Parikshits Reasoning

Teesha thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
Parikshit feels that had he n Gayatri went along with Shubh they wud have supported his wrong doing? Can anyone pls explain why? As far as I remember, Shubh didnt say "Ma Pa cum with me cus Im right" rather he said "Maa Paa cum with me cus there is no place for u either in this house" He said that seeing n being aware of the fact how Anusha treated them. He asked them to cum along not becus he needed their support but becus they needed to b respected rightly n live a peaceful life which they r not getting at all with Anusha around.
Parikshits reasoning of letting Shubh go alone was so like...errm not appropriate. I have heard n seen parents guiding kids when they r on the wrong path rather then leaving them alone to realize their mistake.

Yeh toh Shubh ka balha ho ke he realized long before otherwise I dont think anyone wud find their way right by being left alone without the right guidance.

Shubh knws the difference btwn wrong n right n that is not the point. All he needs is a little understanding n support. They cud have heard him out, n tried understanding but one after the other his ppl jus pushed him away.

If Parikshit believes that by going with Shubh they wud have shown he is right then by living with Karthik they r showing he is right. If kids must b left alone to realise their mistake n repent then Par-Gayu shud have left Karthik at first cus no matter wat Shubh has done he has never insulted their thoughts n beliefs like Karthik has many times.

n wat bothers me still is..They continue to remember that he is on the wrong path but they dont try thinking how he wandered off? Mayb sumthing happened? Instead of slapping him n insulting him, Parikshit shud have asked him y he chose the way he did? What led him to it? Chalo lets put that aside but how cum neither of his parents realized how Shubh stood up for them?? More than going on abt wat Anusha did to him, he made Karthik aware of the fact of how poorly Anusha treats them. Tab toh uska saaht dena chahiya tha. Had I been in Parikshits place I wud have been like "u want to kick ur brother out, kick him out but not becus he cant stand ur wife or u but becus wat he did was wrong" How cud they let Karthik kick him out jus becus Karthik cudnt stand a word against Anusha? I remember Karthik clearly said "Agar tumhe meri biwi or mujhse itni hi takleef hai toh nikal jaao yaha se. abhi ishi waqt"
If all this is suppose to b a lesson for Shubh then is Shubh suppose to also realize to keep shut even tho his parents r being tortured, insulted?
I have stood by Parikshit everytime he disagreed with Karthik but his reasoning of not supporting Shubh still doesnt go thru my head well!!
Comments?
Edited by rajeev4aamna - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

561

Users

3

Frequent Posters

herakhan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

yaa....i had d sameee doubt!!.....I understand par doesnt want to become a burden on shubh but punishing him by leaving him alone is utter nonsense!!!.......

I personally think kartik is worse dat shubh!...Atleast shubh knows wht he is doing is wrong and is trying to get out of the mess as fast as possibe!!...but Kartik, he doesnt consider black marketing wrong!!!!!!!????.........he justifies himself by saying that "aaj kal aisa hi chalta hai!!"....wht kind of an explanation is dat??......😕
I think Par shud have slapped kartik as well!!....its not fair!!!!...
but really, i want to know what did d creative team mean by saying that children shud be left alone when they make a mistake???......
jasmine_anih thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
I think they are drawing a line in the sand.
Though shubh's reasoning for getting in to underworld is because of cirmcumstances...he needs to get out. His parent's have always saved him and sheltered him when he has done something wrong.
But the work he is doing is put his life in danger everyday and he will limit his future by doing so. He needs to take responsiblity for his actions and learn to handle himself, he is old enough. His parents feel as long as they are with Shubh, he will not grow up.
Though Karthik is rude and jerk, he is not putting himself or his family in immediate harm. If shubh's parent's had gone with Shubh, shubh would still have to provide for a family, making him more vunerable to the underworld.
Though my children are young, I really appreciated the two ends of the conversation between Parkishat and Gayitri when they were discussing wether or not to go with Shubh. that is really what parent's go thru. I also think Gayitri wanted Shubh to know he is loved but he needs to work out his problem.
As far as Karthik goes, his problem may or may not be worked out it is really dependent on him.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".