To vote or not to vote-what is the basis - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

7.1k

Users

24

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

anarvekar thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#41
Here is my take on this. I will vote for somebody who I believe is really special. I believe that performer in C2007 is Raja. His best performances have been truly outstanding. He does some things in his songs which only a top professional can do. Granted, he is not that great in all genres. However, he does better than average even in the genres that are not his forte. That, I believe is the difference between him and Musarrat. Musarrat was great in Nusrat/Rahat genre but below average in most other genres.

To make a long story short, I will vote for somebody whose performances you can go back to many years from now and watch again and again (performers like Raja this year, performers like Parthiv Gohil and Shreya Ghoshal in previous years). I have watched Parthiv's performances so many times on youtube. I know I will do the same with some of Raja's performances. Vote for guys who floor you with that special talent.

Now, I will stop my rambling 😆
66567 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: Iloveapu

Meena where are you girl....LaLaLand....😛

Arre Pakistan lost Cricket match...today....

and AdvilJI lost aaj ki Nari ki awaaz.....Poonam.....😆

Haha.. i dont follow cricket simply cuz i dont understand it..
But just saw it on the news..its jhashan is all over Zee-Tv..

This Dhoni guy is SOoOoOoO HOT.. hehe..😆

India is crazy over Cricket.. 😆😆.. i feel bad for Pakistan.. they'll have there day..😃..
rex_01 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#43
i don't judge conestnts on just that weeks performace, in the intial weeks i would support contestant who i like, in comeing weeks i support the contestant that has grown on me, sum 1who has impressed me so much that even if they give 1 or 2 bad performance it wouldnt change my view o them, tas they hve been outstanding other times, in this case, raja and aneek they truely need to reach the top for me they have have been the deserving srgmp contestants, i liked sumi as well but she is out now. 😊 i felt her voice was the best out of the all the girls in srgmp C2007.
124014 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Meena1

Haha.. i dont follow cricket simply cuz i dont understand it..
But just saw it on the news..its jhashan is all over Zee-Tv..

This Dhoni guy is SOoOoOoO HOT.. hehe..😆

India is crazy over Cricket.. 😆😆.. i feel bad for Pakistan.. they'll have there day..😃..

oooh r we talking about cricket???????? 😃😳😆... that was THE BEST GAME.... a veryyy close game...but finally india had to win👏

and yea Dhoni is veryyy garammm😉😆...sreesanth looked cuteee w/ his glasses... and RP singh's dimples...awwwwwww😳😳😳

swifthorse thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#45
Dhoni/Sreeshant, RP Singh???? girls cant stop with the subject matter.. .they need to get attached to the subject 😆 Anyway it was a great match & I was ecstatic at the end of it!

I felt very early in this show when we had our top 12/10 that our girls here dont measure up to guys this year..C2005 they did.. Nihira shd have been the winner.. but this year.. I believe Aneek, Amanat & Raja shd have been top 3. However last few performance of Raja made me rethink that & I thought Poonam shd break into top 3. Tough luck with her throat last week!
Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 17 years ago
#46
There has been some discussion on what it takes a girl to win. Well here's my opinion:

A woman who wishes to win anything by votes needs to have both talent and a strong stage presence. Indian women are typically subdued when it comes to performing on stage and don't really know how to get the crowd moving. They have to start being hardcore if they want to win such shows.

If Mauli Dave was more talented in terms of singing, she would have been a serious threat to the boys. I loved her personality; she was a real entertainer.
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: mas999

This is Zee's way to manipulate results, Poonam got eliminated on 24th, People who would continue to vote for her online won't kow that until 28th. They may have say for example 50000 votes. These will become redundent and may be used to add to anouther contestant votes who Zee wants to stay, Not too defficult as the code for Poonam can be replaced by say Aneek and he gets all the Votes😕 Just a theory😉

Well Mas999 just read your theory regarding the votings.Here is the official explanation provided on the voting side telling us what they do with the extra votes received....

Hope this clarifies the myths and the misconceptions...😊

[quote]

http://saregamapa.rediff.com/poll/index.html

Vote for your favourite contestant on ZEE Sa- Re-Ga-Ma-Pa
You can also vote through SMS and televoting. Click here for details

Voting for this round is open from Friday September 21,10 PM and will close on Friday September 28, 8 AM

Votes submitted between Monday 8 AM and following Friday 10 PM, will be considered for the next round.
However, if the contestant for whom you had voted during this period gets eliminated next Friday, then these votes for the participant will become redundant.

SO KEEP VOTING!
.[/quote]
Edited by advil - 17 years ago
mermaid_QT thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#48
tfs adi..

so this means other cotestants are pocketing votes for next week, not based their performance for the pertaining week, but week before.. now the logic is lost furthermore!!

😕
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: mas999

😆 Ha ha ha 😆 I know that is posted on the web site, But the huge redundent vote listing with that many e-mail IDs are a good tresure to be used to cover trail if needed.

Anouther problem the Rediff polling web code is so poor and highly insecure, fan clubs and communities are exploiting to send unlimited number of votes by writing a small code that automate voting to send 100 or more votes on one click. They post these links in their fan clubs and quickly take those away within hours fearing that they could be caught.

So what if there are multiple votings with a zillion email ID's..? Even via SMS there are multiple votings..

What matters is if the participants are receiving the votes or not...It seems that they are...now which fan site does what, how does it matter to us,I dont think it is our business, what matters to us is if we want to do it ourselves and save whoever our favorite may be..

They put their reasoning, there will be some scripting too,and some strategies as well..: to accept the clarification or not to accept is one's own personal choice.

The channel is out to make money, the participants is out to make a career and viewers are out to have a good time and vote for their favorite contestants.

The show no where says that if one does not like it they have to watch it, neither does it say that if you have watched it you should vote.Its public's choice.

I have a question, had your favorite contestant reached the top or even won the contest, would you still say this...?

If a female participant is not in top 3, then it is not the channel's fault alone, it is the fault of the voting public as well, who chose otherwise..

Edited by advil - 17 years ago
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: mas999

That is axactly my point of was when I high lighted, Just vote blindly day and night irrespective of their performances. A thouroughly screwed and manipulative voting systems with lots of back doors.

Okay this brings us back tothe objective of this thread....how many of us can claim that we really vote based on that week's performance?

If you read through the posts of this thread, you will see that most agree that by now they have chosen their favorite and regardless of a poor performance now due to whatever may be the reason, they would vote their fav,simply to keep him /her in the contest because they believe he/she can do much better and shine...

So does that week's performance really matter? If it did , then why are we unable to accept this week's elimination....after all based that week's performance, the results seem pretty logical...

Mass999 - am I making sense?😉

Edited by advil - 17 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".