Yes she showed illogical things and she openly admitted that she does as audience want to see that and TRPs also reflect that.
Where as Rajan Shahi says something and does something. Also he also showed most cliche tracks which were already created and overdone by Ekta, such as : Illegitimate son,death of main leads and remarriages. So, he is no better or different than Ekta.
I will take Ekta anyday over RS as I am sure at the end of the serial main love story and leads will be together, and during the illogical tracks I can switch on and off them easily as I don't expect anything from her except the happy ending of serial with main love story.
Whereas RS promised a lot and fallen short of fulfulling them always at least regarding Ragvir.