The gimmick of Zee TV.!!!! - Page 5

Originally posted by: Modesty

Qwestji, you r right. Once an avid fan of SRGMP (Sonu nigam days) now I have almost stopped watching this show. Gajengra singh should have left the show untouched. This show used to be a sheer delight for true music lovers. He should have introduced some other show if he wanted to mint money. But he chose an unethical route. Clubbing Diwakar with other singers made them look hapless.

I agree on this..I too have been a fan old Sa Re Ga Ma sice Sonu Nigam days and has been my favourite pgm ever since..I still love the programme but wish they could do away with the public voting system..I am happy that Sanchitha won it(at least some one who deserved won it unlike the other programmes)..But Abro or Pawni could have been the other two final contestants..Sameer is a good inger too..

Originally posted by: sareg

Sorry guys(and gals, Jayaji was also involved), my apologies, we all know whose corner we all are in. So I guess all of us over-reacted to a valid argument

My apologies

But it is good discussion for all of us some good Ideas and thought's came out of it. No I do not think any one went overboard in these discussion it is always good to have respectable discussion and that helps.

Originally posted by: Nandiv

I agree on this..I too have been a fan old Sa Re Ga Ma sice Sonu Nigam days and has been my favourite pgm ever since..I still love the programme but wish they could do away with the public voting system..I am happy that Sanchitha won it(at least some one who deserved won it unlike the other programmes)..But Abro or Pawni could have been the other two final contestants..Sameer is a good inger too..

Hi Nandiv thanx for your opinion bud. But please please please a kind request yaar this post is not for who you think should have been top 3 , it is not for who is better who is worst, it is not for who is derserving who is un derserving, It is about do you agree with ZEE NEW SHOW FORMAT OF CHANGING THE RULES IN MIDDLE OF THE PROGRAM. ZEE BRINGING IN NEW RULES , ZEE INTRODUCING PUBLIC VOTING etc... that is the point of this thread.

Keep well yaar.

Originally posted by: Qwest

But it is good discussion for all of us some good Ideas and thought's came out of it. No I do not think any one went overboard in these discussion it is always good to have respectable discussion and that helps.

Bob da i think we still need to brain storm. Cuz by just us wondering here the SHOW FORMAT wont change bro. This thing will happen again in Challenge 07, it will happen in Zee cine stars ki khoj, It will happen in next Lil champs and EMAT. Those of us who CANT ACCEPT this new changes wouldnt it be better to find a new program? Or if you are still gonna watch it cant we just accept the Changes and move on with it?? instead of slandering the contestant dat did make it whom we didnt think worthy or deserving etc..

what ya think?

Originally posted by: Modesty

Qwestji, you r right. Once an avid fan of SRGMP (Sonu nigam days) now I have almost stopped watching this show. Gajengra singh should have left the show untouched. This show used to be a sheer delight for true music lovers. He should have introduced some other show if he wanted to mint money. But he chose an unethical route. Clubbing Diwakar with other singers made them look hapless.

I think in the earlier days when Sanjeevani sang , the show was named SA RE GA MA. This one is SA RE GA MA PA. He did indeed introduce a new show!

Bobda, I agree that the format should not be changed and that these wild card entry participants should not be allowed... But when they have introduced this format everywhere in the reality shows, we have accepted it... But this wasnt done just to bring Diwakar inside the contest...

Now days wild card entry have become a norm for reality shows... How would Zee know who will be eliminated after the public voting starts? So, they had to bring in wild card entry before in hand along with public voting... I wouldn agree that Diwakar is in because of the sympathy... He has his own talent and he sings from the heart... Now, is it Diwakar's fault that he is physically challenged? There may be a contestant who is physically challenged and yet wins a competition(but he deserves it) so, would we say he won because of the sympathy?

The Top 3 for me are Pawni, Abhro and Sanchita.. But still when we have accepted public voting - we cannot help it.. Diwakar has improved himself a lot - esp we can see that during the last 4-5 episodes.. His mausam ki adla badli just brought in tears to many of our eyes... And he deserved this 2nd position among the 3 finalists... Diwakar took it as a challenge to sing fast songs and he proved himself.. We should praise him for that...