Reason why Aneek won't win!! - Page 3

I would LOVE for Aneek to be eliinated, just so we are rid of Mr. HR!!

I still feel that HR adversely affected Vineet's chances of winning C2005! His non-stop and nauseating love-story was really boring then, and it still is!

Look aneek is not as good as raja amanat or poonam. Plus HR is irritating and aneek plays along with HR. so they both deserve to go.

If the results are manipulated they will have Amanat,Aneek and Sumedha as top three to carry forward the ridiculously silly love triangle to its climax.Then they would go for real voting to decide top 2 and winner.
If vote count is genuine Amanat,Aneek,and Poonam will be top three and Poonam will lose.Final may be btween Amanat and Aneek.ID and HR having a friendly fight this time unlike Vinit-Debojit final.

Originally posted by: piya_y116

For me i think Zee will have top three with Aneek, Amanat and Poonam!!

Now, they won't have Aneek as the winner caz he already won the Bengali Saregama..so they won't want him as the winner for 2x...plus last year, Debo won from the same state, so Zee wouldn't want to repeat the same thing!

Now ..Zee has many benifits by having Amanat as the winner..it will them recognition world wide. It will be the first show to have a winner outside of India and that also pakistan! This would be a great step toward their popularity!!

By making Poonam win, they can also say that they are the first one to have a female singer win Singing competition contrary to the other shows. Plus they will also pull up the card that they made a career of a normal girl who came from such poverty, and they will get audience and people's love and respect for making her life!! you know how emotioanal , us Indians are !!

From Raja or Sumedha winning ..they won't get any of this extra publicity.!!

this is just my theory ..wat do u all think??😳

Your theory assumes that Zee is manipulating the results, voting is not having any effect on wining /elimination, this is a very pessimistic view!! Zee can only increase their credibility by allowing voting to decide the outcome, not by trying to create a simulated ideal scenario.

Originally posted by: biswita

Actually u raise some good points. Why was Amanat, the SRGM ME challenge winner, made to go through the entire audition/prelim process, while SRGM Bangla and Marathi winners (Aneek and Abhijeet) were give direct entry?

Any ideas, anyone?

this was brought up by ID on that very same day when Aneek and Abhijit made their entry but no one had any answer!! That's caz there is no answer..it was completer unfair!!

possible. raja and amanat have fair chance 😛

abid ji, it's called humility. aneek asks for votes in the humblest manner and that is the correct thing to do... talent to Ooparwale ne diya ha, and uske saamne everyone is the poorest person, hai na? isi liye humiltiy ek artiste ka sabse bada gehna hai..

i'm sure you remember how janta threw out apurva cos he came across as arrogant, even tho he was a good singer. he lacked humility and paid for it..

It is obvious that he is going to ask for votes in a humble way, because he wants to win that 50 lac contract and so do the others, in this competition nobody is competing for free or love...Remember he said that he learnes from amanat, mussarat and raja bhai...or u forgot that too..and on saturdays episode he got low marks and still he is in the top....just be fair...everyone has been in the compition from the beginning and Aneek came in the middle. just think if you are standing in the line to get tickets for a movie and someone cuts you and gets the ticket before you and go watches the movie while ur still standing there will you like that No right. Same goes for Aneek.

Originally posted by: abidshakoor

abid ji, it's called humility. aneek asks for votes in the humblest manner and that is the correct thing to do... talent to Ooparwale ne diya ha, and uske saamne everyone is the poorest person, hai na? isi liye humiltiy ek artiste ka sabse bada gehna hai..

i'm sure you remember how janta threw out apurva cos he came across as arrogant, even tho he was a good singer. he lacked humility and paid for it..

It is obvious that he is going to ask for votes in a humble way, because he wants to win that 50 lac contract and so do the others, in this competition nobody is competing for free or love...Remember he said that he learnes from amanat, mussarat and raja bhai...or u forgot that too..and on saturdays episode he got low marks and still he is in the top....just be fair...everyone has been in the compition from the beginning and Aneek came in the middle. just think if you are standing in the line to get tickets for a movie and someone cuts you and gets the ticket before you and go watches the movie while ur still standing there will you like that No right. Same goes for Aneek.

abid, my response was specifically to your 'poorest person' comment which i felt was slightly demeaning to aneek. how the other points you've mentioned are connected to that comment, i fail to see. i'm sorry if i've missed out on something there.

about the direct entry, we're really flogging a dead horse.. long dead actually. but still, if you want to, then here goes. aneek was NOT responsible for the direct entry. zee committed to srgmp bangla and marathi winners that they will be given direct entry to srgmp vishwaydh 2007 and it was told at the beginning of the show. so aneek (and abhijit) did not just saunter in the studio like a walk in the garden and start singing. he was officially brought in by zee. however fair or unfair that decision may seem to ppl, it WAS zee's decision and NOT aneek's personal choice. so pl direct all your rants at zee cos of their faulty format/policy. blame zee all you like but pl don't blame aneek (or abhijit the marathi winner) for something they had no control over.

also, many ppl say amanat too won srgmp dubai but had to compete from the beginning in vishwayudh. well there too i see zee at fault. if they could promise marathi and bangla winners a direct entry, who stopped them from promising the same to the dubai winner too? after all, they make their own rules.. it's their show.

Who deserves to be a winner?
1. Has strong hold over sur/tal & give consistently good performance
2. Has a great voice
3. Is versatile & can sing across genre comfortably.
4. A good performer who can entertain the crowd

Aneek does not have as good a voice as Amanat & Amanat is not as good a performer as Aneek..In all other depts they are well matched. They stand out as the most consistent & the best singers in the show and a final between them wud be the best thing that can happen to this show!

I think Aneek is super talented, but he has a mentor who doesn't think so and unfortunately keeps using some silly love triangle to garner votes. this love story is putting people off and will be eventual downfall of Aneek.

It's unfortunate that Himesh can't get this. I truly believe Aneek is the most talented.