Does Ameer deserved max marks?? - Page 6

Originally posted by: rock&roll

😊

After ur statement,I actualy went back and listened to many of his performances again 😊....Th boy is really superb..Hs harkats/murkis are gr8,almost never falters on sur.Typically,I wld not have been able to find a single minus point with him,but since I was looking with a critic's eye,I noticed the following.

Next to lyrics,his weak point is taal.Sonuji commented that his taal was not correct in Saaware.Also listen to 'O jaana' .He makes mistakes with Taal quite a bit.He kinds of rushes up the song,ie,makes the rhythm slightly faster over a period of time.....He does this in the mukhda and in the alaap...Also when he starts the first line 'O jana',he starts on the wrong beat.He shld've started it a second late.But this gets covered up since the musicians are good and they adjust accordingly.

Saw him make a slight mistake in Sur once-in the antara of Chakke pe chakke.He picked it up at the wrong place and stopped(realised his mistake).The musician dada then played it in the right place for him and he picked it up.

But these are like nit picking for the sake of it.He is basically very good.Needs to work on the lyrics and taal a li'l more.And as,Gopalbhai, had pointed ,he is probably too playful and takes singing too lightly.He needs to get more serious abt his talent..Then the sky is his limit 😊

R&R, Simply excellent very well analyzed. The sky is his limit .

Originally posted by: AznDesi

Thanx for bringing it up Bob da and Rock n Roll bhai it's a she.😆

wanted to avoid it but cudn't😆😆

Originally posted by: Qwest

R&R, Simply excellent very well analyzed. The sky is his limit .

Yes he is very good. Let us also understand that he only has a week to practise these songs and remember so many things from taal, sur, timing etc. Things which can be worked upon with the luxury of time.👏

Originally posted by: rock&roll

😊

After ur statement,I actualy went back and listened to many of his performances again 😊....Th boy is really superb..Hs harkats/murkis are gr8,almost never falters on sur.Typically,I wld not have been able to find a single minus point with him,but since I was looking with a critic's eye,I noticed the following.

Next to lyrics,his weak point is taal.Sonuji commented that his taal was not correct in Saaware.Also listen to 'O jaana' .He makes mistakes with Taal quite a bit.He kinds of rushes up the song,ie,makes the rhythm slightly faster over a period of time.....He does this in the mukhda and in the alaap...Also when he starts the first line 'O jana',he starts on the wrong beat.He shld've started it a second late.But this gets covered up since the musicians are good and they adjust accordingly.

Saw him make a slight mistake in Sur once-in the antara of Chakke pe chakke.He picked it up at the wrong place and stopped(realised his mistake).The musician dada then played it in the right place for him and he picked it up.

But these are like nit picking for the sake of it.He is basically very good.Needs to work on the lyrics and taal a li'l more.And as,Gopalbhai, had pointed ,he is probably too playful and takes singing too lightly.He needs to get more serious abt his talent..Then the sky is his limit 😊

WOW very nice analysis. On a normal hearing you are right i would certainly miss all those points thank you for pointing them out. Also sorry i called u bhai hehe RockNRoll ji! there 😛

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

As far as i am concerned whatever performance any singer gives to the maximum level best in terms of both technical and expression point of view, will be considered as standard, as that reflects the capability. Any subsequent better performance will revise the standard, any worse performance will be considered below their (individual) standard. 😉

HAHA simple and fair enuff 👏👏

Originally posted by: Qwest

Agreed and well said.

Once again if voting started talent will be at back seat.

Originally posted by: AznDesi

Also sorry i called u bhai hehe RockNRoll ji! there 😛

It's ok...No big deal 😊

Originally posted by: 2smart4u

wanted to avoid it but cudn't😆😆

2smart4u, u r irrepressible......😆😆

Originally posted by: Summer3

Yes he is very good. Let us also understand that he only has a week to practise these songs and remember so many things from taal, sur, timing etc. Things which can be worked upon with the luxury of time.👏

I agree...Mistakes in taal can be rectified with practice and with time..But it needs working upon..It is one of those things(like singing in falsetto/kansura)which needs to be caught and rectified when young.Otherwise it will become an irritant for life,difficlt to rectify in later stages(after 25 or so).....But I'm sure Aamir will do the needful.His sur and murkiyan are very good.Of course,they can also be improved upon(there is always scope for betterment).........Aamir is one of my top fav contestants along with Rohit...I see max potential in the two of them.......Future Mohd Rafis and Sonu Nigams? 😉😊

Great Analysis anu di ..you are the best👏 ..........
And as for comparison of "Teri Deewani" and "sawre" he sang both the songs exceptionaly best....lakin aamir ka kuch pata nahin abhi bhi aur best ga sakta hai....I want his best in the form of "Tujh se naraz nahin zindagi"...... 😊