Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 14

Poll

Do you think it was right on part of Vineet, Hema & Himani to walk out

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

737

Views

175.6k

Users

389

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

gauri_sharma15 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
They made this special singing contest show into a cheap desi drama. The truth is if people were truly voting for best singers, this would not happen. This only shows that our Indian people are still fighting with each other reagionally; and this public voting prooved it. Instead of honestly choosing a good singer from INDIA. People want someone from their region/cast to win. And Debo's mentor's ego is playing a big role also in this hungama; Even Ismael knows Debo's didn't sing well and knew he would be out & that's why he walked out; and took a final cheap shot to gain public sympathy.

And YES... Hamachandra, Himani & Vinit did the right thing by walking out; Only a truthful person will do what they did and that's not to stand by watch injustice. Sure its upsetting that they are doing this; but its the right thing to do!

And Debo also knows he didn't sing well that day and he is not better then Hamachandra, himani, or Vinit; If he was truthful about his singing he would've oppted out of the contest. And even more; when Nihra was there; Debo should've be then one gone; Ismael has built Debo up too much and now his Ego is involved.

I think they should bring back Nihira and cancel the public voting. Then start another round with the 5 contestants and have knowledgable judges do the selection.
gauri_sharma15 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: enigma007

What justification you are talking about ??? HR voicing Vineet's love everytime??? ISn't it a technique for fetching votes??? If there's a public voting concept added then all the contestant needs to respect that else they cud have walked out long time back.

Debo is a Con-Artist more than a singer.

enigma007 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

how are u judging them????? By the mentor's comment, it is purely biasing thoughts of YOU alone

jktw thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
The issue is aptly described and I feel that what these three have done was completely unnecessary and it shows bad taste.Being somewhat senior to these guys,my suggestion is that you have to accept lot of things and you can not just walk out from those situations that too forming a curtail kind of thing.These guys were telling that they had a discussion on it before and that itself is alarming to me.To become a winner,one should learn to accept defeat and when you are not the judge,you can not help how things will be decided.We have seen it ample no of times in different fields and this at all does not show sportsman spirit in them.It is their audacity,their Ghamand (that they felt they were better than Debojit) that was controlling them.It was also bad to see that Vinit's relatives were having a bad discussion with Debojit's wife.I guess,at the end of the day,this incident made these three unpopular from where they used to stand in public mind.They should not have done it or should have discussed with some seniors before taking such a audacious step on national television.It might jeopardize their carrers.I am also baffled why did they wait till result about Vinit was declared and why didn't they do what they did as soon as result about Debojit was declared.
lonely_star thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: gauri_sharma15

They made this special singing contest show into a cheap desi drama. The truth is if people were truly voting for best singers, this would not happen. This only shows that our Indian people are still fighting with each other reagionally; and this public voting prooved it. Instead of honestly choosing a good singer from INDIA. People want someone from their region/cast to win. And Debo's mentor's ego is playing a big role also in this hungama; Even Ismael knows Debo's didn't sing well and knew he would be out & that's why he walked out; and took a final cheap shot to gain public sympathy.

And YES... Hamachandra, Himani & Vinit did the right thing by walking out; Only a truthful person will do what they did and that's not to stand by watch injustice. Sure its upsetting that they are doing this; but its the right thing to do!

And Debo also knows he didn't sing well that day and he is not better then Hamachandra, himani, or Vinit; If he was truthful about his singing he would've oppted out of the contest. And even more; when Nihra was there; Debo should've be then one gone; Ismael has built Debo up too much and now his Ego is involved.

I think they should bring back Nihira and cancel the public voting. Then start another round with the 5 contestants and have knowledgable judges do the selection.

I wud like to say that ...its not the ego of Ismail...which is a hurdle..Im also a fan of vineet...but dont u think HIMESH IS TOO PARTIAL ON PART OF VINEET?😡Thats really disgusting to see Himesh...backing vineet as a loverboy and stuff...this show is all set to put vineet as the winner...pleas mind that also..dont u think Nihira deserved a win...In the whole contest I dint see her miss a 'sur'....

P.S:Im an avid fan of both Himesh and Vineet...but i dont like the partiality done By H.R😡

jktw thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
Completely agree with lonely_star.I hope somehow these three read what is being discussed here.
lonely_star thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
DOnt ut hink the mentores knew abt the "alleged" walk-out?...its drama by H.R and Adesh...they cant accept defeat...whatever...the results...are u need to accept it...wether its regional voting or not..u shud have the guts to go to a challenge and...if u quit cheaply...unless ur dead 😆 ur a cheap coward....till now these ppl dint doubt on voting....suddenly they r getting doubt on votes??? 😡
rpavan thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

If debo had got hightest percentage of votes who got the second and third highest votes
did they showed that in show
jktw thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
Public voting is another bad judging process and the way Shaan used to request the contestants to woo voters on regional basis was not right.For such high level of contest,judging should have been done by eminent experts in the field.I gave this feedback before and again standing by it.
rpavan thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
The best thing is to stop public voting and have different rounds for the singers and judge the final 3
They should bring in some very good singers/directors as judges

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".