Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 15

Poll

Do you think it was right on part of Vineet, Hema & Himani to walk out

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

737

Views

175.7k

Users

389

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

rpavan thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Also the mentors should not be allowed to talk to the judges.
otherwise even when Kapil came in he was telling that Himesh had told about Vineet and vineet is like sachin and all blah blah. Its really disgusting to do so on a contestant showing so much partiality.
I would really support ismail and adesh for not being partial and they give high points to other ocntestants based on performance.
mitr_2804 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: lonely_star

DOnt ut hink the mentores knew abt the "alleged" walk-out?...its drama by H.R and Adesh...they cant accept defeat...whatever...the results...are u need to accept it...wether its regional voting or not..u shud have the guts to go to a challenge and...if u quit cheaply...unless ur dead 😆 ur a cheap coward....till now these ppl dint doubt on voting....suddenly they r getting doubt on votes??? 😡

sorry to interupt but i dun not agree with u....this is a challenge but a singing challenge n not regional challenge...the best singer is supposed to b chosen n not the best regional supporter of sumthin fo tht stuff.....debo can in jus bcuz of regional votes n not his talent...NE ppl voted him jus bcuz he was frm their region n tht is the most digusting thing on earth..... many ppl belive tht the other 3 who revolted were a zillion times better than debo n tht not fair....

jus imagine urself in tht place n see even u wud do the same... being a good singer its a shameful thing to loose against a baseless singer.....debo is a true baseless singer..the other 3 deserve more than him......

n regarding HR y blame or punish vinit for HR ...... its always HR who brings his luv in between n not him......plz think over it..

think properly n vote cuz every vote counts n ur vote cud make a huge differnce in sum1 future...

as215 thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: asha rao

If u feel debo used regional support what about hema 'thappa kunda vote '

PriyaS thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

I think it was ridiculous that Vineet, Himani and Hemachandra walked out. If anything, this will sway the public vote even further in Debojit's favour. Debojit obviously appeals to the public, and the more criticism he gets from the mentors, the more votes he receives. This incident will only bolster his public support.

As for Himani, Vineet and Hemachandra - on entering the competition, they were cognisant of the fact that the winner would be decided by a public vote. I don't think it was their place, as contestants, to decide that Debojit didn't deserve the public vote and walk out. It is common knowledge, that in such contests, the winner might not necessarily be the best singer. By walking out, and making a farce of the competition, they have handed victory to Debojit, and disappointed their legion of fans.

Edited by PriyaS - 19 years ago
neha9 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: PriyaS

I think it was ridiculous that Vineet, Himani and Hemachandra walked out. If anything, this will sway the public vote even further in Debojit's favour. I think he has always had the "underdog" vote.

As for Himani, Vineet and Hemachandra - on entering the competition, they were cognisant of the fact that the winner would be decided by a public vote. I don't think it was their place, as contestants, to decide that Debojit didn't deserve the public vote and walk out.

Debojit did or didn't deserve the votes, I dont know. But, it was obvious that only one place is voting for him non stop. It explanes how many people want him to become the winner.

dangenil thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: madhu_vemula

To some extent Zee tv and shan are responsible for encoraging audiance for voting on the regional basis.

U r wrong! Thanks to Zee TV who actually shown us the truth behind the public voting & now onwards no one believe on public voting in any kind of show (Indian Idol / Nach Baliye / Laughter Challenge/...) The older format of SaReGaMaPa was perfect & I am sure Gajendraji go back to his original format after end of this show. Still hats off to Gajendraji who handle such kind of sensitive show for last 9-10 years.

hemusin thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
dekho bhai logo y to galat baat hai ki kisis ko 80/ vote mily to kyaa huaa kisi ek admi to usy sary vote nahi diy naa yaa ismail darbar n to nahi naa sary vote diy vote to aam janta n diy to in tino ko kyaa muskil hue agar vote 80 vote asam s aye hai ho sakta thaa ki vinit or himani or hema ko bhi utany hi vote miltay par ab esaa nahi lag rhaaa y to esaa hi lag rhaa hai ki ismail jo kah rhaa hai baisa hi ho rhaa hai m ismail s sehamat hun jab unony vinit ko puchaa ki tum kyaa sochty ho ki tum achaa gaty ho or yaa tum har baar first aogy agar humari baat chalti to m to yahi khata hun ki tino agar nahi gana thaa to bho show m aye hi kyaun unko thaa ki aaj debojit bhaar ho jaygaa or y teen hi rah jayng par esaa nahi huaa kyunki debojit is no. 1 aya to tino n sochaa ki ab nahi gaana hai to darama suru kar diyaa himani vnit hema y tino kya sochty hai ki india ki abaj ko y bevkuf samjty hai jo itnaa vote karty kal bola thaa ki 70 laakh vote paddy hai to log kyaa india ki janta ko pagal samjty jo itnaa vote karty hai jab y teeno y bol rahy hai ki nhira jab bhaar hue to humy tab jodd dena thaa to ab tak kyaa kar rahy thy inki nind kyaa ab khuli meri to yahi ray hai ki apnaa vote soch k dena kisi esay singar ko denaa ki bho us vote ka hakdaar ho nahi to in tenno ki tarh nahi pahly ek bolti hai ki m gamndi na ho jau to y kyaa thaa
janta ki kyaa ray mujy nahi pata hai jnata khud dekhti hai ki kisy vote milnaa chaiy or kisy nahi . meri to yahi ray hai ki kal jo tino n kiy us k liy to in tino ko bhar kar nhira or debojit k bich m fasla hona chaiy
in tenno n bahut hi galt kiyaa hai y bol k nhony kya soch kar bolaa or kyaun bolaa ek pal k liy to mujy esaa laga i y debojit ko jitany k liy bola rahy hai jab pata chla ki y tino to debojit ko 80 vote milny ki bajah s bol rahy hai to esaa dil kar rhaa thaa ki in tino ko pakad k bhaar bithaa dun jaky

hemu
lonely_star thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: mitr_2804

sorry to interupt but i dun not agree with u....this is a challenge but a singing challenge n not regional challenge...the best singer is supposed to b chosen n not the best regional supporter of sumthin fo tht stuff.....debo can in jus bcuz of regional votes n not his talent...NE ppl voted him jus bcuz he was frm their region n tht is the most digusting thing on earth..... many ppl belive tht the other 3 who revolted were a zillion times better than debo n tht not fair....

jus imagine urself in tht place n see even u wud do the same... being a good singer its a shameful thing to loose against a baseless singer.....debo is a true baseless singer..the other 3 deserve more than him......

n regarding HR y blame or punish vinit for HR ...... its always HR who brings his luv in between n not him......plz think over it..

think properly n vote cuz every vote counts n ur vote cud make a huge differnce in sum1 future...

SORRY BOSS...u cant say....that coz..u say that HR and vineet r not b blamed....they r the conspiracy creators...who knws is vineets loverboy image a cheap tacti for creation of votes! all this is a drama...I personally think Nihira Joshi was the only "clean minded" contestant in the final round.

P.S.1:Im also an avid fan of H.R and vineet but the current trends in this show....is too bad in taste...P.S.2:these are only my views no HARD FEELINGS PLZZ👏

Joey13 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
These three are simply trying to gather sympathy something we know artists never should. An artist lives for the love of the art and not for public stunts. They have let down all the people who voted for them.

And for what ? we all know what Adesh and Himesh were doing, trying to put down Debo. Thet have let their singers to feel that they are bettersingers getting less votes.Some of them have given very poor performances out of over confidence.

at Debo has been an artist and a MAN!!
jyotimehta2 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago


<B><size=6>In my opinion the walk out from Vinieet, Hema and Himani was appropriate, It looks like public voting is creating mess and Sa re ga ma is loosing its dignity and creditability



I think they should bring back Nihira and cancel the public voting. Then start another round with the 5 contestants and have knowledgeable judges do the selection.</size></B>

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".