Ismail-ji , I want to ask u ONE question

Ismail Darbar saab,

You said vote-out of Nihira was injustice. Sir i ask u, Who should have been voted out then?

WHO???

if not nihira, who??

i respect u as a music composer but dont u think what u said or did was complete non-sense?

i mean, WHAT was your point? u said nihira shouldnt have been voted out, so who should have been? debojit?
or is it vinit? or who?? u defnitely must have had someone in mind

id like to express my opinion to the members that ismailji seems to be a good person basically but has lost his sense here.

how can these people say 'thank u to assam for voting, vote more please'

what kind of regionalist behaviour is this. openly asking a particular state to vote, such a shameful thing.


and the worst thing is that we are USED TO IT now, we dont find it so bad to ask people of particular state to vote or thank the people of a state to have voted so much.

whats the point in this show now? looting innocent people's money(via sms) and gaining TRPs to the show.

SOME SAY MUSIC IS DIVINE, if it really is, then God will defnitiley punish zeetv, gajendra singh and the business partners for exploiting music so much for money and show popularity(TRPs)

bhai yeh question HR se poocho....vinit ne kaha na mujhe up waale vote nahi karte....kyon karenge..unme abhi bhi sanskriti baki hai..unko nahi poasand ki ek 17 saal ka baacha lov eki baat karein.........

nihira ke jagah vinit ko jana chahihe tha..agar hr love story wala khel nahi khelta..to kab tak chutti ho gayi hoti..arre woh to sharib ka 50 % bhi nahi hai.....ID jyaad asochta nahi hai..usko laga nihira ko jaan anahi chahihe tha...koi bhi nihira nahi....yeh sochne wwali batein hr se karo..usko music chod ke sab aata hai...

Originally posted by: monxx

Definately Debojit.
Not bashing..., but the performance of that EPISODE clearly indicated that.
Debojit was the weakest link on that episode. If you dont believe me watch yourself:
http://www.musicnmovies.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=2363

lo ek aur...bhagwan ne haath diya hai to kuch bhi type karo... aare kabhi to akal lagao...ab to video link de diya..ab to log sachai jaan jayenge....

jabardasti bsu likhna hai isliye jo man mein aayega likhenge..

Originally posted by: trueandlovely

Ismail Darbar saab,

You said vote-out of Nihira was injustice. Sir i ask u, Who should have been voted out then?

WHO???

if not nihira, who??

i respect u as a music composer but dont u think what u said or did was complete non-sense?

i mean, WHAT was your point? u said nihira shouldnt have been voted out, so who should have been? debojit?
or is it vinit? or who?? u defnitely must have had someone in mind

id like to express my opinion to the members that ismailji seems to be a good person basically but has lost his sense here.

how can these people say 'thank u to assam for voting, vote more please'

what kind of regionalist behaviour is this. openly asking a particular state to vote, such a shameful thing.


and the worst thing is that we are USED TO IT now, we dont find it so bad to ask people of particular state to vote or thank the people of a state to have voted so much.

whats the point in this show now? looting innocent people's money(via sms) and gaining TRPs to the show.

SOME SAY MUSIC IS DIVINE, if it really is, then God will defnitiley punish zeetv, gajendra singh and the business partners for exploiting music so much for money and show popularity(TRPs)

Vinit and Himani were not better then Nihira. And I would say this for Deboo too. So in my opinion it should have been either vinit or Himani who should have got eliminated in Nihira's place. Nihira was the best among all these top five contestants. In fact she should have been the winner of this challenge. But it was all because of poor public voting system and Himesh Reshamiya who has hyped vinit in such a way that the whole show got spoiled since the Agnipariksha round started. Sharib was way better then vinit. Sharib should have been there in vinit's place. In fact I would say that top four should have been:

NIHIRA

HEMA

SHARIB

DEBOO

Thats it.

Shaan should be voted out.

Originally posted by: sher_e_Punjab

bhai yeh question HR se poocho....vinit ne kaha na mujhe up waale vote nahi karte....kyon karenge..unme abhi bhi sanskriti baki hai..unko nahi poasand ki ek 17 saal ka baacha lov eki baat karein.........

nihira ke jagah vinit ko jana chahihe tha..agar hr love story wala khel nahi khelta..to kab tak chutti ho gayi hoti..arre woh to sharib ka 50 % bhi nahi hai.....ID jyaad asochta nahi hai..usko laga nihira ko jaan anahi chahihe tha...koi bhi nihira nahi....yeh sochne wwali batein hr se karo..usko music chod ke sab aata hai...

WAH BHAIJI WAH....
aapko lagta hai ki sochne samajhane ka kaam to sirf aap hi kar sakte hain..baaki sab to assam ke niwasi hain ? 😉

well...agar hr ko music nahin aata to phir saari film industry ki music sense ko deemak lag gaya hai .....becuz aaj in chaaron mentors mein se sab se zyaada films hr ke paas hi hain bhai jaan. Even subhash ghai jaise producer ne bhi hr ko hi apni film mein sign kiya hai. And if you go by the record every body is well aware that Mr subhash ghai has got those fine ears for music which come rarely to commercial film makers.

Samajh ki aap ki daad deni hi padegi. 17 saal ka bachcha aur itne saare contestants ko peechhe chor ke aaj sab se aage khda hai. kuchh aur chahiye kya iss bachche ki kabliyat ka saboot ??

ID is a great music director magar regionalism ko usi ne uksaaya hai.
remember in one episode he clearly said "....debojit ko sirf assam se voto mil rahe hain...bhayya mein gujraat ka hoon aur gujraat walon se kehta hoon ki debojit ko vote karen..agar gujraat aur assam mil gaye to debojit ko koi nahi hara sakta...."

Sir even ID was and still not very confident about his shishya's music calibre.

ab aur kya kahen.....!!!!! aap kafee samajhdaar lagten hain........

STARYAAR,
I just cant digest your point. Vinit ne baki sab ko piche choda is ki kai vajah hai aur un vajaha me ye nahi ke vinit accha gata hai. I can take u r challenge if u want to say vinit is a better singer than Nihira. Do you think so vinit could cross nihira as because vinit sing better than her??????

Originally posted by: sher_e_Punjab

bhai yeh question HR se poocho....vinit ne kaha na mujhe up waale vote nahi karte....kyon karenge..unme abhi bhi sanskriti baki hai..unko nahi poasand ki ek 17 saal ka baacha lov eki baat karein.........

nihira ke jagah vinit ko jana chahihe tha..agar hr love story wala khel nahi khelta..to kab tak chutti ho gayi hoti..arre woh to sharib ka 50 % bhi nahi hai.....ID jyaad asochta nahi hai..usko laga nihira ko jaan anahi chahihe tha...koi bhi nihira nahi....yeh sochne wwali batein hr se karo..usko music chod ke sab aata hai...

Are we talking abt this century or abt 18th century come on guys grow up

The reason why ID said Nihira's exit was not justified was very simple.According to him the whole process of elimination by voting is farce.Because a good singer may be voted out or a not so good singer voted in for reasons other than his/her singing abilty such as regionalism,and product selling(HR) etc.ID is the worst product seller.When Nihira was voted out he spoke against the public in a crude way.Where as the others both HR and AS always played to the gallery.