IMO, sadi needs to be APOLOGETIC for some mistakes - Page 5

Poll

in your opinion, does sadi need to be shown to repent?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

5.9k

Users

17

Likes

128

Frequent Posters

pricey28 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: sweetkanu

@ pricey apologetic is better 👍🏼 yaar vaise ur post was thoroughly analyzed by u on sadi



thanks. and what do you mean by, "yaar vaise ur post was thoroughly analyzed by u on sadi". i mean, what point were you leading to/trying to make with that comment...??? just wondering yaar...😊
arjun_rocks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: pricey28



thanks. and what do you mean by, "yaar vaise ur post was thoroughly analyzed by u on sadi". i mean, what point were you leading to/trying to make with that comment...??? just wondering yaar...😊

i jst mean that u have putted sum gud points about her that's why i wrote.@ pricey But in poll i think there is still repent word😕😕
Edited by sweetkanu - 15 years ago
-Pallavi- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

sorry Pricey,
I really dont see any reason ...what Vasu has done is sin, what Alekh and Ragini have done are mistakes, but some of their mistakes became sin when they blamed Sadhna like being jealous...

Mamaji told a very important thing the other day...every person is judged by God by their Karma. Sadhna's Karma is so good that every person is coming back to her accepting their mistakes, without her actually doing anything to make them realise...she is a soul whose presence and goodness take away the sins from weak mentality but basically good people. Such is her character, wherever she steps, goodness and good luck follow..whether it is for Kaushi, Ragini, or for Alekh or now for Vasu...could anyone think that a character like Vasu can melt down..she acts like a sponge to take away any negative qualities of persons, who are basically good at heart.

People need to judge Sadhna not with a jealous mind, but with a pure and open heart.

Beautiful answer 👏
This to me is something truly positive.
-Pallavi- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: serialjunkie

Sadhna is a selfless character not a flawless character. This is what I feel. She is selfless to a fault. She wants to please everyone and do the right thing for everyone and in her earnestness she ends up making some not-so-stellar judgment calls. (like signing the divorce papers instead of seeking aalekh's support or mamaji's advice).

What bothers me most about Sadhna is that she has taken it upon herself to be a One-Woman-Crusader. She needs to stop making unilateral crusades and trust her family and loved ones a bit more to be of help to her.

I certainly didn't appreciate her taking off just like that w/o telling any of her loved ones. She tried to save Vinu from jail and she could have easily shared this with Ragini and sought her counsel.

I sometimes feel CTs have sketched her character to need constant reassurance of her self-worth and prove herself to be a worthy member of Sharma family by pulling off feats of heroism single-handedly. CTs need to stop making this character try to pull off heroic feats and have her as the balanced, sensible, loving an
d passionate character.

Do I feel she needs to repent? NO, I don't think her intentions were ever wrong. Her methods were, however, questionable.

One-Woman-Crusader - 😆
Actually, this is one of the reason, for so many fights which took place in this forum. People who like other actors/actress used to feel that Sadhna is the only one who fights for justice (though in her own way). But, it is nothing to do with any other actors/actress. Her character is sketched like that.
-Pallavi- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: chocolover89

The thing is Sadhna doesn't seem to think divorcing Alekh was wrong, nor has anyone made her feel it was wrong. Instead, everybody, gloried her "selfless" act, whereas with Vasu, Ragini, Alekh, plenty of people made them think what they were doing was wrong. Mamaji, Ragini, Ranvir, Alekh all glorified her act. If only they had once told her, you need to set your prorities straight, then things might be different.

I don't know if she really needs to repent for it, but she definitely needs to stop taking her relationship with Alekh for granted and make it a "bali ka bakra." I have no trust in Sadhna when it comes to her marrigae. I still feel, that if necessary, she will "sacrifice" it even when there are plenty of other options available as she, like serialjunkie so wonderfully put it, lieks to be a "one woman crusader."

@Bold - This will not happen again. Vasu is there to dominate (in a positive way) Sadhna now.
-Pallavi- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: suchitra_1

Ok no one is perfect. I have always maintained that.

But the real problem is something else...

When Ragi does a mistake, and repents, we forgive her

When Vasu does a mistake, and repents, we forgive her

hey eventually Indu will accept Anandwa and he will forgive indu too!

Just because Sadi and Mamaji are "too good to be true" characters , doesnt mean that there aren't people out there like them.

We just are sooo engulfed in this "give and take" world that, characters like sadana and mamaji are unbelievable so we want them to also be just like everyone.

The only fault of sadana is her own goodness. If she instead of helping everyone , just thought about herself more then I am sure , all the people who object Sadi in this forum will side with her and agree with her more.

Human beings tend to blame those who cause them to have guilt feeling.

Like, the saying, Zayada Harishchandra bannay ki koshih nahi karo...

etc.

Taunting...

I mean there is nothing wrong to be truthful and to such an extent that loosing everything for a principle he stood for but instead of taking him as an example , people now Mock his actions and say, bada aya harishchandr ki aulaad...

Or ,

as they tell to sadi: Mahan bannay ki koshish ...

So,

for me, Sadhana has done More good than her tinny mistakes. Which are also arguable ... thus , to compare her with other characters is totally wrong , she is NOT like Ragini, nor Ranveer, nor Alekh , nor Vasu nor inderjeet and not even Mamaji.

And no she does not have to repent for showing goodness.. this is like nick picking..

As one of the people in the thread said, She has apologized more than anyone in hte show. mujhe maaf kardijie Alekh ji,
mujhe maaf kerdijiye mummyji

Mujhe maaf kerdiji papaji

Mujhe maaf kerdijiye mamiji

Mujhe maaf kerdijiye jiji

Mujhe maaf kerdijiye Ranveerji

Mujhe maaf kerdijiye mamaji

and ofcourse she forgives everyone,

Everyone including Naveen and Avni..

so what else is needed?


Well said, Suchitra 👏
gilmores thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 15 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111



Just watch the video again, Sadhna said not "their love"..she said "her love"..she said "mere pyar kabhi kaam nahin honga".

Either way, if her love wasn't going to die, then why divorce her husband? What I am saying is her reason to divorce had nothing to do with Alekh. It was all about Kaushi. When it comes to something as huge as divorce, the decision needs to involve ONLY husband-wife. You do not divorce your spouse because of your family or his family.
gilmores thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 15 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: reguser

@Bold - This will not happen again. Vasu is there to dominate (in a positive way) Sadhna now.

I hope so, but I just don't trust Sadhna at all to not sacrifice Alekh for another problem.
gilmores thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 15 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

For Alekh's good future, Sadhna can sacrifice anything. Though it was ultimately shown she signed the divorce paper, I feel anyway that was going to a divorce only, if Ranveer had not made Alekh realise..Mamiji's operation was included more to make Kaushi repent.

To become a good wife, one needs to become a good human first. There is no doubt about Sadhna being a good human. Alekh has reached such a phase, where he respects Sadhna as a human and takes pride to have her as his wife, just because of Sadhna's good deeds.
When Alekh gave his answer to Sadhna and Sdahna left RH, what I liked that she never cashed on that and maintained their relationship in a dignified manner...if one remembers her lyrics of Dil janiye when Sadhna used to see Alekh-Malllika relationship...for me, a man who accepts a second lady within few hours of breaking marriage should repent more...


as Suchitra said, what ever Sadhna like people do, they can never be treated as good...

But just because Alekh takes pride in that doesn't mean that we, the viewers, must also. And sacrifices of any kind in ANY indian show are glorified, regrdless of whether they ar right or not. @bold
And he has repented! He left his house, money, luqxuries, everything, slept on a bench, worked so hard to get a job just for her!
And about the divorce, well then atleast, it would have been a divorce for the right reasons, ie one involving both spouses, not some external person. Then Alekh-Sadhna would have divorced because they cannot be together, not because Sdahna decided to use Alekh as a scapegoat to save her Mami's life when she clearly had other options.
Edited by chocolover89 - 15 years ago
pricey28 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#50
@choco: read all your posts, and once again: 👏👏👏👏👏👏

@sweetkanu: but unfortunately, i can't edit/change the poll question. however, i have edited the thread title 😉

Edited by pricey28 - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".