Are u satisfied with this Top 5? - Page 4

I would have been really happy if mussarat made it to the top 5! Junaid was my favorite but i knew that he wouldn't be able to make this far! now my full support is with amanat as i believe he deserved to win. Mussarat got eliminated and a lot of ppl said that it happened uz he wasn't versatile( 😕 ) which i don't agree with. however, now i am supporting the ONLY versatile singer of the contest and that is AMANAT!! 😊

Originally posted by: *payal*

junaid or harpreet instead of?

Sumedha !!!

Raja, Aneek Amanat, Poonam are all so good that it hard to order them
Sumedha is sightly weaker but also a good singer.

It all comes down to specific performances, public taste and luck.

I am hoping for a final between Aneek and Amant or a three way finale
between them and also Poonam.

I wish there was Harpreet instead of Poonam....Just my opinion,but the last performance of Poonam's which I thoroughly enjoyed was "Vande Mataram"...As a matter of fact,I've enjoyed more renditions of Harpreet than of Poonam 😕 Harpreet was more versatile than Poonam IMHO.

yah..but i hust wish tht junaid was thr 😭 ..i miss him soooo much

Originally posted by: mas999

Your are so right, I wish if we could have Harpreet instead of Poonam.

No way! harpreet and Poonam are class apart! The kind of song Poonam has sang is not only difficult for a female singer but also for a male! Besides that Poonam singing has a special charm which connects its listeners emotionally which is something that can't all singers do! In typical terms her voice and singing carrys a sense of 'emotion' (happy or sad) which takes a song to an another hight! Your post is understandable since your are a Sumedha fan you would want Poonam to be out before Sumedha, and that is natural! I too voted for Sumedha while Mauli was in as I believed she was far better then Mauli and should not go out before her but with Mauli and Mussy gone Sumedha is the weakest amongst them and she is deff. not as par as Poonam!

But hey, she is an awesome girl and posses a very good voice quality and I think she is already a winner as she is singing for no other then The Bhutt camp who are known for having great music in their films! With such a great opportunity she is def. gona go far in the industry and her weakness can also be fixed in the studio with several takes!😊

Originally posted by: Dhanush071

No way! harpreet and Poonam are class apart! The kind of song Poonam has sang is not only difficult for a female singer but also for a male! Besides that Poonam singing has a special charm which connects its listeners emotionally which is something that can't all singers do! In typical terms her voice and singing carrys a sense of 'emotion' (happy or sad) which takes a song to an another hight! Your post is understandable since your are a Sumedha fan you would want Poonam to be out before Sumedha, and that is natural! I too voted for Sumedha while Mauli was in as I believed she was far better then Mauli and should not go out before her but with Mauli and Mussy gone Sumedha is the weakest amongst them and she is deff. not as par as Poonam!

But hey, she is an awesome girl and posses a very good voice quality and I think she is already a winner as she is singing for no other then The Bhutt camp who are known for having great music in their films! With such a great opportunity she is def. gona go far in the industry and her weakness can also be fixed in the studio with several takes!😊

👏👏you always put your points in a sensible way and what you've posted here is also good! Sumedha is a good singer and surely gonna have the chance to get into the industry through Mahesh Bhutt but Poonam is far too accurate in sur/tal and she is some what unique but hasn't got her break which I feel very bad for! Poonam is a gem of a singer and could be a singing lagend in the making but HR, ID and others are too busy supporting and hyping the male contestant and all Poonam gets, are some clipping of her slum house and sick mothers every week instead of the praising of her great talent!

yes, i like all top 5 singers. i don't think there could have been a better choice...

Guys, why are yo fighting like hooligans....


If you want to see your set of favorites why not launch a parallel Saregamapa show and fit it with whoever your favorite is.....

Does any of the 5 contestants now pay you guys to vouch..oops fight for them?

Originally posted by: Dhanush071

No way! harpreet and Poonam are class apart! The kind of song Poonam has sang is not only difficult for a female singer but also for a male! Besides that Poonam singing has a special charm which connects its listeners emotionally which is something that can't all singers do! In typical terms her voice and singing carrys a sense of 'emotion' (happy or sad) which takes a song to an another hight! Your post is understandable since your are a Sumedha fan you would want Poonam to be out before Sumedha, and that is natural! I too voted for Sumedha while Mauli was in as I believed she was far better then Mauli and should not go out before her but with Mauli and Mussy gone Sumedha is the weakest amongst them and she is deff. not as par as Poonam!

But hey, she is an awesome girl and posses a very good voice quality and I think she is already a winner as she is singing for no other then The Bhutt camp who are known for having great music in their films! With such a great opportunity she is def. gona go far in the industry and her weakness can also be fixed in the studio with several takes!😊

If this post is addressed to me....

I respect your opinion,though unfortunately,we have to agree to disagree here...Poonam,In my opinion,is best suited to sing Richa Sharma/Subha Mudgal/Usha Utup numbers...Booming,full-toned,rich and sonorous singing...I didn't quite enjoy her rendition of "Dil to Paagal Hai",I felt the song demanded soothing,euphonious sweet-sounding dulcet tones...Sumedha's tune and melody might not be as impeccably perfected as Poonam's,nor might her sur and taal complement each other in perfect concert,but I prefer her innate voice quality...Just akin to how I loathe Alka Yagnik's shrill screechy voice but LOVE Shreya's deeper,resonant voice...bottomline is that it's all a matter of opinion...Each to his own😊