Round 9 - Feed back Thread

👏 👏 Dolly, I absolutely love your presentation for each round! Great work 👏 👏

A new Round, and what a great line up of songs ! Fabulous !

It seems two songs this time again have been sung by more than one person.

From the ones I have heard so far, the ones that have caught my attention are :

Seemadi's - Ankhiyo ko rehene de

Seemadi, just fabulous !!! Your voice suited the song so well.👏

Aparnadi's - Chandan sa badan.

Aparnadi, would have loved to hear some other type of song from you.So far except for the disco round you have mostly sung classical based songs.Now I am sure of your strong area, lekin some other type could give an idea of your versatility. But this one was great.👏

Vidhya & Lavanya : Ek Pyar Ka Nagma Hain...

Both of you have sung very well.in some areas each one excelled a little more while in some other area the other one did, but overall both were good.👏

Sarita : Mein to bhul chali babul ka des

You were good.But again you are selecting similar type of songs in all rounds-sweet melody, it seems.Kuch alag karke dikhayo na.. would love to hear a different genre from you.😳

Sindhu..Hansta Huya Noorani Chehra

you sang well, but there were a few diction issues...otherwise good.👏

Pawan/moon : was ok.😊

Ashishda , Raju, Mamtaji, - need to hear you guys again...there was too many disturnbances/multitasking works happening to concentrate.😳

But must say as the rounds progress, this contest is getting tougher.Now we have some fabulous singers and judging who is better is surely a very tough job.

Originally posted by: advil

Aparnadi's - Chandan sa badan.

Aparnadi, would have loved to hear some other type of song from you.So far except for the disco round you have mostly sung classical based songs.Now I am sure of your strong area, lekin some other type could give an idea of your versatility. But this one was great.👏

Thank god Rupadi nahi bole 😆

Chandan Sa Badan is hardly a classical song Adi. Probably thats true for most on my songs in earlier rounds as well, with the exception of marathi song. Infact, this was the most difficult song for me to sing so far. Some classical songs may be easier to sing than this one. I think most of Lata's songs have "something" thats very hard to emote/sing... I have tried my best, hope its tolerable😛 Am glad you liked it 😳

Versatality ke liye aage rounds hain na 😆 Round 10, Gazal, indipop, rural etc...Mera patta katne ka pura bandobast hain aage 😆

BTW - just read judges round songs for all. Must say quite a great choice, some are easy some not so easy. Ari jane na dungi - now thats what I would call a classical based song.😳

Adi, I wouldn't agree that Sarita is singing the same kinds of songs.In fact, if anyone has attempted different kinds of songs, it's her. Do you remember, she sang "gore gore o baanke chhore" in two different voices, then there was "jeeya dhadak dhadak" which she sang in a deep throated voice, then there was "meethi meethi baaton se bachhna zara", again a very different kind of song because it had singing cum talking.

Originally posted by: punjini

Adi, I wouldn't agree that Sarita is singing the same kinds of songs.In fact, if anyone has attempted different kinds of songs, it's her. Do you remember, she sang "gore gore o baanke chhore" in two different voices, then there was "jeeya dhadak dhadak" which she sang in a deep throated voice, then there was "meethi meethi baaton se bachhna zara", again a very different kind of song because it had singing cum talking.

Well I felt it. If you hear her, then between gore gore o baanke chhore and mein to chhor chali piya ki des, she doesn't sound much different.

yes in the earlier rounds - the childern's special one she sang something different same goes for jiya dhadak jaaye.since then whether it is dooni sagali or gore gore..or piya ka des...it is sweet melody i would say...gore gore had some naughtiness in it, but it still goes as sweet melody only, not much variation..😊

Originally posted by: AG

Thank god Rupadi nahi bole 😆

Chandan Sa Badan is hardly a classical song Adi.

Rupadi...😆

Hearing your songs is a treat.They are just awesome.👏

If I am not mistaken "Chandan Sa Badan" is based on Raag Yaman....hain na..?😳

Your patta cutting is not that easy....you will go a long long way...seems like aapko #1 spot se bahut lagav hain...absolutely jam ke baithe hain...👍🏼👏

Originally posted by: advil

Well I felt it. If you hear her, then between gore gore o baanke chhore and mein to chhor chali piya ki des, she doesn't sound much different.

yes in the earlier rounds - the childern's special one she sang something different same goes for jiya dhadak jaaye.since then whether it is dooni sagali or gore gore..or piya ka des...it is sweet melody i would say...gore gore had some naughtiness in it, but it still goes as sweet melody only, not much variation..😊

So what kind of variation would you suggest?

Originally posted by: punjini

So what kind of variation would you suggest?

😆 Thats the mentors job....as an audience I would like to hear a sad song, or songs that sound different , say for example a song like "lambi Judaayi.." or a song like baahon mei chale aao, or Hare Rama Hare Krishna , Raat baaki baat baaki etc.

Originally posted by: advil

😆 Thats the mentors job....as an audience I would like to hear a sad song, or songs that sound different , say for example a song like "lambi Judaayi.." or a song like baahon mei chale aao, or Hare Rama Hare Krishna , Raat baaki baat baaki etc.

Lambi judaai is the same genre as jeeya dhadak. Baahon mein chale aao is melody, which according to you she already attempted. Raat baaki is something which would sound just like another melody unless there are accompanying beats.