Worst sufferer is Ranveer's character now... - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

66

Views

5.6k

Users

18

Likes

96

Frequent Posters

SPN_JD_Addicted thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: --Anu--

Anyone who understands Sadhana's character would know that she will
never let Alekh go into the fire, she would rather go herself. Another
point, Sadhana heard Alekh saying that how would he survive if something
happens to his mother. So she must have gone to save Vasu for her
Alekhji.



As for Ragini holding on to Ranveer, it was her natural reaction. She
does that in pretty much all the scenes. I think she does that for her own moral support than anything else.



Alekh couldn't free himself to save Vasu but when he will know that
Sadhana is inside, I am sure no one can stop her hero to save her. Does
it mean that his love for Sadhana is stronger than Vasu ? Cvs just have to
show Sadhana saving Vasu and Alekh saving Sadhana. It seems end result matters the most to them than a proper script.


RagVir part,so agree!Even we saw her holding on to his collar during that kulfi scene.
sonya85 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#52
I wanted to watch it before commenting. But i'm sorry, after watching it, it is quite dissapointing the WAY she holds him back. It sought of makes the fact that she's screaming 'mamaji!' slightly insencere. It's kinda like, ''i'm so sad and sorry you 're in there mamaji, but my husband's not going back in there for you'' 😕. So yeah, CT's could have sketched that better in my view. They should have shown ragini trying to run in there with them.
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: sonya85

I wanted to watch it before commenting. But i'm sorry, after watching it, it is quite dissapointing the WAY she holds him back. It sought of makes the fact that she's screaming 'mamaji!' slightly insencere. It's kinda like, ''i'm so sad and sorry you 're in there mamaji, but my husband's not going back in there for you'' 😕. So yeah, CT's could have sketched that better in my view. They should have shown ragini trying to run in there with them.

its a total insincerity in the part of the director..especially for a person like Ragini, who did so much to unite mother and son..
what the director wanted to show, he could not..that the three are caught tightly by neighbours and hence could not go in to save Vasu, whereas Sadhna was not amidst the neighbours, so she could find a way...
Edited by Omshanti1111 - 15 years ago
SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

I feel that the worst sufferer now is my favourite character, Ranveer. New Creatives have just lost the main issues of Ranveer's character, which made Ranveer so loveable. Initially, in order to prove Anand smarter, they were sort of showing Ranveer dumb. Today was another bad day for Ranveer. The character who always could sense things so well, whether his "zid" to meet Sdahna in the jail, anticipating something must be wrong with her or his ability to identity his brother's "tarap" for Sadhna or tackling Ragini in a warm way during the rift track or leaving the house as a sort of protest. Creatives just are spoiling his basic character.

Another thing, which I noticed today and such a heavy mistake by the director...when the fire set in, did anyone see Ragini was holding back Ranveer, so as to not get inside...what an error in direction? it gave a completely different meaning. One hand, they were showing Rgaini is crying for Mummyji and on the other hand, she is holding Ranveer back...do not the directors proof read ?

@Bold: This is not an error at all, but very natural reaction.........
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: farislove

@Bold: This is not an error at all, but very natural reaction.........

I too understand this can be a natural reaction, then when they are trying to establish/show Ragini as generous and an altruist character, this is a time to make her character strong...the creatives should conver every half chance to full chance for this endeavour...
taral83 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: reguser

May be you r right. Ragini cant send Ranvir inside that house. But, it would have been better if CTs show us that all three were held tight by the neighbours.

I think this would have been the best solution to show the what they were trying to show. I have not seen the episode, but on the basis of what you wrote and others wrote, seems like Ragini didn't want to send her husband in to save his mother because she didn't want to loose TWO people she loved. Though there is nothing wrong in that, its a bit weird. That happens alot though in movies. Where loved ones are caugh in flames and other family members hold on to their loved ones so that they don't go jumping in the fire to save their family. Though it might look selfish, its not. By trying to go save them, they might also loose their life. Sadhna running in to help Vasu is actually just to prove the point to Vasu how much Sadhna cares and loves Vasu. its for the character of Vasu, no one else. Sadhna I don't think went jumping in because she didn't want Alekh to jump in but because it was a reaction in panic. Whatever the case maybe. I agree with reguser, that the neighbors should have help back all of them and one should have gotten loose and ran towards the burning house. It would have shown equal love and care towards Vasu. CTs should start thinking harder.
Edited by taral83 - 15 years ago
Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: taral83

I think this would have been the best solution to show the what they were trying to show. I have not seen the episode, but on the basis of what you wrote and others wrote, seems like Ragini didn't want to send her husband in to save his mother because she didn't want to loose TWO people she loved. Though there is nothing wrong in that, its a bit weird. That happens alot though in movies. Where loved ones are caugh in flames and other family members hold on to their loved ones so that they don't go jumping in the fire to save their family. Though it might look selfish, its not. By trying to go save them, they might also loose their life. Sadhna running in to help Vasu is actually just to prove the point to Vasu how much Sadhna cares and loves Vasu. its for the character of Vasu, no one else. Sadhna I don't think went jumping in because she didn't want Alekh to jump in but because it was a reaction in panic. Whatever the case maybe. I agree with reguser, that the neighbors should have help back all of them and one should have gotten loose and ran towards the burning house. It would have shown equal love and care towards Vasu. CTs should start thinking harder.



Taral, Sadhana didn't save Vasu because she loves her MIL so much. She went inside for her Alekh. Alekh was so desparate to save his mother and he was standing very close to the door, but 2-3 people were holding him very tightly. Sadhaha didn't want Alekh to get hurt, so she goes into the house and no one sees her. She saves Vasu and throws her out of the house. As soon as Vasu is out, she tells the trio that Sadhana is inside. You must see how ALekh jumps into the fire like a hero and saves her.
Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: farislove

@Bold: This is not an error at all, but very natural reaction.........



I agree. Ragini didn't even try to run behind Ranveer and stop him when Ranveer wanted to go inside the house for his bhaiyaa.
taral83 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: --Anu--



Taral, Sadhana didn't save Vasu because she loves her MIL so much. She went inside for her Alekh. Alekh was so desparate to save his mother and he was standing very close to the door, but 2-3 people were holding him very tightly. Sadhaha didn't want Alekh to get hurt, so she goes into the house and no one sees her. She saves Vasu and throws her out of the house. As soon as Vasu is out, she tells the trio that Sadhana is inside. You must see how ALekh jumps into the fire like a hero and saves her.

aw our Alekh and hero...lol
I still think it would have been better if the neighbors just help them all tight.......I mean what is this lets jump in the fire game....thats stupid.......first Vasu is stuck...then Sadhna goes in to save her...Vasu comes out...but now Sadhna is stuck.....so then Alekh jumps in like hero to save his lady love......then one will get injured int he process...so forth.........I find it dumb.......It could have been simple............Vasu stuck...........all foursome are outside...screaming their heads of "MOOOMMMM" "mUmmyji"....while the neighbors hold on....Sadhna gets loose....and runs straight in........saves Mummyji but injures herself.....Vasu feels bad and changes.......simple! lol. 😆
SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

I too understand this can be a natural reaction, then when they are trying to establish/show Ragini as generous and an altruist character, this is a time to make her character strong...the creatives should conver every half chance to full chance for this endeavour...

If they show Ragini doing something else like letting Ranvir to go in, it would look very illogical from her side..........

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".