Round 9 - Feed back Thread - Page 4

Not a bad idea since the judges' choice round is going to be stretched out until July 25.

Originally posted by: *dolly*

I have a suggestion ...
can we have a round where the contestents will sing oldies..meaning songs of K.L. sehgal ji, suriya, noorjahan etc...only..it doesnt have to be a compititive round but a fun round..Iam curious to see how those songs will sound...
what you all think?

all the entries were wonderful best of luck 😳

Wow.. can't wait to listen to everyone, Kimi and Dolly ji, great banners, and Sweta lovely avis!! 😳 👏

Can already recognise some of these songs... can't wait to listen, will give feedback soon!

Aghhh, I had half of my responses written out and my computer shut down😭😭 so have to re-write them....

First of all, thankooooo for having all the songs of zshare, makes life much easier cos no need to download them.... much easier to comment and listen to!!😛

Ashish ji - I have not heard this song, actually... so unfortunately, I haven't had a listening of it before, but you sang it so beautifully!! You picked a different song and emoted it also very well.. only thing, when I heard the "uff yeh kumbuktu", I felt something there but as I haven't heard the original before, I can't say if it it's right as wrong...😳 As usual, always a treat to listen to your songs... the finals are nearing and I am positive you are going to be tough competition... great job!!👏👏

Seema ji - Wow, you sang it really well and the high notes were also very nice, along with the changes in pitch... so sweetly sung!!👏

Sindhu - I looovveee this song!!😃 I am so so glad that you picked it, was hoping someone would sing this song... you sang it so well, I just felt a bit of breathlessness with the "dil rooba" part... but really nice!!👏👏

Lavanya ji - Another sing I really like.. you sang it very nicely... I just felt that whenever you said "hai", there was too much emphasis in it. Pretty much throughout the whole song, I felt that only that specific word stuck out from all the lines... but other than that, very nice!👏

Aparna ji - I also really like this song, was telling Amma too, cos it's one of her favourites... you sang it very well, I just felt there was... hmmm, hard to put.. not as much feeling this time? But it was really beautiful, very nice👏👏 Am sure you will go far too...!

Mamta ji - You have such a sweet voice!! Very nicely sang, only parts where it was a bit nasal, but other than that, great job👏

Vidhya ji - Nice to see the same song in a different rendition.. I felt you had feeling in this and sang it very well.... again, love your voice... great job!!👏👏

Moon - You sang it nicely, mostly in sur, but I wish you put more feeling into it... it's one song that has so much feeling, especially the way it's portrayed... I felt that was missing.. but other than that, nice job!👏

Raju ji - Oh ! Another song which is repeated.. Raju ji, it is always such a nice treat to listen to your songs... again, I felt bits of this song where I could almost hear Udit ji singing... you had lots of feeling, very very nice!!👏👏 Again, you will be another tough competitor for sure...

Sarita ji - your voice is so sweet and sounds like a kid... very nicely sung, there was some disturbance in the middle of it so it was kind of hard to hear those parts, but you sang it very sweetly...!!👏

Pawan ji - You sang it nicely, some parts i felt were off a bit in the sur, but your voice has very nice throw... nice!!👏

What a great round overall, definitely a different one at that because I have only heard some of the songs here... great job everyone again!!👏👏

And Priya di, sad to see you go... You were a wonderful mentor and I'm sure all of the contestants in your Gharana were very lucky to have you. Though I am still full Bandish😳😆 will miss you in this competition!!

Ammu,

as always, thanks for your detailed reviews. Yours is also the only detailed review this time, I think. Lagta hain real SRGMP shuru hone ke baad IF SRGMP ko log bhool hi gaye. But natural, I guess.

Anyway, thanks for your reviews.

Originally posted by: ammmu

Aghhh, I had half of my responses written out and my computer shut down😭😭 so have to re-write them....

First of all, thankooooo for having all the songs of zshare, makes life much easier cos no need to download them.... much easier to comment and listen to!!😛

Ashish ji - I have not heard this song, actually... so unfortunately, I haven't had a listening of it before, but you sang it so beautifully!! You picked a different song and emoted it also very well.. only thing, when I heard the "uff yeh kumbuktu", I felt something there but as I haven't heard the original before, I can't say if it it's right as wrong...😳 As usual, always a treat to listen to your songs... the finals are nearing and I am positive you are going to be tough competition... great job!!👏👏

Seema ji - Wow, you sang it really well and the high notes were also very nice, along with the changes in pitch... so sweetly sung!!👏

Sindhu - I looovveee this song!!😃 I am so so glad that you picked it, was hoping someone would sing this song... you sang it so well, I just felt a bit of breathlessness with the "dil rooba" part... but really nice!!👏👏

Lavanya ji - Another sing I really like.. you sang it very nicely... I just felt that whenever you said "hai", there was too much emphasis in it. Pretty much throughout the whole song, I felt that only that specific word stuck out from all the lines... but other than that, very nice!👏

Aparna ji - I also really like this song, was telling Amma too, cos it's one of her favourites... you sang it very well, I just felt there was... hmmm, hard to put.. not as much feeling this time? But it was really beautiful, very nice👏👏 Am sure you will go far too...!

Mamta ji - You have such a sweet voice!! Very nicely sang, only parts where it was a bit nasal, but other than that, great job👏

Vidhya ji - Nice to see the same song in a different rendition.. I felt you had feeling in this and sang it very well.... again, love your voice... great job!!👏👏

Moon - You sang it nicely, mostly in sur, but I wish you put more feeling into it... it's one song that has so much feeling, especially the way it's portrayed... I felt that was missing.. but other than that, nice job!👏

Raju ji - Oh ! Another song which is repeated.. Raju ji, it is always such a nice treat to listen to your songs... again, I felt bits of this song where I could almost hear Udit ji singing... you had lots of feeling, very very nice!!👏👏 Again, you will be another tough competitor for sure...

Sarita ji - your voice is so sweet and sounds like a kid... very nicely sung, there was some disturbance in the middle of it so it was kind of hard to hear those parts, but you sang it very sweetly...!!👏

Pawan ji - You sang it nicely, some parts i felt were off a bit in the sur, but your voice has very nice throw... nice!!👏

What a great round overall, definitely a different one at that because I have only heard some of the songs here... great job everyone again!!👏👏

And Priya di, sad to see you go... You were a wonderful mentor and I'm sure all of the contestants in your Gharana were very lucky to have you. Though I am still full Bandish😳😆 will miss you in this competition!!

Originally posted by: anarvekar

Not a bad idea since the judges' choice round is going to be stretched out until July 25.

any more takers 😆

I am returning today after a weeks vacation and was hoping to see atleast some activity here, lekin yaha par to ekdam sannata hain... 😆 😆

Thanks ammmu for your detailed feedback again for this round 👏 Wonder if lesser feedbacks is responsible for lesser emotions in singing 😆 😆 j/k..As I had mentioned earlier too, this was the toughest song for me to sing during this contest so far.

Where are the other contestants and members, kuch messages to post karo ... Jago Sone Walo, Sunalo Hamare Gane 😆

Originally posted by: AG

I am returning today after a weeks vacation and was hoping to see atleast some activity here, lekin yaha par to ekdam sannata hain... 😆 😆

Thanks ammmu for your detailed feedback again for this round 👏 Wonder if lesser feedbacks is responsible for lesser emotions in singing 😆 😆 j/k..As I had mentioned earlier too, this was the toughest song for me to sing during this contest so far.

Where are the other contestants and members, kuch messages to post karo ... Jago Sone Walo, Sunalo Hamare Gane 😆

tumhara itezaar thaa...warna mein to feedback mein kabhi leekhti hi nahi...sirf sunti ho...😆😆..is baar meri post 2 weeks tak padi rahi finally i had to quote myself..😆

Originally posted by: *dolly*

tumhara itezaar thaa...warna mein to feedback mein kabhi leekhti hi nahi...sirf sunti ho...😆😆..is baar meri post 2 weeks tak padi rahi finally i had to quote myself..😆

😆 Yeah .. I saw that

Dolly, your idea of singing old old songs is good. But pata nahi contest ke bhi songs koi sun raha hain ya nahi, to phir aur songs kyon sunenge 😆

Originally posted by: AG

tumhara itezaar thaa...warna mein to feedback mein kabhi leekhti hi nahi...sirf sunti ho...😆😆..is baar meri post 2 weeks tak padi rahi finally i had to quote myself..😆

😆 Yeah .. I saw that

Dolly, your idea of singing old old songs is good. But pata nahi contest ke bhi songs koi sun raha hain ya nahi, to phir aur songs kyon sunenge 😆

well ..we can may be add a idea of inviting "other members" to send there enteries too for those oldies 😉😆..not for competing but for fun......phir is tereh u can attract more people...😆