Round 8 - Feedback-Farmaish Podcast Added - Page 2

Oky, here's my feedback... loved this round, was smiling even more each time as I kept thinking of my India😛

Ashish ji - Wow Ashish ji.... you have put a lot of feeling and emotion into this song, everytime I listen to it, i feel tears in my eyes, and you have managed to do that too... so beautifully sung!! I don't have to keep saying this everytime, but can't help it... your voice is just so melodious😳

Seema ji - I love your voice, it's so nice and you too have put feeling into this song, i can really tell you mean every word... so beautiful👏👏!!! YOu have nice throw in your voice and overall it just sounds so nice to hear the song...!

Cindu ji - I am so glad you picked this song, it's one of my favourites... Especially in the chorus, i could really hear the feeling in your voice.. so beautifully sung, i don't have any critique about this, except I wish it could have been a bit smoother, as it seemed to have more than normal pauses in it... but your voice is so beautiful, very good!!😃👏

Lavanya ji - Ahhh, another song which I like so much... only thing is the first "jeet jaayenge hum", the sur was a bit off, and I wish you had done the little up and down part (i'm sorry, i sound confusing😕), like "tu agar", that part... But you did it later on with "rang hain" so that's good! and the "r" is a bit much but you fixed it later on... again, every song which i am listening to has a lot of feeling in it and your's does as well... very well sung!!👏😛

Biswita ji - Wow, it seems like everyone is picking my favourite songs😆 I think your emphasis on words like "saath" and your throw was a bit too much, but we each have our different pronounciations so that maybe the reason as well... and the "ek din" part, the ending was not finished properly.. but you sung it well😛

Aparna ji - Wow, this song suits you so well!!😃 Again, each time you wow me with your singing, all the vibrato parts were done so well, the "Mataram" parts, and i really felt even more proud listening to this song.. only thing I will say is the first "aaaaa" you have, before "sujalam...", that seemed a bit off to me and it kind took me by surprise, or maybe that was the intended effect😉 But beautifully sung!!👏👏

Vidhya ji - The sweetness of your voice really made the "pal", when it went high sound so good... i know that is not hard to sing, but you did it so beautifully!!👏😳 Some parts here and there were slightly off, but the entire essence of the song really went through so well.... great job!!😛

Moon ji - Uhoh, for some reason i could only hear the beginning and then i think something happened to my sound because i couldn't hear the rest!😕 Strange... i tried again but hopefully later it may work.. the part i heard though was nice, although it was too short so i'll give my full feedback when it works again😃

the coolest one - This is the third time i've downloaded it and it doesn't work ahhhh, let me try again later... so sorry!!

Mamta ji - I love this song!😳 You sang it v. well, there was some parts that went of, the "sama" and "pal" a few times, but overall, it was really nice and i could feel the words as i was listening as well... great job!!👏 Only thing i wish is when you say "chahe jo tumhe" i wish there was even more feeling in that..

Raju ji - Omg, first time listening I thought it was Udit, until few seconds later i realised it's not!! Wow wow, the "o raahi", so so beautiful..... as usual, i always love your songs.. so beautifully sung👏😳 Can feel every word as i am listening to this too.. everytime you wow me even more👏

Sarita ji - Again, for some reason i could only hear about 40 seconds of the song and it went away!! I'll try again later, so sorry.. dunno what is happening with my computer😕

Pawan ji - Wow, i love this song, there were parts in that you went out of sur, like the first "mera rangde basanti chola", and the "rangde" parts (especially when it goes high) but overall it was sung well, you have such nice throw in your voice that every word comes out so well👏

Uhoh, have to go and i had just one left😆 Will finish my feedbacks on the ones i couldn't listen to and Suhana jis as soon as I come back....

One thing I especially have to say about this round, is that i hear so much feeling and emotion in every song... Wherever we are all from, we are proud of our own country... and it shows in all your lovely voices!! Beautiful!!!👏👏😳

All the best to all the participants and this will definitely be a tough round for judging.😛

EDIT - Cholly, i put the wrong name, i meant the coolest one, not Nik ji😛 thanks Adi for telling me :P

is there anyone except ammmu having a problem with my link??if so please pm me

Very nice songs. I am loveing them all. Let me finish listening to all of them.

thank u so much tanaz,appa(gr8 to see u bak!!), ammu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 😃
no comments on my feeling 😆 😆 ........was so much bothered abt the feel..... 😆

by the way can i give my feedback too???

Originally posted by: cindu

by the way can i give my feedback too???

Yes sure why not Sindhu. do give.😊

Also as we know Nik did not submit his song in time. he was having trouble with his PC. but he has now sent his song. According to him its his farewell song to all of us. here's the link to the song.

http://www.savefile.com/files/759982

Nik i personally am really sad with this turn of event.Just when u did so well, getting such a good position this had to happen. But we are really sorry we hav to follow the rules.So cant accept the song for the contest.

Originally posted by: Barnali

Yes sure why not Sindhu. do give.😊

Also as we know Nik did not submit his song in time. he was having trouble with his PC. but he has now sent his song. According to him its his farewell song to all of us. here's the link to the song.

http://www.savefile.com/files/759982

Nik i personally am really sad with this turn of event.Just when u did so well, getting such a good position this had to happen. But we are really sorry we hav to follow the rules.So cant accept the song for the contest.

Nik, I hope you continue to practise classical music because you are improving day by day.

You chose a very difficult song this round, which had a lot of harkats. You fumbled in some places, while in some places you were excellent. Overall, you have captured the emotion of this song very well.

Very sorry to see you go. But, as the lyrics of this song say "jo bhi ho kal phir aayega." Do take part again next year if you can.

Originally posted by: Barnali

Yes sure why not Sindhu. do give.😊

Also as we know Nik did not submit his song in time. he was having trouble with his PC. but he has now sent his song. According to him its his farewell song to all of us. here's the link to the song.

http://www.savefile.com/files/759982

Nik i personally am really sad with this turn of event.Just when u did so well, getting such a good position this had to happen. But we are really sorry we hav to follow the rules.So cant accept the song for the contest.

Barnali di:

Its sad to see a good singer go due to rules that was beyond his control. Can't all the judges, mentors, and you all reconsider the decision. After all getting the best singer is our motto. Just a suggestion.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Barnali di:

Its sad to see a good singer go due to rules that was beyond his control. Can't all the judges, mentors, and you all reconsider the decision. After all getting the best singer is our motto. Just a suggestion.

Appa - the coordination committee of the contest has discussed this before taking this decision... These rules have been formed upfront when the contest began, and the same rules have been applied for some participants earlier too and they had to be unfortunately eliminated as they could not submit their song on time... We cannot make a one-off exception for any particular contestant...

This has been very unfortunate, but at the end - we will have to abide by some rules even if we may not want it to happen. Hope you understand.

Hello everyone. First of all congrats. to Dollyji and everyone on the wonderful format and the great effort put in creating the thread. It is highly impressive.👏👏👏

I am always nervous to give my comments as I am no music genius......... but here is my input. Thank you😳

Sur Sangam Gharana:

Ashish: Kar Chale Hum Fida

Great effort. I really loved his rendition of the song.

I always like listening to Ashish.

Seema: Hum ko maan ki shakti dena:

This is my fav. song and Seema is one of my fav. singers.

It was very clear and I loved it.

Cindu: Ek Tu Hi Bharosa:

Felt like there was a bit more effort made

in some of the words than necessary

but otherwise it was very nice.

Lavagnya: Zindgi Har Kadam

Just the tone or pitch sounded

different in few places......the voice

sounded different in different places...but

very nicely rendered.

Biswita: Hum Honge Kaamyab

Nice try but I am not sure about the

pitch.......it seems too high. But

good try Biswita.

Bandish Gharana:

Aparna: Vandematram

Wow..... what can I say?

Aparna did an excellent job!!

Vidya: Aane wala paal jaane wala paal

It was very clear and well practiced.

The rendition was very smooth.

Mamta: Saare Jahan se Aacha

After Saare Jahan Se Aacha

Hindustan Hamara........ it kept on

getting stuck and I could not hear further.

Sorry!!

The Cool One: Yahan Ke Hum Sikandar

There was quite a big gap between the lines

but the verses were clear. Good effort

Moonlite: Kaal ho na ho

I really enjoyed this. She rendered the

song with much ease.

Aalap:

Raju Kabi: Ruk Jana Nahi

Wow........ just flawless.

I just loved it.

All the best to you.

Sarita: Le chal ye dil jidhar nikal pade

Great effort. Her voice is very

soothing and comforting. Well done.

Pawan: Mere rang de

Very clear. Just found the pitch

a little high for the song. Otherwise

good effort.

Jhankar Gharana:

Coolma: No submission??

Suhana: Ashayein

It was a very good rendition

and I enjoyed listening to it.

Overall great effort by the contestents. It always blows me away how they can sing so well without any back-up music.