Vinit off key in Tum Mile - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

51

Views

5.3k

Users

21

Frequent Posters

tellus thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#41
Hello Qwerty... Good, you have started the basic lesson in typewriting... Now move back to the first line asdfgh;lkjhj and practice typing in few more posts... There is an exclusive topic out there for you guys..

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh



yes he was off note for a fraction of a second but then debo misses the same and even messes up pronunciation.. (HR pointed that out) so they even out.. Dont try to act the smart aleck along with Ms Sangeetaaji.. People are voting for undeserving debu without even listening to him.. thats like missing the whole wave-length!!!

unknowngal thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#42
Yeah i thought he went off tune too
biswita thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: sangeetaa



Well, as you say, we can all afford to be critics coz we're not up that
stage. But that's not the point. If we are judging the contest, our ears
have to be capable of picking up these things. India ki voice besura nahin
hona chahiye.

As for "all of them are besura" - as far as I'm concerned, there's a marked
difference between going slightly flat and slipping noticeably. Hema
might go a tiny bit - I mean minutely flat - and that too only on his bad
days - which are few. Debo has a greater chance of going flat - he
doesn't have as good control over his voice as Hema - but VINIT slipped
up on sur badly in that song.
(On Baar Baar Haan - Vint did better on sur, but had other problems - he
was not able to pick up or project his voice, he missed a line, and shouted
the high notes - although shouting worked ok in this particular song)

Now here is the thing that kept bothering me - this guy got FULL MARKS
on SRGMP after slipping this badly on something as basic as *sur*. I
almost started doubting my ears; that's why I posted. The potential harm
to the public is immeasurable. Public ko sur ki pehchaan na raha tho bura
hogaa, na?

Finally - please do not ever ever say that *I* called *Hema* *besura*.
Kasam se, mai tho heart attack se marjaoongi.

If you want to see Hema mess up you don' have to go back far...just watch the previous day R'day episode. If you want to see more, watch the BW episode. His other problem is diction. But he's good.

Debo has gone off so many times I've lost count. But sometimes he was perfect, and a treat to watch, esp with Jhumroo.

The only one who was near perfect was Nihira. BUT FOR GOODNESS SAKE NOT HEMA, he CANNOT be a role model.

tellus thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#44
Am proud to be my govt's servant. Wish you too are happy - in Afghanistan

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh




Oh tellus its so pleasing to know there is a stenographer opining... Get back to work and finish the document you started....or are u working in govt office?

Edited by tellus - 19 years ago
mdroy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#45
qwert:

you are getting stranger by the minute but it's ok -- I get a good laugh
😆 😆
ms04 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh



Vinit never failed on high notes.. tell lata mangeshkar to sing "Piya tu ab toh aaja" she will fail as well.. so what does your sensibility say she failed!!! Now keep your insensibilities to yourself dump the non-singer DEbo and support the winner!!! He evne has it in his name VIN-IT.... u understand WIN IT!!!!!!!!!



I never said he is not going to win-it. But that doesnt make him a better singer than hema,debo and nih...naah leave her outta it.
Dazlingflower thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#47
Vinit was off key. Actually what I observed was that he was singing very loud. There was not any softness to his voice. Just because you shout out of your lungs, doesn't mean that you are singing right. I don't know why HR was showing his gay gestures towards Vinit. He was okayyyyyyyy.
sangeetaa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: Shantibai

]i fully understand where you are coming from smith
corona loveryou want to gag us with the notion that this 3 ft chottoo with
a croak is the god send gift a panacea to our evils .......but you know
what ?some of us keep our heads screwed on our shoulders and
think ..........you know? THINK?have you tried it lately?Then you will see
transparently that Binita has messed up severally and the only thing that
keeps her faults camouflaged is h that Machiavelli Himesh who jumps like
a yo yo and defends his lost cause as though he was the messaiah sent
to release us Indians from our musical bonds as invesed from vedic times
............so off goes hindustani music carantick music . all the
gharanas ..........all the 10000 years of tapascharyaa an in comes the
music plagiarised from the pakistanis and the late Laxmikant
pyarelal.............😉



**somber applause**
sangeetaa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: biswita


The only one who was near perfect was Nihira. BUT FOR GOODNESS SAKE
NOT HEMA, he CANNOT be a role model.



Hema is not perfect but he has a solid foundation. I think the most solid of
all the male singers. In a few years, mark my words, he is going to be great.

And if our country is lucky enough to give rise to great composers in the
film industry, he will make his mark.

If not, then I hope Hemachandra keeps at Carnatic music. He has a lot to
offer its many fans in the future.
sangeetaa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh



Vinit never failed on high notes.. tell lata mangeshkar to sing "Piya tu ab
toh aaja" she will fail as well.. so what does your sensibility say she
failed!!! Now keep your insensibilities to yourself dump the non-singer
DEbo and support the winner!!! He evne has it in his name VIN-IT.... u
understand WIN IT!!!!!!!!!



Qwertyji - You are right about one thing. You said:

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

.. i am trying to get these ivory tower delusional
residents back to face off reality..



Yeh tho sach hai ke hum aisa reality face karna hi nahi chahthe jis me
logon ko sur se thoda hilna aur sur se bilkul phisalna ka pharak na pata
ho - jisme koi bhi sadak ka aadmi declare karega ke Lata-ji ya Jasjit-ji
kya gaa nahi sakte- jisme naak se ronewala koi aadmi ko sangeet gyaani
maanaa jaata hai.
Aisa zamana hum tho dekhna hi nahin chahte. Behtar hai ke hum
aankhen (aur kaanen bhi) bandh hi rakhe.

Aur rahi aapke pyaare Vinit ki baat - to quote somebody:
Voh bura singer nahin hain. Jitnaa aataa hai, utnaa gaataa hai. Aap ushi
ke liye vote kijiye.

Jai Ramji ki!
Edited by sangeetaa - 19 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".