Today's Judgment

Was today's judgment of eliminating Sarika the right one?? I am really confused.. Both the other girls performance was also not upto the mark.. Jothi was better after Ashaji corrected the mistake.. But im not sure, what u people think about this judgment 😕

I think it was rite...I dunno..but I think Jyoti can be a really gud singer..sply after I heard her after Asha Tais advice...I liked her performance better den Sarikas..jus wat I think.. 😳
i 4got d name of d gurl who sang first....she was gr88!!! 👏 👏

well i think todays judgement was wrong.i totally disagree.sarika was much better then jyoti as shekhar had said.
i dunno y asha tai select jyoti??????

Originally posted by: Anu.Rad

Was today's judgment of eliminating Sarika the right one?? I am really confused.. Both the other girls performance was also not upto the mark.. Jothi was better after Ashaji corrected the mistake.. But im not sure, what u people think about this judgment 😕

Read your update Anu and it seems the mentors were against Sarika being eliminated. Poor girl....... I hope she comes round. The show will not be aired here till tonight. Thanks.

I've not seen today's video yet..Waiting for the evening show here. But whtever I've heard so far from the singers, I feel Reecha was the best (she always sings on sur).
May be yesterday her choice of song was not good n she missed clarity at one or two points. thts why she didnt get green altho I felt she shd hv got instead of Nirupama.
Nirupama had chosen a simple song which needs only the 'throw' n feelings, but her performance in the first episode of C2007 was besura at some points. Y'day's performance was OK but not grt. I felt they could hv heard her today if she wdnt hv got the green y'day n then decided.
I feel Ashaji likes if the contestant sings her songs..
Sarika sang nicely y'day also n I felt the problem was only wth her range. But yes, tht is one thg we cannot ignore in Music. Range is very important.
Jyoti is a good singer but not confident enough.
It really depends a lot on the judge...

Originally posted by: Prenz~13

I think it was rite...I dunno..but I think Jyoti can be a really gud singer..sply after I heard her after Asha Tais advice...I liked her performance better den Sarikas..jus wat I think.. 😳
i 4got d name of d gurl who sang first....she was gr88!!! 👏 👏

i totally agree... i love how they did haath fanna song happy and sad...

I think Sarika sang well, and Jyoti didn't sing well first time but has shown her true capabilty once she was corrected by Ashaji. Frankly, I never liked Sarika's voice quality and she sounded nasal to me on several occasions. Jyoti's voice is very good, but if we compare Jyoti's first performance with Sarika's performance, I thought Sarika was better today.

But again, I can never dare to challenge Asha ji's decision. There must be some reasoning behind her decision which neither the mentors nor that public has the potential to understand. Asha ji and Lata ji are personifications of Ma Saraswati, and they can never be wrong.

I agree with the judgement made by Asha...

I agree the judgment was totally unfair.

I agree with ashaji....to be honest all were below par...sarika voice is not all that gr8..jothi sounds good need to sing better....reecha was obviously better and sings with good control of the pitch. so in a choice between jothi and sarika there was not much left behind...so our zee tv has this beautiful drama enacted....ashaji will leave the show without announcing and then a big drama (may be in all this sarika might have got stressed and fainted..as she looked ok when they told the result)..and already they told in the beginning that they can get back contestants..so they have to show at some point in the show..I think in the run it becomes irrelevant as both jothi (unless improve her singing style) and sarika will be eliminated soon...so its all a BIG drama