HR - Just For Today...I appreciate you - Page 2

We must appreciate that Mauli is singing the songs she likes. She might have failed but she should not have been discouraged the way he asked "What are you trying to prove , you have such a distinct style , why do not you stick to that alone ?"
Also in the independence day theme , where could she have found a song that suited her style ? They should have given proper comment like "You could have sung this song at a scale few notes higher .. It is good that you are trying genres which does not suit you but you gave a good attempt .." kind of stuff.
Last of all , if somebody should be worried about Mauli's future in SRGMP.. it should have been Bappi da. Does he mean Bappi da is no good as a mentor? In HR gharana itself this "sticking to core competency funda
" is not working as almost all his students too have shown up in danger zone and he needs to be worried about that more.

Originally posted by: USA_fan

HR is a unconventional singer...as well as unconventional person. He is good ...but he doesnt know to express his words. He wants to talk sensible...but many times utters flat words and it goes wierd! Sometimes controversy.

I dont like him given 10 ..10..10...and commenting about flaws. I guess he wants to support contestents. Its good in a way..but as a judge...you should not do like that. BUT if he gives less...then again people take it in a wrong way! So ...HR is basically a like-dislike judge!

BUT today....after other judges giving 7 7....I was expecting he will give 8. BUT to my surprise...he gave 5!! To be frank...that was the right justified marks anyone correctly could give. And the explaination he gave was well appreciated by audience too. For singer like Mauli she is good in her Genre...and it has prooved 2 times. Now she should stick to it to survive.

I am not against Mauli or HR. Remember Rajesh Roshan episode...because of HR requesting her to sing again....she was able to get green and be in this Race. So I guess HR fully deserves to comment on her whether it is encouragement or discouragement.

So...HR...follow some basic principles...talk carefully and act professionally...be generous...but not too generous that look stupid! ...

For today...I appreciate you! 👏

Very well written 👏 👏 👏 ...I totally agree with u 😛

HR realised that by giving support to someone who has not performed well, his own singers like JOY will get kicked out. We cannot expect everyone to perform well all the time for all songs, so hope Mauli bucks up. But now in the final stages matters are getting more serious and the Mentors will only recognise those that performed well eventhough they are from a different group.

None of the mentors are supporting Sumedha; though she was in bottom 3, neither they gave her more marks(they just gave her marks that she deserved or even less) nor they requested public to vote for her/praised her. They seemed to be more worried that Mauli sang badly and she might get less votes. It was really very mean of them.

well, i loved it when he said to molly, what do u wanna prove. i just love it. i really hated when visal & shekhar gave het 7. her song was sucks. and when mussarat sang, shekhar said very good. aap nai bohat acha & feel se gaya. and stil they gave him 8. that was radiculous.

These days people are liked or disliked on what they think about a singer 😉 😆