WHoevr said Hemu cant sing at High Notes - Page 13

Originally posted by: srianne

Shame on all those people who resort to name (like blind and fantics) calling to prove their point.

To the genius who think we supporting Hema because we're south Indians...
Don't you think you're the one who can't see that Hema has fans all over India in this forum than just South India?. Just because someone started one thread "Hema's telugu fan club" out of the million threads in the forum doesn't mean we're all regionalists. It was started jsut for fun so that some of us could WISH and BLESS HIM in our own mother tongue. Was it a blunder? There are people everywhere in this forum writing in their own language, you think they're all regionalists too? I consider myself an INDIAN before even thinking which part of India I am from. You're the one dividing the country here as South Indian and rest of the country.

Also, for geniuses who suddenly started call themselves Hema's fans now after he's out - please give us a break. He doesn't need your sympathy.

wah re wah.....kya kaha aapne.........👏👏

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Okay, this is the heights.

I've been accused of things I never said on this thread

1) Varshaji and Parneetha have been hinting that I said that Hemu can't sing t high notes. If you have the guts, sya my name out aloud. If you had bothered to read my analysis carefully, I only said Hemu lacks a certain finesse at high notes. What's wrong in that? Ask Nirajji, Bhaktada, Tansenji, appa rao...any one who's a trained musician, they'll tell you the same

2) Parineeta, i am certain you never read anything fully. Show me where I said Vande Mataram is an easy song that's why ARR sang it, and I promise I'll never, in my life, talk about music another day. That's a promise 'cross my heart. Infact, one of my friends said it, and i refuted them openly. Vande Mataram is a difficult song to sing, and Hema sang it exceptionally well.

3) Vande Mataram as a song has absolutely no Taans. Please don't brand any harkat as a taan. A taan is a totally different thing
Taan = a melodic passage of notes from all three octaves specific to a raga interwoven to a fast tempo which echo the imagination and command of a singer. Vande Mataram does not have taans. Shall I tell you why? Because ARR sang it. ARR is a singer trained in the Carnatic Style. Taans are a concept specific to the Hindustani style. Yes, there are NO taans in carnatic music. Hence, any carnatic vocalist doesn't sing taans.
Whereas Na To Karvaan has 2 taans...once when the tempo dies after the last 'Laaj rakho more ghunghat pat ki' and after Rafi finishes 'Inteha yeh hai ki bande ko khuda karta hai ishq'...after that, Mannada starts off in the Gamak-Taan to finish the song. There are very few songs where Taans have been incorporated. The ones which come to mind are - Madhuban mein radhika, prem jogan ban ke, aaj gawat man mero, ketaki gulab juhi, na to karvan ki talash, lapak jhapak tu aa re badarwa, jhanak jhanak tori baaje (just a small bol-taan)

Get your facts right before you bash people.

And yeah, i don't need to, but seeing this bitterness on this thread, I'll reiterate what i've always maintained. I am a Sharib-Hema-Nihira-Swanada fan. My close friends on this forum know it. Now that Hema is out, I'll support Debo wholeheartedly.

Pah.. 😡

First of all, thanks for letting me know the diff between Taan and Harkat, i thought both are same when i was talking about Vandemataram. As i have always said, i have never theoritically learned music, but have a good ear for great music.

Comming to the other parts of ur post i would say that , Aaap apne khamiyan doosro mein nikalnein me mahir ho and thas when u said "Parineeta, i am certain you never read anything fully". This is what ur friends said and this is what i said , i'm specifically quoting it hear cause u definetly dont read all the posts

Originally posted by: parineetha

Hats off to both of you for ur guesses but sorry guys ur wrong, its not dwaraknath that i was reffering too. I really liked his analysis of Hema. Infact he is one who is a bit unbaised in his analysis. But one thing i disagree in his analysis is Debos voice is better than Hema's. But thats his personal choice, so i will not comment on that.

And also ur are very good at using bad words too, though u had edited them later i had already read it.

This is for Ruby_bindas, just because some person does not know the jargon in music does not mean they dont know anything about music. If u think so , then probaly ur underestimating others. Just because i like Hemas singing a lot and not Debos as much does not make me less knowledgebale that you.

Originally posted by: parineetha

First of all, thanks for letting me know the diff between Taan and Harkat, i thought both are same when i was talking about Vandemataram. As i have always said, i have never theoritically learned music, but have a good ear for great music.

Comming to the other parts of ur post i would say that , Aaap apne khamiyan doosro mein nikalnein me mahir ho and thas when u said "Parineeta, i am certain you never read anything fully". This is what ur friends said and this is what i said , i'm specifically quoting it hear cause u definetly dont read all the posts

And also ur are very good at using bad words too, though u had edited them later i had already read it.

This is for Ruby_bindas, just because some person does not know the jargon in music does not mean they dont know anything about music. If u think so , then probaly ur underestimating others. Just because i like Hemas singing a lot and not Debos as much does not make me less knowledgebale that you.

And also Dwarakanath, i really dont need to know whome u support, that is entirely ur preference. Debos fans might need it, not me.