ShaunSA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
That's what happens when parents marry babies off. Aham, gopi, jigar, rashi. All basically children who have no sign of maturity or adulthood. Why do parents do this? Or is it just a continuation of that abhorrent practice of child marriage which still seems to take place with primitive cultures?

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

2k

Users

9

Likes

77

Frequent Posters

Aymee thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I don't get it either Ashwin.
I guess for some parents they think since they did it and survived that their children should be able to handle it also.
It could be that the girl's family wants to "get rid" of their daughters soon and for the boy's family, they need a free servent.
Likely nowaday, some parents are getting some sense and are not forcing the children get married at a young age.
suk19 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Ashwin parents are complicated especially indian ones, mine included, parents need to live their lives they had fun in their day n age so now it comes down to their children they want us to babysit them because they have done so much for us we have to repay them back. ideally if they get this right let the children live their lives let them go out in the world make a name for them selves let the children think about their children. i am not saying abandon your parents but to have a relationship where rather than the child being suffocated to let them be free let them have fun let them be responsible visit your parents go n stay weekends with them but let the children make their own decisions not theirs.
i have said to my girls its your life after you leave my home me i am here will always be here until god takes me i dont want to be a burden to my child neither to i want my child to be a burden on me i want them to be successful make a name for themselves so i can feel proud
Aymee thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Well said Suk.
What I don't understand is that why do our Indian culture and other cultures thinks women are such a burden for a family if she is not married within a certain age?
And how do our parents knows which person is best for us as a life partner. We are not talking about school projects where the teacher pick out your partner, we are talking about choosing someone for the rest of your life. They know when it is the right time and with who?
Ahem (though he has be a jerk recently) got lucky with Gopi but Jigar didn't with Rashi. That is what I don't understand about arranged marriages and marrying at a young age. I am not suggesting love marriage is best solution but it is not better than arranged marriage either.
Edited by Aymee - 13 years ago
aris22l thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Ahemji is an old man. If he hasn't grown up till now, he never will. Gopi is more mature than him and she is the youngest of the lot.
Xarina thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
"We gave you the breath of life
Therefore we exercise our right to rule over you.
We will decide what is right and what suits us and society.
Your hopes and aspirations are meaningless and no more."
Imagine if something like that was said to you?
Unfortunately, there are plenty of parents who still hold the above view, consider their daughters a burden, marry them off to a man with whom they have nothing in common and strangle any chance of them leading a normal married life. Pile on top of that, if you will, the disapproving looks, the, we have washed our hands of you attitude when the inevitable hits the fan and you have a snapshot of what some parents are like.
Shaun, I know that this has deviated from your question. Sorry.
ShaunSA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Nai nai xari! It all falls under the discussion lol. Reminds me. I was told in mauritius that a boy or girl will only leave home on marriage and never before. Fortunately in sa the kids pretty much move on or out after college. Although some never leave home. And Its becoming more common for couples to live together a few years before marriage too. So common that no-one even comments when it happens lol. Having said that i think of my cousin. Who recently went and got her daughter engaged two years before she even left school. Oof the whole family was mad about that! Hopefully my niece wisens up in college and sends the boy packing.
Xarina thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: ShaunSA

Nai nai xari! It all falls under the discussion lol. Reminds me. I was told in mauritius that a boy or girl will only leave home on marriage and never before. Fortunately in sa the kids pretty much move on or out after college. Although some never leave home. And Its becoming more common for couples to live together a few years before marriage too. So common that no-one even comments when it happens lol. Having said that i think of my cousin. Who recently went and got her daughter engaged two years before she even left school. Oof the whole family was mad about that! Hopefully my niece wisens up in college and sends the boy packing.

You have an enlightened family. You are lucky and I hope your niece makes decisions which are right for her and not bend to the will of your cousin. Different cultures and communities have different values and outlook. Here in the UK for many years it was said that as soon as a child turns 18 they can leave home and start making their own way in the world. Marry who they want within reason and live their life their way. But the south asians are not the only ones to marry their children off at an early age and for them to leave home only after marriage. Greek and Greek cypriot girls are married off between the ages of 16-18, the travelling community, also known as gypsies or romanys practise this too as is the norm with some parts of the middle east and south east asia. The difference being is that in the middle east and asia the girl is still not given a choice. Culture demands that she is a silent party to what is going on. There is a call to make child marriages illegal, as you are no doubt aware, but because it involves young girls, poverty and tradition it is not being dealt with head on.
-Nafisa- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Parents normally get the girl engaged at a young age, it's a strategy they employ when they know the girl is still under they thumb (still listens to the parents and would not argue against it), so when the girl is still a teenager and in high school, get them engaged already, the prettier the girl the easier to get her off your hands...😳. Marriage soon after school, girls are seen as burdens but we know differently, when the parents are ill, homemaking skills (cleaning, cooking, all the crochet, sewing skills) it all counts for nothing to them until they don't have a daughter then they realise it. Then they want they son married quickly to bring a daughter-in-law to do all these things for them. So it's wrong to think this sex of child is more valuable then the other.

All because men bring home the money to buy everything in the home.

Going back to why girls get married earlier possibly as we are looked after, the man earns the money, and are supposed to attract that man, we need to be married young, when the looks are still there and you are healthy enough to work and also to give healthy babies (don't kill me for stating this please).

Things are changing where women want to be the breadwinners too. Go out and work, but society is finding it hard to adjust to this I think, because kids go to school and the teacher and other kids ask, who made your lunch today, I did it myself or the nanny did it for me and it's a big deal, the in-laws also from a different generation wouldn't want to hear that. So it ends up the woman doing the homemaking and earning the money, therefore double work...making the woman tired all the time and cranky.

So what is better to choose to get married to a modern man with modern in-laws that will accept you will have a career and won't do the homemaking work or marry your parent's wishes earlier to an old fashioned family do the homemaking, forget career and just stay home...look after your kids and hopefully you will do a good job and they will look after you in your old age and you won't miss the retirement cheques.😳


Xarina thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
I understand what you are saying Nafisa. But define 'modern' man. Is this the same modern man who will proudly tell all around him that he is enlightened and that his wife goes out to work too, but once inside the house he will sit with his feet up. His excuse. He has had a hard day at work. But his wife has been out to work as well and had just as hard if not much harder day at work and then come home to her second job. Why does not this modern man think that if he gets up and helps then the household chores would be done in no time and he would have a much calmer wife. If the wife cooperates and goes out to work to earn money to help with the household bills then surely should she not expect the same consideration from her husband. Whichever way you look at it, girls get the raw deal from parents to in laws to husbands. God only knows when it will change.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".