Worst sufferer is Ranveer's character now... - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

66

Views

5.6k

Users

18

Likes

96

Frequent Posters

SPN_JD_Addicted thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#41
Bani,it happened before(sorry to say this again in the rift track) cos it was needed for the story and its happening again!I guess once everyone goes back to the RV house Ranvir might go back to his normal self!
arjun_rocks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

Instead of showing that, if the director could show that all three were held tightly by the neighbours, that would have made more meaning...

I dont understand why we cant have a healthy discussion, I mentioned in the opening post thats its a problem of the script and direction and not Rgaini. When someone points out this sort of mistakes, instead of fighting and finding fault with each other, the best part is to write in the blog in a polite way that this was not inappropriate for the character of Rgaini...so that the team knows how diligently we follow the show and that we are not without brains.

we are just having a discussion...

@ Bani yes that would have been more meaningful and we can have healthy discussions over that but some posts here r admonishing somthing else of ragini's chracter.It is showing ragini back to square one .
Sorry to say but still i can say holding his husband is not a big deal here .
Edited by sweetkanu - 15 years ago
Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#43
Anyone who understands Sadhana's character would know that she will never let Alekh go into the fire, she would rather go herself. Another point, Sadhana heard Alekh saying that how would he survive if something happens to his mother. So she must have gone to save Vasu for her Alekhji.

As for Ragini holding on to Ranveer, it was her natural reaction. She does that in pretty much all the scenes. I think she does that for her own moral support than anything else.

Alekh couldn't free himself to save Vasu but when he will know that Sadhana is inside, I am sure no one can stop her hero to save her. Does it mean that his love for Sadhana is stronger than Vasu ? Cvs just have to show Sadhana saving Vasu and Alekh saving Sadhana. It seems end result matters the most to them than a proper script.
serialjunkie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

I feel that the worst sufferer now is my favourite character, Ranveer. New Creatives have just lost the main issues of Ranveer's character, which made Ranveer so loveable. Initially, in order to prove Anand smarter, they were sort of showing Ranveer dumb. Today was another bad day for Ranveer. The character who always could sense things so well, whether his "zid" to meet Sdahna in the jail, anticipating something must be wrong with her or his ability to identity his brother's "tarap" for Sadhna or tackling Ragini in a warm way during the rift track or leaving the house as a sort of protest. Creatives just are spoiling his basic character.

Another thing, which I noticed today and such a heavy mistake by the director...when the fire set in, did anyone see Ragini was holding back Ranveer, so as to not get inside...what an error in direction? it gave a completely different meaning. One hand, they were showing Rgaini is crying for Mummyji and on the other hand, she is holding Ranveer back...do not the directors proof read ?



@bold - i think Ragini did not stop Ranvir because she was selfish or trying to "save" or "hang-on" to her husband or because they did not feel strong enough for mummyji, it suicidal to jump into an uncontrolled fire and Ranvir is not a professional who knows how to fight fire and save someone. I think it was quite sensible, otherwise, two lives would have been lost instead of one.

What they should have shown was to have Ragvir join the neighbors in throwing buckets of water to control the fire. What I felt was an error in direction was that they showed Ragvir freeze in place while the others were trying extinguish the fire.


Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#45
I dont write much about Ragini, because what I try to state about her, no one understands...I try to point out the flaw in the script, not about Rgaini...screen space is not important, what is important is a proper track and direction.
Ragini is no Avni or Malti, Ragini is Ragini, her quality is way higher than an ordinary girl, esp. when creatives are trying to project that, the girl who can do much to unite mother with sons, that proves her true feelings...creatives should take utmost care to sketch the character of Ragini now, paying attention to minute detail
its true she can hold her husband back for his protection only....but the script actually wanted to show that the neighbours are holding all three, but just misdirected it...its a flaw of the script, which I am over and over trying to point out/...they are just sketching this track somehow..
Now I am not sure, if you are thinking I am sort of trying to demean Ragini...no way... pls find many posts of mine, where I criticise very badly Sara Khan, esp. as regards to her dresses..and even Alekh...
dont u think if the director had shown all three are tightly held back by neighbours, that would have been more meaningful,...
-SalShah4eva- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: reguser

May be you r right. Ragini cant send Ranvir inside that house. But, it would have been better if CTs show us that all three were held tight by the neighbours.

both rannu and allu is vasu son
so they have to show them especially
how can sons be quiet n stay outside when their mom is inside..
serialjunkie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: --Anu--

Anyone who understands Sadhana's character would know that she will never let Alekh go into the fire, she would rather go herself. Another point, Sadhana heard Alekh saying that how would he survive if something happens to his mother. So she must have gone to save Vasu for her Alekhji.

As for Ragini holding on to Ranveer, it was her natural reaction. She does that in pretty much all the scenes. I think she does that for her own moral support than anything else.

Alekh couldn't free himself to save Vasu but when he will know that Sadhana is inside, I am sure no one can stop her hero to save her. Does it mean that his love for Sadhana is stronger than Vasu ? Cvs just have to show Sadhana saving Vasu and Alekh saving Sadhana. It seems end result matters the most to them than a proper script.



@bold - I completely agree! Sadhna was so agitated when Aalekh got a small cut on his finger while cooking and was visibly upset. She would never let Aalekh jump into an inferno and would rather jump in herself.
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: KiNnY-pArTnEr

both rannu and allu is vasu son

so they have to show them especially
how can sons be quiet n stay outside when their mom is inside..

did u see Vasu never even uttered Ragini's name, (leave Sadhna'), she was only saying Ranveer and Alekh are inside. Ragini is the one to make her realise her feelings for her sons...but she never thought that Ragini could be also inside...I understand her not taking Sdahna's name, as she hates Sadhna...
anyways, Ranveer and Alekh are her own sons and Rgaini is after all, Sharmaji's daughter...these are small incidents but speaks a lot about a character
serialjunkie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

I dont write much about Ragini, because what I try to state about her, no one understands...I try to point out the flaw in the script, not about Rgaini...screen space is not important, what is important is a proper track and direction.
Ragini is no Avni or Malti, Ragini is Ragini, her quality is way higher than an ordinary girl, esp. when creatives are trying to project that, the girl who can do much to unite mother with sons, that proves her true feelings...creatives should take utmost care to sketch the character of Ragini now, paying attention to minute detail
its true she can hold her husband back for his protection only....but the script actually wanted to show that the neighbours are holding all three, but just misdirected it...its a flaw of the script, which I am over and over trying to point out/...they are just sketching this track somehow..
Now I am not sure, if you are thinking I am sort of trying to demean Ragini...no way... pls find many posts of mine, where I criticise very badly Sara Khan, esp. as regards to her dresses..and even Alekh...
dont u think if the director had shown all three are tightly held back by neighbours, that would have been more meaningful,...



@bold - that was not my intention at all

I was referring to the directional approach as well, and sharing that the approach taken by directors may be misunderstood as selfishness on Ragini's part, but the truth is her reaction is sensible in that circumstance.
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: serialjunkie



@bold - that was not my intention at all

I was referring to the directional approach as well, and sharing that the approach taken by directors may be misunderstood as selfishness on Ragini's part, but the truth is her reaction is sensible in that circumstance.

sorry, it was not directed at you in any way...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".