ismail n himesh acted sore losers - Page 3

Replies in blue

Originally posted by: harry143

i neva said amanat doesnt deserve 2 win.his ghazal round perf. was da best on dis show

If thats is true then how come Amanat was at # 3 in the Ghazal/semiclassical round? any explanations on that?

any1 cud hve made out ismail n himesh were bashin raja 4 gettin max votes..

What excatly did Ismailji say? he told Raja that "you did well but this one being your genre song, you could have done it better".

Now tell me, was he wrong in stating this?Isn't it a fact that Raja could have perfromed the song much better than what he did for this round? Then nwhere does the question of Ismailji bashing him come from?

n u mean adnan doesnt knoe anthin abt music

Sorry to say, but Adnan Sami today was not at all up to the mark.He hyped them all.

Thank you advil.. you stated everything I wanted to say. ID only told Raja that this being his type of a song he could have done much better like he always has in the past. He was not up to his own mark today. ID did not say he was worse than the other two or anything.. just that he wasn't in his own league like he could have been with that song.. What's so wrong about that? As a guru he is supposed to criticize them when need be.. especially at this last stage in the competition.

Originally posted by: harry143

innocent remem. wat he did in c2005 wen debojit came last ..i was angry wid his aftr perf. comments n nt at all wid his commnts abt raja's perf.

Please get your facts right before you state them. When excatly did debojit come last ?

You have every right to be mad at him. Be so, but thinking that your fav participant is beyong any criticism is a bit unfathomable.

Personally I feel he was right for both Amanat and Raja. In fact the way he told Amanat after the third song that Amanat knows better music than him shows that he can still pay the biggest compliment.

Originally posted by: harry143

aww man he left da show only 2 cme back wen debo was 4th in votin thn himani was eliminated next week...

Leave aside rest, let me recap the C2005 scene for you. ID left the day Nihira was eliminated and despite a great perfromance by Debu in the qawaali round(he had sung the toughtest song and had done pretty well too) As and HR had given him very low scores . Debu did not receive low scores from the junta.

He had mostly left seeing Nihira's elimination and injustice on points given to Debu. This is for a fact that on that day both As and HR had acted very biased.

Remember now.

ID today said things not to put raja down.

Lets hope Raja does not give another chance to ID or HR to make such comments.and after Rang de basanti song they were both appreciative of Raja , weren't they?

Originally posted by: harry143

aww man he left da show only 2 cme back wen debo was 4th in votin thn himani was eliminated next week... "your fav participant is beyong any criticism is a bit unfathomable"..i quit makin u understand wat i wanted 2 say..bt agn my LAST ATTEMPT 😭 😭 "Saying that you cud do better and this is your fault is one thing and is called constructive criticism

but saying you are here becaue of public support and undeserving and responsible for elimination of certain candidate is another thing....this is hitting below the belt "written by tindrum is wat i want 2 say..n I AGREE RAJA WAS NOT UP 2 DA MARK bt he wsnt bad even ismail said so

exactly they want him to feel guilty of the fact that he is in final 3 ...they never ever used such words for their own shishiya.....

and that is the reason exactly why VS stood with Raja on stage because they knew their comments of his being 'Undeserving' could break down his morale....HR did not tell this to Aneek....was his performance up to the mark?...how HR defended Amanat and asked ID to hug him ....

there is a HUGE difference between their behavior towards Raja and their own shishiyas