Vinit Straight Answers - Page 2

Originally posted by: selsynch

Thats becoz of politics within mentors and unnecessary hype.

well den do u mean 2 say dat da mentors giv marks acc. 2 how much hype a contestant is given

well den i dont think dey wud hav been chosen as mentors if dey dint know 2 giv deservin marks 2 da contestants

n about politics

do u think da other mentors were so foolish dat dey wud shower marks on vinit n let deir pupils get less marks dan vinit?

Originally posted by: bangboy

I still remember JL giving 10 for Hemu for his kawaali,where as HR giving 8

to hell with mentor's mentometer and their points .if you will count debu's point from day one till last date you will find that his total comes to less than even paresh (five performances total )but at the end of the day who is winner "DEBO" 😆

Originally posted by: bangboy

Do u think Hemu would have got 10 for Nahi samne,If it wasnt his last performance? (and if subhash Ghai wasnt the guest)

I am sure he wouldnt .(His Vande mataram deserved atleast 9,I dont mean to say Vinit dint deserve 8 for all is performance)

ya u r right hem shud hav got atleast 9

its a too difficult song n hem sang it beautifully

but he surely deservd da 10 he got 4 nahi saamne so all mentors gav him 10

Originally posted by: Sarkar

to hell with mentor's mentometer and their points .if you will count debu's point from day one till last date you will find that his total comes to less than even paresh (five performances total )but at the end of the day who is winner "DEBO" 😆

😆😆😆

u r right sarkar😆

Lets Hope for good music from all the contestants whether its Vinit or Debu or Hemu

Originally posted by: bangboy

Lets Hope for good music from all the contestants whether its Vinit or Debu or Hemu

ya i agree

but i can hope dat only frm vinit,hem,himani,sharib n nihira😊

I voted "No" for Vinit but that's only if the old SRGM judges system was incorporated, i.e. have various rounds, i.e. songs of judges choice, various genres, singing without music (don't remember this 1) and so on. with the 2005 judges round, only the mentors were selecting the songs so obviously the song selection masked a lot of the contestants' weakpoints.

In the new SRGMP maybe Vinit stood a chance but with the old one (the tougher one), I don't think so. The ones that might have made the top 4 would have been Nihira, Hema, Sharib, Debo. I didn't place Himani if versatility was stressed. abhijeet could have been the choice but his perforance in this challenge wasn't upto mark maybe due to other reasons.

😊

If judges were asked to be on the show, then Vinit would not have reached the final four...he is good but highly overrated and all of a sudden he has this bloated ego and so full of overconfidence..I doubt if he will make it with this kind of attitude.

Unfortunately, a lot of highly talented people are arrogant. It doesn't sound nice to us, but that's the way of the world. I dont' like his attitude and think age will help him. 17 yr old boys tend to be a bit like this.

But, The truth is Vinit scored the highest among all singers in C2005 and was the most consistent. We cant erase that fact. That's the reality and it was in front of public. Hype or no hype. We can't be hypothetical in a situation like this we have to look at reality.

However, I am glad he did not win only because this setback will be good for his maturity and talent. There are more things in life beyond being talented. Being Humble goes a long way.........

I think that Vinit wuld be the judges 1st choice, cuz lots of ppl already knew of him nd his potential, and was doing realy realy good. He onli started being bad is when they lipsynced nd he missed entrances or came in too early.


--~Random Balloon Dropper~--
*~*HAPPY HOLI*~*