Created

Last reply

Replies

73

Views

4.2k

Users

45

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

66567 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: TinaKhan

Yeah true!! That is not fair at all.

I agree..
*xsaher jaanx* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#52
i think this mite affect the voting for the paki singers which mite be wat zee wanted
mini2390 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#53
i was disappointed with the Jazba Junoon performance!... a lot of words were omitted!...i feel they were forced not to sing those phrases! ...but i think it was unfair because that first performance was only of Junaid, Amanat and Mussarat together..... who are all Pakistanis... it cud have been just a Pakistani performance to depict their representation of Pak, so why the need to omit the main words in the song? and im sure these three just had no other choice but to sing this song without the main lines!

and i was very proud of the way the Pakistani contestants said a few lines of poetry for the sake of peace and harmony between the two nations! 👏 ...but the disappointing part was that none of the other contestants said anything like that! .... no offense, but the show didnt seem to celebrate both independence days, but only one!..and yes, many of the kids there did hold up Pakistani flags, but they surely didnt hold those flags all by themselves, the show officials surely told them to hold them!.. it wud have been nice to hear sumthing from the other contestants as well, which wud have sounded natural and from their hearts, just like the way Junaid, Amanat and Mussarat said a few words for both nations!

Edited by mini2390 - 18 years ago
Muba thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#54
I found that weird tooo...not singing the actual song....I don't think there is anything wrong in saying pakistan's name in song...cutting the lyrics just because of pakistan's name doesn't make sense
miss_canada thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: *xsaher jaanx*

i think this mite affect the voting for the paki singers which mite be wat zee wanted


I agree!
Edited by miss_canada - 18 years ago
miss_canada thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#56
To all the Pakistani fans here, I would just like to say that try to think positive about y they might have changed the lyrics...I mean yes I agree that it was not a very nice thing they did about changing the lyrics, but wouldn't it sound more awful if those Pakistani guys standing there sang Pakistan hai TUMHARA?? 😕 😕 😕
I would rather change the lyrics instead of saying that standing in India!
Edited by miss_canada - 18 years ago
joie de vivre thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: miss_canada

To all the Pakistani fans here, I would just like to say that try to think positive about y they might have changed the lyrics...I mean yes I agree that it was not a very nice thing they did about changing the lyrics, but wouldn't it sound more awful if those Pakistani guys standing there sang Pakistan hai TUMHARA?? 😕 😕 😕
I would rather change the lyrics instead of saying that standing in India!

Perfectly put!..I think its quite a feat getting singers from Pakistan to sing on an Indian platform,and to celebrate the Independence day TOGETHER was definitely praise-worthy,as it's happening for the first time.We can definitely rise above the shallowness and petty gripes,can't we??.Trust me,it wouldnt have been a pushover for the co-ordinators,organising the show without hurting the sentiment of the UNIVERSAL AUDIENCE...It's a touchy subject actually,with people of both the nations,what with so much of grisly history behind the two countries and the scourge of wars ..Most Indians are tolerant,but to be candidly honest,I'm afraid I cannot say that every Indian would have absolutely comfortable with the idea of overt Pakistani patriotic songs being rendered on the show,thus I wouldnt blame the producers if they decided to play safe and tried not to get into a sticky wicket ....We would want to adopt the "glass is half full" outlook on the episode,and be glad that foreigners were permitted to praise their nation and celebrate its Independence day,rather than ranting over the glass being half empty because a few lines were chopped out..I'd infact be over the moon if an Indian singer was allowed to sing the Vande Mataram in Pakistan,even if a few lines or stanzas were omitted,but well,that's just me....

Coming to the voting,certain contestants like Mauli have a constant vote bank consisting of voters whose allegiance is for the "person" and not for the "performance"...Whereas some poeple vote for the "performance" alone,and those people vote for the songs which appeal to them on a personal/emotional level..Certain songs would wonderfully strike a chord with the Indian audience---for instance "Vande Mataram"(both versions, sung by Poonam and Raja respectively) and the song which Aneek sang---so they are bound to get more votes from that particular section of voters

PS..I profusely apologise if this post offended the sentiments of anyone,I didnt intend to do so in the slightest....If the moderators deem any part of the post/post in its entirety as inappropriate,I kindly request them to trash the post or edit it.😊

Edited by joie de vivre - 18 years ago
friends_rock thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#58

I agree with u all.thatss not fair..they should have let them sing "pakistan hai humara" okay no porbs they are in india so they cant sing for pak...poor boys 'becharee phas gayee😆

Sidrom thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Kaya ho raha hai yaar... jitna disect karoge utni burayee milegi... There is nothing perfect in this world.. Agar ek taraf few word change hue to doosri taraf Sandeshe aate hain aor Maan tujhe salaam duniya ke sabhi sipaahi aor mother ko dedicate kiaa gaya... Agar ek taraf sher-o-shayari hui to doosri taraf Pakistan ke flags dikhaye gayen... Kyun nahin hum positive cheez dekhen... Kaya yeh kam hai hum sabhi logon ke lie ke Amanat, Junaid and Musarrat jaise singers ko sunne ka maoqa milaa... kaya yeh kam hai hamare lie ke hum sab ek saath beghair ek doosre ki nationality pooche pakistani and Indian singers ki tareef karte hain... Kaya Joy ke out hone pe Amanat, Junaid yaa Musarrat nahin roya... Kaya Wasi and Sikandar ke bahar hone pe sabko afsos nahin huaa... Mana ke song ko change kiaa lekin hamein kaya pata ke kis halaat mein change kia gaya... Whatever we will say will be rumor unless we know the reality... So, please let us move on and enjoy a brilliant show and hope deserving singers remain in this show...

Very well said..👏👏 👏....I think its a big thing for such a big indian show to let Pakistani singers participate and again a big thing for Paki singers to stay on top and come to the top nine ...If only pakistanis are voting for them I doubt that tehy could be in top nien..so I am pretty sure that indians are voting for them too. So we should applaud indian for taking the big step.

reeya12 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: Sidrom



Very well said..👏👏👏....I think its a big thing for such a big indian show to let Pakistani singers participate and again a big thing for Paki singers to stay on top and come to the top nine ...If only pakistanis are voting for them I doubt that tehy could be in top nien..so I am pretty sure that indians are voting for them too. So we should applaud indian for taking the big step.






well said both of u,n plz dont u people start creating misunderstanding,i know zee is cheap,i 2 dont want mussarat,junaid and amanat 2 b eliminated n 4 this rather than discussing this dont waste time and vote 4 them,i think pakistan sud b enough 2 vote 4 them.okn no hard feelings 4 any nation.n ya india 2 did not sing 'sare jahan se acha hindustan humara'.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".