Tit for Tat _ Yes Vishal give it back - Page 6

Vishal did not bash Aneek. He was very, very gentle with him. And, he didn't say anything wrong. Aneek's Jaane Jaan was good, and better than Poonam and Raja (he was more or less on par with Amanat) but it was not the best of Aneek's own performances.

Glad Vishal gave Himesh a taste of his own medicine, it had to be done. Even in doing so, Vishal still did not degrade Aneek, Aneek had no "broken down" look on his face....as opposed to the way Raja, and to some extent Poonam, look whenever Himesh keeps pounding at them. Himesh keeps doing it even though it is visible that his words are hitting below the belt and ripping their ambition to shreds rather than motivating, inspiring, and helping the contestants to work on their weaknesses and build on their strengths.

Constructive criticism is tough love on the one hand, with appreciation and gentleness on the other. It lets the person in the hot seat firmly know that the critic sees the person's strengths as well as their weaknesses, while at the same time helping the person figure out, "Aha! So THAT is what I need to work on....THIS is how I can make my performances better...." or...."I know I can do better. I am getting too overconfident and being lazy...I need to go back to basics." Things of that nature.

Whenever HR gives his negative comments, contestants rarely have that "aha" look on their face.

it came as a pleasant surprise from vishal 😊 i didn't expect vishal to say sumthing along those lines

Originally posted by: srk_biggest_fan

what the hell he HR thinks of himslef i would really wanna know who are those himesh fans who blindly follow what he says and whom HR always request for votes . i don't know who listens to himesh . 🤢

Do not worry , Himesh ji's fans listens only to his songs not his requests!!!

Well Done Vishal! Keep it up! Teach a lesson to Himesh!

Yes, Vishal was brilliant 👏 👏 👏 ...just once though I'd like to see someone else have the last word--instead of HR.
Vishal definitely tried---it was kinda funny cause even though the argument was over, HR would add something just so he could have the last word. Then Vishal would reply and HR had to have the last word again. 😡
It would seriouly be a miracle if someone could shut him up in an argument.

I remember the incident when the mahaguru Ashaji asked one of the contestant "Who selects the songs?". The contestant replied "It is the music director ". The music director(of the live music band) protested that it is the mentor who selects the songs. Some argument followed but Himeshi JI simply silenced the poor music director by saying " Jab main bol raha hoon, koi beech me na bole ". So it is in his nature that he always tries to enforce his point either bullying or being polite.

Hats off to Vishal for paying HR back.We really have had enough of HR antics cant handle anymore.

Rajs's 1st song wasent as bad as Aneek's infact i thought Raja sang the first song well too.

Why does HR have to interfere in everything and demoralize Raja.

And I dint understand one thing when Aneek hadent sung good why did Vishal give him 10 he could have easily given him 7 or 8 grrrrrr why dont people retaliate equally. 😡

really gr8 vishal 👏 👏 👏 , i think u shud've done this b4 😊
whts the prob wid HR??? wht he'l get if Aneek looses coz of any of other contestents....all r good so why cant he be sprty here!!!! 😕 😕
& all his crap 'audience aap batao!!!' 😕 ya phir 'kareena ji aap bataiye'.......
i just pray to god tht he leave the show asap coz of him neither mentors nor audience will b enjoying here or judging their fav's singing here!
take it this time!!! no wonder raja wil top again coz of HR.......
now its semifinal.... let's judge on performances..

VS is a smart person with decency : I do not think HR will change a bit and will continue to bore every one.
Its not good for his fan base , he should realize it.

Yes, Vishal did just that. ANd I was extremely glad... loved to see that smirk reform on HR's face... showed how he couldn't make something up to reply to what Vishal had suggested. I agreed with what Vishal had said.... that performance was certainly not in his top 15.