Versatality - Is Vishal right? - Page 4

Originally posted by: vichanakya

It is a matter of choice ma'am. You deserve what you choose😊.

Himesh and Vishal both are correct in their own way. Himesh is keeping in mind the winning factor here so saying thus. but this being a singing contest a contestant can be asked to show his/her capability in every field. so that way Vishal is right too. Yes why he is not saying the same to raja is definitely a question he should be now asked to reply.

Versatile singers always go way ahead than one genre singers. first of all one genre singers hav limited scope than the other. Secondly the same genre singing can keep the market demand for sometime... not too long. after sometime listeners are bound to reject it as it would become monotonous. But that would not be same with a versatile singer.

Originally posted by: Meena1

Because the quality of these items will differ.. "All in one" items never function properly.. always giving problems.. 😃..😆

All in one items when materialistic, may not function properly true. but this is music. where it is such "All in one" items that work the best. Best examples being Lata, Asha, Rafi, Kishore. 😊

Originally posted by: identt

RAJA did not show that he is versatile, then why Vishal picks other contestents? I think versatality is a plus point but a lot of great singers did not try to go out of their strengths.

I ask him to imagine the following:
Jagjit Singh singing: Eena Meena deeka!
KL Sehgal: Chahe koi mujhe jungli kahe!
Himesh R: mein hoon jhoomroo!
Mehdi Hasan: Jahan teri ye nazar hai
Usha Uthup: Jadu hai nasha hai
etc etc

Originally posted by: Andy*

As far as versitality is concerned, most of the contestants aren't versatile either, e.g. take Raja, Joy, Mauli (but these contestants also have something different to offer)

Exactly ! they have something to offer and that's why they are here, Well said!!👏

Originally posted by: piya_y116

I am serously fed up off Vishal's versality lectures...i used to support him in the beginning but now it is getting too much, let them sing watever they want to sing..after all they have to win public votes and public doesn't want their good attempt to sing different types of songs..public want execellent singing so they can vote for them.

First time i actually agree with Himesh that first become the best in your own genre and make your identity, then try different things!!

wat do u guys think about this..plus i honestly think Raja doesn't have verstility either , he always sings those Qwali type songs which suit his voice the best..but other judges don't say any thing!! Raja has not sing any soft songs, not that i remember!! Then why Vishal is not saying anything to him...He needs to look at his own gharana before pointing fingers😡😡

i m defnatialy agree with u i don't like the way vishal react he just do that when is musrat and you r right abt raja he always sing in same verstility and i don't like that either abt vishal i don't knw whts his prob😡

Originally posted by: imran310

[/
P]

then mauli should be on her way to houston by now right?

and lets remember aneek is a champion and mussarat can still level
him.

ANEEKCANNOT SINGANY TYPE OF SONG!i would love to hear aneek
sing a classical urdu song or even a Nusrat song. he cant do that.

[/
QUOTE]

Without any disrepect to the great NFAK, I am confident that Aneek would
kick A** on any classical song as he has demonstrated a good grasp of a
classical base and I am guessing he has some classical training. I think
he really has far better voice control than Mussarat. i think Mussarat has
one thing going for him which is his voice quality/sound in high notes - -
evocative of RFAK.

I support Vishal's comments because everyone from Lata to Sunidhi is
versatile and that is because of a core classical base. It's ok to prefer
different singers in different types of songs but not ok for a singer to
limit themself.

As for Raja -- I don't think he is a one genre wonder at all. He was
awesome with Subah Subah a completely different song from the other
songs.

Also Amanat, Poonam, Sumedha and even Joy has shown versatility so I
don't think that Mussarat should get a pass!