Rank and Rate 28th April Performances!

Poll

who was the best?

Login To Vote
-Seraphic- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

MY RATINGS BASED ON SINGING ONLY:

BOYS:

1) Vishwas - 10/10

2) Sharib - 9/10

3) Hrishikesh - 9/10

4) Aishwarya - 7/10

5) Irfan - 7/10

6) Rajeev - 6.5/10

GIRLS:

1) Ujjaini - 10/10

2) Sinchan - 9/10

3) Twinkle - 9/10

4) Sanchali - 8.5/10

5) Prajakta - 8/10

6) Banjyotsna - 8/10

AVERAGE FROM THE ABOVE RATINGS:

1) Twinkle & Vishwas - 9.5/10

2) Hrishikesh & Prajakta - 8.5/10

3) Sharib & Banjyotsna - 8.5/10

4) Ujjaini & Aishwarya - 8.5/10

5) Irfan & Sinchan - 8/10

6) Rajeev & Sanchali - 7.5/10

MY ANALYSIS:

Twinkle and Vishwas were mind-blowing. Vishwas simply blew me away with his singing. He was too good today. Hats off to him! Twinkle sang very well. But ofcourse Vishwas was much better than Twinkle. The good point was that Vishwas had more part to sing than Twinkle. I really liked both of them singing today. Overall, a superb performance!

Sharib and Banjyotsna were very good. Sharib sang well, he started off brilliantly. Banjo sounded good too. But then she forgot some lines in between and sharib had to cover it well. Anyways still it was a good performance.

Ujjaini and Aishwarya were amazing today. Both sounded very good together. It was really great hearing them. Ujjaini was superb, was very good on high notes. Aishwarya also sang well, but should give up his habit of taking annoying air breaths. Overall, a very good performance!

Irfan and Sinchan were good but not as good as judges made them. I have to say Sinchan was really very good today. Be it high notes or low, she rocked them all. She was energetic while singing and was mind-blowing. Coming to irfan, he lacked the energy of the song, and was a bit dull while singing. But sur-wise he was good. I wanted him to sing more well. Today, Sinchan was much better than irfan. Overall, an enjoyable performance!

Prajakta and Hrishikesh, sounded very sweet as always. But still Prajakta has got the problem to go shrill on high notes. I hope she works on it and then she will be really good to hear. While, Hrishikesh sang very well. I liked his singing like always. But only if Prajakta sing more well, they will be a perfect couple. Overall, a good and soothing performance!

Rajeev and Sanchali were so good. This time i agree with the judges Rajeev's sur wasnt right at all. His voice didnt match up with the song well. Sanchali was good and much better than Rajeev. Overall, a good performance!

Edited by red rose! - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

47

Views

3.2k

Users

21

Frequent Posters

sumesh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
1) Twinkle & Vishwas - 10/10 Claps to Vishwas !!!

2) Irfan & Sinchan - 9/10 Claps to Sinchan

3) Prajakta & Hrishikesh - 8/10 Claps to Hrishikesh

4) Ujjaini & Aishwarya - 7/10 Claps to Ujjaini

5) Sharib & Banjyotsna - 6/10 Only for Sharib

6) Rajeev & Sanchali - 5/10 Only for Sanchali


I feel Rajeev & Banjyotsana weakest among guys & gals !!!

Raina101 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
1- Twinkle and Vishwas-10/10
they were too good..individually i wouldnt rate twinkle 10/10 but vishwas compensated for her.... together they were brilliant...bishwas was fantastic...

2- Sinchan and Irfan 8.5/10
Sinchan deserves 10/10 she was amazing in todays performance...Irfan sang well too but somewhere in between his throat seemed to give him problems...otherwise they would probably share the number spot with TV... great chemistry

3- Ujjaini and Aishwarya 8/10
Great performance from them and consistently...i must say they compliment each other perfectly..only gotta work on the chemistry..other than that great performance..unfortunately for them TV and SI overhsadowed them today

4- Hrishikesh and Prajakta- 7.5/10
They sang very well as usual, though i believe they couldve chosen a better song more suited to their style..but they did justice to wat they chose...dunno why votes seem to be eluding them. they need to connect with the audience..other than that singing was flawless

5- Banjyotsna and Sharib 7/10
They were good...Sharib was better than Banj, but somehow they lacked what the other jodis had.... today their performance seemed mediocre in comparison...but if i look at it individually they were very good.
a bit more and they cud be at number 1...

6- Sanchali and Rajeev 4/10
Sanchali , i never liked her as a singer... i think she can only sing a particular genre...no versatality..today her voice seemed a bit too shrill.. Rajeev was awful...no sense of rhythm...but extremely lucky to get all these compliments...
SHUBHAMSG thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
NOBODY can criticise SHARIB it seems ..even if he gives a completely awful performance..Today he was BAD ..
Oh and BTW ..SHARIB forgot the lines not BONJYOTSNA ..BONJYOTSNA made a total mess of the tracks but she managed to remember the song ..also the feel of the song was totally absent.. as was also the power of KISHORE DA'S voice ....
-Seraphic- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

NOBODY can criticise SHARIB it seems ..even if he gives a completely awful performance..Today he was BAD ..
Oh and BTW ..SHARIB forgot the lines not BONJYOTSNA ..BONJYOTSNA made a total mess of the tracks but she managed to remember the song ..also the feel of the song was totally absent.. as was also the power of KISHORE DA'S voice ....

i think sharib wasnt bad, he was pretty good 😊

and yes sharib didnt forget the lines, banjo herself says in the green room that it was all her mistake, she forgets the lines and sharib was jst trying to cover it up.

SHUBHAMSG thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
Otherwise SHARIB might have just gone berserk on her .... I think she was more influenced by fear more than anything ..Yes SHARIB was BAD ..this is not his type of song at all ..his voice doesn't have the power or punch to be in KISHORE DA's field ..he would have been better off with a RAFI song ....though I dont know whether RAFI has any of BAPPI DA'S song .... I didn't praise SAPTAK when he did not perform well ..neither should you with your favourite ..just accept the fact that SHARIB was BAD today ..
-Seraphic- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

Otherwise SHARIB might have just gone berserk on her .... I think she was more influenced by fear more than anything ..Yes SHARIB was BAD ..this is not his type of song at all ..his voice doesn't have the power or punch to be in KISHORE DA's field ..he would have been better off with a RAFI song ....though I dont know whether RAFI has any of BAPPI DA'S song .... I didn't praise SAPTAK when he did not perform well ..neither should you with your favourite ..just accept the fact that SHARIB was BAD today ..

if im not mistaken u supported saptak even when he wasnt good like "u r my soniya" and "maahi ve"

im supporting sharib today not bcos he was bad but bcos i think he was good 😊

*Jaya* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

Otherwise SHARIB might have just gone berserk on her .... I think she was more influenced by fear more than anything ..Yes SHARIB was BAD ..this is not his type of song at all ..his voice doesn't have the power or punch to be in KISHORE DA's field ..he would have been better off with a RAFI song ....though I dont know whether RAFI has any of BAPPI DA'S song .... I didn't praise SAPTAK when he did not perform well ..neither should you with your favourite ..just accept the fact that SHARIB was BAD today ..

Objection Objection - How can you say that Rafi saab did not have power, Shubham? 😕 Rafi saab was the most powerful voice ever....

SHUBHAMSG thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
Hello ..I did not say that RAFI does not have voice power ....I said that SHARIB did not have the type of voice power which is in the area of KISHORE KUMAR ..He has the type of voice power which is nearer to RAFI .... You have interpreted the post wrongly ..
SAPTAK has voice power which is KISHORE DA derived
VINIT has voice power which is RAFI derived ..
I meant to say THIS ..
saregama thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

I think Shubham must have not come out of yesterday's shock where SAPTAK got eliminated..... 😉 😆 😆😆 So he is bashing Sharib...😛😆

Shubham, I will really let you know next week if Sharib was really that bad........😃

RIGHT SHUBHAM??????? 😆


No offense my dear.......Just kidding to make you cool down and peaceful.... 😛

Edited by saregama - 19 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".