Versatality - Is Vishal right? - Page 5

Originally posted by: sibal52

There is no right or wrong answer to this vital question. I for myself believe in showcasing my strong points.

I do not think Aneek can sing Sanware song as good as Mussarat.

that's true and Mussarat seriously sang outstanding with Saware performance, he deserved big applauds👏

Originally posted by: Manpreet Kaur

i m defnatialy agree with u i don't like the way vishal react he just do that when is musrat and you r right abt raja he always sing in same verstility and i don't like that either abt vishal i don't knw whts his prob😡

agree with both of u.he wants a perfect singer to come out of the show and if that is the case it is not gonna be from his gharana.it might be harpreet but not raja or junaid.

raja only sings sukhwinder's songs and those type while junaid sings only sonu nigam's songs or performance based songs.harpreet is originally from bappida's gharana.

let me add apurva's name as well.he sang kk songs throughout the competition and he wasnt successful when he tried to sing a kishore kumar song

Originally posted by: Barnali

All in one items when materialistic, may not function properly true. but this is music. where it is such "All in one" items that work the best. Best examples being Lata, Asha, Rafi, Kishore. 😊

Originally posted by: S a r a h

see if you have best and an average material then to make more n more money we start with selecting best thing as it is accepted more widely than an average quality material...

and ONLY a specialised candidate in one particular genre does the best in that particular genre than a multi-talented average candidate ...
any day quality is better than quantity..
in earler times, singers used to get weeks of time to prepare for a single song and now the competition is so much so that makers dont wait for an all-in-one candidate to prepare for a genre to take best out of him... they definitely switch on to other who can sing that song the best ...

in earlier days a singer used to sing all songs of a movie and these days a single song is sung by more than 1 singer of same gender (not talking about duet of group song but a simple song that can be sung by a singer) example being dil vich lagya ve, teri yaad and so on.....

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

I think talking of versatility , the format itself should be such that it ensures versatility. There should have been rounds for classical, semi-classical,folk, indi-rocks, sufi etc forcing all the singers to bare their versatility.

Since the format does not demand it, it is pointless to argue whether the purpose of this talent hunt show is to find out a versatile singer. Why should any participant endanger their chances in the competition by trying things which the competition has not strictly envisaged ?