Does it fair? - Page 2

Originally posted by: binal54

i agree to cauz they are just kids how can theydo all that heck they should think u know waht its not the frist time they did this 😡 😡 😡

Tell me when they did it before and what was the reason?

Originally posted by: Rasny

Yah, coz all the kids prepared kareena's song...then karishma's song..then in short period again asha jee's song..how this poor kids could manage these all?😊

I agree with you guys... it wouldnt have been fair if they WERE eliminated... im glad there wasnt any eliminations this week because not only were they unprepared but all three of the bottom three had soar/bad throats which could be heard in their performances and Loria who had the worst throat mostlikely was the one out because she sang the worst😭

How is that fair?

Originally posted by: SonPan

I agree with you guys... it wouldnt have been fair if they WERE eliminated... im glad there wasnt any eliminations this week because not only were they unprepared but all three of the bottom three had soar/bad throats which could be heard in their performances and Loria who had the worst throat mostlikely was the one out because she sang the worst😭

How is that fair?

It was not fair to top 3 singers of the week.

They should have eliminated. END OF STORY. There is no explanation for not performing well since all the kids had equal time and oppertunity to perform. It was short but all had equal time no one has more or less. Also throat infection and sickness has been in the past as well and contestants have been eliminated because of it. EVERY KID now will deserve a second chance. Or it wont be fair atall. Heck those who got eliminated deserve to come back as well if they are goin to do this. 😡 😡 😡

Originally posted by: AznDesi

They should have eliminated. END OF STORY. There is no explanation for not performing well since all the kids had equal time and oppertunity to perform. It was short but all had equal time no one has more or less. Also throat infection and sickness has been in the past as well and contestants have been eliminated because of it. EVERY KID now will deserve a second chance. Or it wont be fair atall. Heck those who got eliminated deserve to come back as well if they are goin to do this. 😡 😡 😡

hi. there'll be elimination on fri day.

Originally posted by: Rasny

hi. there'll be elimination on fri day.

What do you mean? next elimination will be next week.

i agree it wont be fair to tanmay vaishali and aamir if they have to sing again and even for the rest who were not in the bottom three. it will be very unfair if a fourth child (who was not in this week's bottom 3) is eliminated.

Irrespective of whatever arguments or sentiments here the judges desided and they have valid points. Sonu and Sureshji are seeing those kids from bigining and they know potential of each kid better then any one else here.

Let's look in a broader prospective and ultimately musical talent (of kids) going to win than anything else.

Originally posted by: Padma55

Irrespective of whatever arguments or sentiments here the judges desided and they have valid points. Sonu and Sureshji are seeing those kids from bigining and they know potential of each kid better then any one else here.

Let's look in a broader prospective and ultimately musical talent (of kids) going to win than anything else.

There is no Valid points cuz the kids who sang better obiously didnt end up in bottom 3 cuz they also have potential. Potential doesnt mean anything since if the current bottom 3 had potential and didnt get eliminated then whoever it is gonna be next week will have potential as well. There are no Valid points. They need to follow the rules of the show thats it.

Originally posted by: AznDesi

There is no Valid points cuz the kids who sang better obiously didnt end up in bottom 3 cuz they also have potential. Potential doesnt mean anything since if the current bottom 3 had potential and didnt get eliminated then whoever it is gonna be next week will have potential as well. There are no Valid points. They need to follow the rules of the show thats it.

Rules should be followed does not matter what.

Otherwise people will loose interest and faith on the judges as well as on the show.