Round 8 - Feedback-Farmaish Podcast Added - Page 3

Nik, Its really sad to know that you were not able to submit your song on time. I have enjoyed listening to all your songs, especially because they were all "haat kar" different from the typical ones - Lagan Lagi, Ramta Jogi, Ya Ali and this one 👏 It takes a lot of courage to do this, I think 😳 The dates for this round were moved from 19th to 23rd to 25th to 26th, just wish they had been extended a little further before the last deadline.....😔

But I also understand that the co-ordinating team has to go by the rules....

Originally posted by: T.

Nik, I hope you continue to practise classical music because you are improving day by day.

You chose a very difficult song this round, which had a lot of harkats. You fumbled in some places, while in some places you were excellent. Overall, you have captured the emotion of this song very well.

Very sorry to see you go. But, as the lyrics of this song say "jo bhi ho kal phir aayega." Do take part again next year if you can.

so here's my feedbak!!!!!!!!!!am no perfectionist nd this is jus my views nd in no intention to hurt nyone!!!!

*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*SUR SANGAM*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*

ashish-let me tell u.......u have such a strong nd a heavy voice nd ahhhh melodious voice 👏 😃 .......all the harkateins wer perfect the surs wer also fine ......the feel too was perfect.......only tht chune paaye part.......think u shook a lil.......excellent rendition 👏 👏 👏

seema- lovely voice..........very sweet nd sooooo pleasing...........u have a very soothing voice nd cann suit ny type of song i think!!!! 😃 .......apart from tht........tht shakti cud have been stronger nd the starting was in a different pitch nd the ending was in a differnet pitch.......think lost ur sur at the jhoot line......i cudnt find the song to listen to... 😕

lavanya-ur voice too has something in it.........i donno how to say it 😆 .............but it has something in it...........ur voice also suits different genres!!!!........i have never heard this song b4..........but the humming was very gud nd the harkateins wer neat.............i think u sung it really well!!!!!!!!!!!! 👏 👏 👏

biswita-i think u held the mike too near.......nd thn slowly it was moving this way nd tht way 😆 ............but u did sing well..............it was simple nd neat.............a great attempt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 👏 👏

*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*BANDISH*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*

Aparna- its a very very difficult song 😳 ..........it had evrything.........all the masalas wer thr in their right poportions 😆 ......to sing the lyrics with speed is not at all easy........nd wud like to commend u on tht 👏 👏 u carried it off effortlessly.........excellent!!!!!! 👏 👏 👏

vindhya- very sweet nd smooth voice nd very soothing 👏 👏 ..............nd u have the ability to sustain ur voice soo well...nd tht to with the same volume till the end!!!!!!!!! nd i think thts great!!!! keeping up the rhythm in such songs......i feel is difficult..........nd evrything else was perfect............u did a great job!!!!!!!!!! 👏 👏 👏

mamta- u sung it really well.........only in a few places u lost sur...........apart 4m tht u did an excellent job!!!!! 👏 👏 👏

moon- u have volume in ur voice some places it was flat.......nd in a few places.........the endings u shud have held it longer rather than leaving it...not in all the places....in very few places......apart 4m tht.......u sang it really well!!!!!!!! 👏 👏

the coolest one- nahi samjhe hain voh hamien part u wer off.............the otrs u wer fine..........i quite enjoyed it..........it was fun........overall..........coool performance!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 👏 👏 👏

*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*ALAAP*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*

raju- wat a wonderful voice.....has so much depth 👏 nd...........after tht o raahi coming bak to tht rukh jaana.......is tuff.........nd u did it absolutely well nd sounded so prefessional 👏 ........loved ur voice nd the rendition was jus excellent.........the dish was fully cooked!!!!!nd lemme tell u this ..........when ur song started playing........the player changed into all kinds of colors........which i didn't see it happen b4........ 😆 😆 👏

sarita- another soothing voice........u sung this song soo well nd loved tht lalala 😉 .........it was sooooooooooo nice.........it sounded soo bubly nd oooo soo very nice.....tht was the highlight of the song!!! nd tht hmm of the same thing.......cud hear each nd evry note.........it was excellent!!!!!! 👏 👏

pawan- this is a very difficult song.......missed some notes while singing mera rang de......azadi ka....tht line u wer off........think u wer in full josh while singing this line.......nd some otr few places too u wer off nd tht basanti chola........tht harkatein thr........u got it sometimes nd sometimes u didnt.........overall........u sang very well!!!!!!!! 👏 👏 👏

*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*JHANKAAR*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*'*

suhana- u have nice voice but u went off surs in some places nd u tried to come bak...........nd u shud have tried repeating tht ashayein which comes thrice after kuch paane.......aas...aas......cause u lost the beat........thts it.............overall a great attempt!!!!!!!!!!!! 👏 👏


JAI HIND!

Sindhu...thats the spirit..!!!!👏👏👏

good job..and now the other participants, where are you all? Please come forward and post too..😳

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

Appa - the coordination committee of the contest has discussed this before taking this decision... These rules have been formed upfront when the contest began, and the same rules have been applied for some participants earlier too and they had to be unfortunately eliminated as they could not submit their song on time... We cannot make a one-off exception for any particular contestant...

This has been very unfortunate, but at the end - we will have to abide by some rules even if we may not want it to happen. Hope you understand.

OK, I did not know that. Then its fair. 😊 Thanks Jaya.

Aparna : What to say!!! U are just awesome.👏 I simly luved the song. it was so melodious but more importantly it was very soothing.😃 Yes one very interesting thing i found in the song. the lines at Sapta koti… the exact words are "abala keno maa eto boley" I doubt if that will go against u its just that i was listening to it too carefully maybe and got it.😆 Sorry aparna…😳

Ashish : U too are really good.👏👏 But as i had mentioned earlier u need to add more feeling into the songs. u are technically correct, but in order to do that u forgot to put in the feeling into the song. the song needed more energy… more as it's a patriotic song.😊

Biswita : U hav done much better in this round than the earlier two rounds. I hav just one advise for u biswita. U hav a habit of throwing few words while singing.😳 Especially the last words in a line. U need to smoothen it out and not throw it. But on the whole a really good attempt.👏

coolestOne : good attempt but lost scales too many time.😊 The song is almost flat. The breaks are too long at times. Always remember we don't have music here so how so ever long the break is in the original song u need to adjust it so that it sounds nice and does not giv the feeling of break. Practice more.😛

Lavanya : very good attempt again.👏👏 but please open up lavanya!!! U hav a nice voice and u are pukka when it comes to sur and taal. So please open up your voice and that will take care of the treble in your voice too. Yes Lavanya, its there at times in the song. also the more u sing with an open voice its easy to bring the feeling into the song.😊

Mamta : another technically perfect song.👏 but in your case i felt u are trying to suppress your voice this time. Why??? For u the same advise again. Start at a bit lower scale and then sing with open voice. Everything else will fall into place after that.

Moonlite : very well rendered moon.👏👏 U just need to work bit more with your diction. But really luved listening to the song.😃 its one of my favourite songs too. U also need to bring bit more feeling to the song though.

Pawan : U hav choosen a really tough song pawan. With your throat condition u should hav gone for a bit flat song. but I must applaud u.👏 U hav sung it really well.👏

Raju : sorry raju from u I hav lot of expectations. But this time I feel u hav blundered. I just could not get into the song. no depth no feeling nothing. True u are way better than many even in this round, but not upto the mark when it comes to your own capacity.

Sarita : Good choice of song in your situation. U hav suppressed your voice ( and with valid reasons I know) but still maintained the scales. Brought the soft feeling of the song very nicely. 👏

Seema : very well sung seema.👏 And this time u hav brought much feeling into the song but still something was lacking. Technically u are always correct just that u need to bring the feeling into your singing. Sing it from your heart and that will bring the emotions into the lyrics of the song. 😛😊

Cindu : as appa said this was a brave attempt.😊 When bhaskar first told me that he has asked u to sing this song, frankly speaking i was really worried. But i never expected that u would come out with such a rendition.👏 The feeling was lacking in the song. U need to bring more energy into the song. U are at times ending your lines abruptly. Let it flow out. That brings the sweetness into the song. but a very very good attempt I must say.👏👏👏

Suhana : Nice attempt Suhana.👏 U need to work with your scales. U hav a nice voice but its always that u hav problem with your scales.

Tina : Very good!!!👏👏 Very well sung Tina.👏 would make just one point here. U should hav started maybe at a bit lower scale. At high notes its getting jarred otherwise. But technically no mistake. Very good attempt again!!!👏👏👏

Thanks Appaji, Barnalidi, Ammu Cindhu, and GA for your feedback. awaiting input from adi and CKY

Only wish you had listened to those lines carefully 2 weeks back😆 Never mind, atleast I know them now 😃

Thanks for your feedback! 😊 (finally 😆😆 )

Thanks to everyone else who have provided feedback for this round - Ammu, Cindu, Gaurdian Angel.😃 Ammu, I will miss Padmajaji's songs .....Cindu - that was great and very meaningful feedback. As Adi said, thats the spirit 👏 Hope I find time to post mine as well

Originally posted by: Barnali

Aparna : What to say!!! U are just awesome.👏 I simly luved the song. it was so melodious but more importantly it was very soothing.😃 Yes one very interesting thing i found in the song. the lines at Sapta koti… the exact words are "abala keno maa eto boley" I doubt if that will go against u its just that i was listening to it too carefully maybe and got it.😆 Sorry aparna…😳

Originally posted by: Barnali

Biswita : U hav done much better in this round than the earlier two rounds. I hav just one advise for u biswita. U hav a habit of throwing few words while singing.😳 Especially the last words in a line. U need to smoothen it out and not throw it. But on the whole a really good attempt.👏

Thanks didi. To be honest it is just that I am more comfortable with the songs in some rounds than in others...but I understand and respect that it is the test of versatility and I try to do my best

thanks every one for all ur feed backs 😛 its highly appreciated.a few days ago i was wondering if anyone would give a feedback or not but the amount of interest everyone is showing in the contest is tremendous 👏

OK,

here is my review.
Ashish: AWESOME, AWESOME, AWESOME
Everybody else: BAD, BAD, BAD

😆. Just kidding. I don't know if I feel comfortable critiquing fellow contestants. I will say one thing though. I completely agree with Barnali ji that Aparna was just awesome in this round. She chose an extremely difficult song to sing and carried it off with aplomb.

I do appreciate the feeback by Tanaz, Appa, Guardian Angel, Sindhu and Barnali ji.

Originally posted by: advil

Sindhu...thats the spirit..!!!!👏👏👏

good job..and now the other participants, where are you all? Please come forward and post too..😳