I will not FORGET what Raunak did but might forgive with time but one thing for sure people like Raunak may feel for a while but will not change in the long run and Panna would remember this.

Thank you di for your explanation! i had same thoughts behind the reason i said none of them deserve forgiveness i jus didnt knw how to put this in words and you did it! 👏[ as always]!

I think panna will forgive him cauz of her in laws but will not forgive him herself so easily.. atleast i would love to see tht, mayb then he will realise wht he did.. This piya track is creating reasons for his acceptance bak in family.. lekin he doesnt deserve it.. wht he did was wrong, and i would be very happy if CVs handle it carefully and show the regret he feel and make him realise his mistake.. even though i knw men are me, esp when it comes to ego they wont change!
Eshwar Kyshap has no right to come back in there lives, he simply doesn't

Everyone is coming to same conclusion for him which is totally justified!

.