The gimmick of Zee TV.!!!! - Page 3

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Don't agree with you Bob da. If Sameer could be on the top three, then Diwakar also deserves to be on the top three. He has a much better voice than Sameer.

Diwakar has a much better voice and he has improved and he seems to sing in his own style. Shaan rightly contested the Jurry's remark regarding his limited range by saying " How can you say that ? this is not his final age".

I have a feeling that Sameer sings with a suppressed voice.

Originally posted by: shefali_123

Huh??? Then Sameer also asked for votes based on cuteness like Diwakar asked because there was darkness all around him and Sanchita too Alka went on harping she was the only girl left.I dont think anything is wrong here. Not only Diwakar but all eliminated contestants were brought back. Diwakar came through by public votes. Rules were changed for Sameer too. He was out twice but brought back. He was not in top 22 but brought back on special request of parents and in the final three too by inventing special rule of 112. So as much compromise has been made to accomodate Diwakar so many have been made for Sameer too.

In my opinion Diwakar's voice is much better than that of Sameer.

Well exactly the Rules were not changed just for him for the TOP 22 there were more kids along with him. So Zee MADE THE MISTAKE OF CHANGING RULES in the first place. Dat is what BOB DA is trying to say the thing dat Messed up the SHow was the Format. About commin out with rules during the show etc....

But people decided to bring Sameer into this equation which is not fair. Since ZEE DECIDED to change the Show format and the rules not the kids. He got in due to a rule change BAD ON ZEE's PART but made it to TOP 3 on his own. He got eliminated at TOP 3 but he was STILL TOP 3. Cant blame Janta either since ZEE BOUGHT THE VOTING RULE IN.

So all i am saying is quit puttin Sameer and other contestant down. If BOB da said sumthin bad about diwakar deal it with BOB DA. No need to put a contestant down WHO HAS NUTHIN TO DO WITH THIS POST.

Originally posted by: Qwest

Point and my thought why we are lowering the stander by doing all these, yes they need to make money no problem but they also need to keep the stander and the dignity of that SARAGAMAPA stage. Cannot keep changing there decision.

Bob da as soon as i read the post i knew this is the POINT you were trying to make but people just cant make their arguement without puttin down a contestant who HAS NUTHIN TO DO with YOUR POST or YOUR POINT.

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

Diwakar has a much better voice and he has improved and he seems to sing in his own style. Shaan rightly contested the Jurry's remark regarding his limited range by saying " How can you say that ? this is not his final age".

I have a feeling that Sameer sings with a suppressed voice.

This Post is not about whos VOICE or SINGING YOu like better. Bob da is Saying why is ZEE CHANGING THE FORMAT TO MAKE MONEY FOR THEM.

Originally posted by: jayc1234

I will not agree with you here Bob'da...

If Diwakar was brought back after he was eliminated, so was Sameer after he was clearly out before the finals.. Voice quality wise, IMO Diwakar is much better than Sameer... So, we cannot single out Diwakar that his being in the final 3 was unjust to Abhro or Pawni... IMO - he is more talented and deserving than Sameer...

Definitely - Abhro and Pawni should have been in the finals along with Sanchita and that would have been the clash of the titans for the Finale..

Jaya my point is the format do you think that was right. I think Pawni and Abro deserve more to get that wild card.In fact they could've seen the opportunity here and may be planned for a special talent show for physically challenged.

Originally posted by: Qwest

My question is about the wild card I do not have any problem with any winner honestly I belive if those other contestant have lost with votes than Sameer also should have gone too. Why Zee management made an exception for Sameer also when he lost to Diwakar for 112 vote is this right format. Why they did not use that wild card for Pawni or Abro they were also very talented.

With all due respect sir, please read your original post, It says

how does a contestant singer who is not even a good singer land up in the final three.

All the justification you have used have been regarding the Sympathy factor

You are totally discounting that Diwakar is a good singer, and that Questji is a subjective statement

You can argue, Diwakar is a not a good singer, I can say he is a good singer, I can say Sameer is absolutely not a singer, you can call him the best singer

Totally different from your current reply here, where you state the demerits of the Wildcard

A wild card has always been in the back pocket of Zee, we all who have watched it since C2005, know that is going to be in play at some point or the other, it was there in C2005, it was there in EMET, that is used to drive up the TRP's. If it was not Diwakar it would have been someone else, I am sure 100 different people would have argued against say a Neha if she came back thru a wildcard and ended up at #2

Again at this point if we want to discuss rule changes, we should be discussing "all" the rule changes not only 1

And I should make myself clear, I dislike "all" the rule changes. and I totally agree with that point of yours

I would have preffered them not invoke the wild card, but let us be realistic Zee would not have found another perfect opportunity to introduce public voting, and that is their bread and butter

Originally posted by: AznDesi

This Post is not about whos VOICE or SINGING YOu like better. Bob da is Saying why is ZEE CHANGING THE FORMAT TO MAKE MONEY FOR THEM.

Thank you so much.

Originally posted by: Qwest

Point and my thought why we are lowering the stander by doing all these, yes they need to make money no problem but they also need to keep the stander and the dignity of that SARAGAMAPA stage. Cannot keep changing there decision.

Yes Bob da I agree with you on this. I wish Sameer was not included in the contest as the 11th contestant, and Diwakar was not called back. Then the 4th and 5th ranked contestants would have been the 2nd and 3rd ranked contestant. In that case we could have seen the final between Sanchita, Pawni and Abhro.

If that had happened then it would have been a final between talents, instead being a contest between talent, cuteness, and sympathy.

Originally posted by: Qwest

Jaya my point is the format do you think that was right. I think Pawni and Abro deserve more to get that wild card.In fact they could've seen the opportunity here and may be planned for a special talent show for physically challenged.

Should never have a Physically Challenged in a Competition like SRGMP it always sways the Judgement and Votes. Then again Discrimination is also not welcome SO WHAT is the SOLUTION?? lets change the TOPIC and figure if there is a Soulution? what you guys think on that? Should Physcially challenged participants be allowed in a competition with participants with no disabilities? If you think it is not allowed then people will label you as Discriminating which is also wrong so lets all brain storm and hear solutions.

Thanx 😛

Originally posted by: AznDesi

Dats your judgement Jayadi but the 10 lakh other people who didnt vote for Abhro , Pawni and Shraddha thought otherwise we cant argue with the public. About Sameer bein out in the Final 3 yes i agree he should have been. It wouldnt have affected him 1 bit since he still came in third. There is no real justification to that. I think they let him stay cuz Gaji wanted more money and maybe thought of the entertainment / performance factor for the finale.

Right on Ron - Sameer was allowed to be in the finals of the show because that would get more votes for Gajji and team for the finals... Calling back the 6th finalist was based on the similar strategy.. introducing public voting in the finals was again for roping in money... Dont even know if Abhro and Pawni were actually voted out... We had the final 3 as they were may be because Sanchita, Sameer and Diwakar was possibly the best combination to get max votes... They were all from different places - so votes splittage would be minimum, and they had all some emotional factors attached along with musical factors too...

If they had not changed the rules, and had continued with judges voting, I guess we would have seen the best finale with Sanchita, Abhro and Pawni fighting it out for the top honor and that would have been a musical treat for one and all....