10/10 and degree of difficulty of d song

Mentors have been giving 10/10 to every body like baba ji ka parsad. Should degree of difficulty of the song be considered before awarding 10/10. Simple song sung perfectly may get 9/10 and difficult song sung perfectly may get 10/10....or any song sung perfectly should get 10/10 as it is difficult to classify which is simple and which is difficult song. What are your views?

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

I think this is a valid point. But for this everybody has to agree for degree of difficulty of the songs and rate them.

Another point , degree of difficulty of songs is not that simple. Some singers who are able to sing heavy and difficult songs are not able to sing seemingly simpler songs without disturbing the original mood of the song and they feel uneasy when there is nothing vocally challenging in the song, so in a sense the so called easy songs may be difficult for them.

Unless there is an agreement about the degree of difficulty of the songs in given set of songs to choose from , i do not see this rating system being successful.

Originally posted by: lifeztuf

Another thing is that initially they shd start with a mediocre rating, bcuz once they like someone's song they straightaway give a 10; rather they shd give him/her a 9/8 as someone who sings better than that person later can be given a 10/9 respectively..otherwise if a person sings an easy song nicely may get a 10 and later if someone sings a difficult song more nicely then also he will get a 10..So there wont be a comparative rating..

Originally posted by: sonyaee

Yes good point.
How about the mentors give the ratings at the end, after listening to everyone?