There is NO comparison between SC & IPK!! - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

86

Views

8.8k

Users

57

Likes

460

Frequent Posters

enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: Nkapoor3

Guys don't be harsh! Both shows are love stories! So what if fans of ippknd mention their show sometimes?


That's the point. It's not once or twice..SC has been going on for almost a month now, and it is STILL happening! And they don't MENTION their show, they COMPARE it with our show. That is the problem.


I know that this is a "controversial" issue 😆..but kya karoon yaar..mein actually mein irritate hoti hoon isse!
enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: Shreya-uktamil

Everyone who knows me on Indian Forum can vouch for the fact that I was a die hard fan of IPK but even I am tired of the comparisons.


IPK is different and Saraswatichandra is different - the only thing they have in common is that they are both love stories.

So just let IPK go and embrace Saraswatichandra😆


EXACTLY! Haha thank you! 😛 HAHA imagine what non-IPK fans must feel! 😆
enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: -X-x-X-



So according to you the TM shouldn't voice her opinions in fear of offending the IPK fans? :/
The IPK members have got to realise that yes they as a majority like IPK but that doesn't mean they can rule every damn place and bring that show in wherever possible! There are people in this forum who haven't watched IPK or chose not and came here for something new... Y'know maybe to discuss Saraswatichandra? I have seen a lot of these posts and about you, I don't know whether you actually haven't seen it or you chose not to but this person does have a point! Keep IPK stuff in its own forum, don't drag it to every possible place even if it has no relevance.


Thank you! We come here to discuss SC & how well the cast & crew are doing, not read about how much someone misses their other show, and well the cast & crew of that show were doing. Ofc, people are fans of IPK & I respect that, but I love this show, and I hope people start respecting that too 😃.
-Sush- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#74
Some one recommended this show to me...because the only Indian TV show I have been hooked onto in the past for any significant length of time (about 1 year) was IPK...Agreed despite its lack of a strong story line...I haven't watched SC yet.

But I came to the forum the other day, and found many IPK fans here...which is a good thing...because...
The comparison may only be anther way of saying...
IPK had me emotionally hooked
This is getting me emotionally hooked...
Hence the biggest similarity that matters to me is ...I like these love stories...
Edited by -Sush- - 12 years ago
enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: grapegirl

FINALLY someone made this post, yay!


I completely agree with you 100% about the annoying IPKKND references.😡 Yeah that show was good in the beginning, but it completely went down the drain, I mean chemistry of the leads don't just make a show, you have to have important secondary characters. IPKKND completely destroyed the secondary characters, that half of them actually had no lines and decided to leave the show.

Saraswatichandra is epic, I mean take todays episode saras and kumud screentime together was like 30 seconds, and it was amazing redardless. I love Kumud's dad, and the buaji is growing on me, I love kumari and everyone, the show is just so well rounded and put together. And come on the show has been on air for what, 3 weeks?...and looks at the TRPs!

Ah and I see you're a once upon a time fan, I love hook!!!

p.s. ooo sorry i didn't mean to bash, got a bit carried away😕


Ahaha YAY! Exactly! I'm not meaning to criticise the other show either, but this really got on my nerves! ..people were comparing even before SC started! I'm surprised to see that so many people agree TBH!

YES! OMG! Another OUAT fan! ME TOO! ..& Rumple 😛 ..& everyone else!

Thank you for commenting! 😃
enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: -barunoholic-


I hardly see any comparision post..okk...I am frm IPK forum..I have many frnds here bt they never bring IPK here in any post..I m using IPK here for the first tym..
n if few ppl r doin this,then dont tag the whole IPK fandom ..
We ppl r enjoying SC as much as u ppl r enjoying..
so I guess insecuirities lie in u

ps- i hv to go rude bt no option was left


Dude, you were almost threatening me not to make this post..you really think I have the insecurities?! Isn;t it more insecure that some people comment on every post they can about how much they love their old show, which went off-air quite some time ago?

And have you even read my post?! 😆 I specifically thanked people who like both shows, and never find the need to compare them. LOL. You're seriously only seeing what you want!
enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: GoldenSkies

Couldn't have put it any better! THANK YOU so much for this much needed post :) I don't normally comment on topics here just read them lol and tbh seeing so many comparisons to IPK had really been getting to me now especially since I follow QH too and we have enough comparisons there too but hey I can cut them some slack there cos it's the same production house (even though I still don't support those comparisons either!) but it's really bizarre to see comparisons between SC and IPK too cos there is absolutely NOTHING to compare! The PH, actors and storylines are all completely different, just the same channels and I understand IPK fans love the show but that doesn't mean your gonna compare shows which are poles apart! So please STOP THAT NOW :)

And I don't understand why some people are saying that the TM has called for a fight :S she hasn't bashed anyone and if people are mature enough then they will understand that not everyone is a fan of IPK .. I can understand that some fans are emotionally attached to the show and SaRun/ArHi and I can completely relate to that, since I'm very much attached to DMG and AR/KaJen even though the show is LONG over but I don't go around comparing DMG to every other show on tv cos frankly that just gets annoying for the fans of that show!

So please be considerate and stop these pointless comparisons and just enjoy the show :)

Once again thanks to the TM for this much needed topic <3


No, THANK YOU! 😃

Even I am a QH fan, and the comparisons there annoy me to no end too..but at least they have SOMETHING in common! And yes, even I was an ardent DMG fan, but if I started comparing everything to that, it would be so annoying for everybody else!

Thanks again for commenting! I just HAD to make this post! 😆
jakther7 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#78
Superb Post completely Agree with U
enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: -B.N.K-



SC is the best show i hv come across with in indian telly .. i was a ipk fan n i loved that show n cried for it.. but what ever is gone is dead n will never come back again ... talking about it n my new home is like making it dirty n all .. me n my frns never did something like that i never let them...

n i agree with u tm but ur post is not doing any good... if u want to stop something or change something ur the one should start that ... ur post is a eye opener but it also doing the same... comparing n offending other... stop talking about it ... the hv to forget abt ipk .. coz our SC is that good 😊


LOL seriously? You believe that I started this comparison by addressing this issue, which clearly so many of us can relate to? That's like saying people who protest against rape, indirectly cause rape!

..And maybe you aren't making those posts, but many others are, and clearly I am not the only one that has noticed that. Plus, I am not "dirtying your fandom" 😆 I am merely just asking some people who DO compare, to please stop :).
enchanted. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: -barunoholic-


if ppl r making posts outof this forum..thn whts ur problem😕
ofcourse u r nt bashing IPK..bt u r targetting IPK fandom..n thts why m going defensive else I gv 2 hoots to such useless posts which will only increase fights


Seriously did you NOT read the post?! We have a problem because some fans, in particular SOME IPK fans are making posts/commenting on posts on THIS FORUM, including others, where they COMPARE or share THEIR LOVE FOR IPK.. and THAT is "useless" ..not my post 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".