Agnipariksha final 4 results- 19/01/06 - Page 6

If anyone is to be blamed for all the drama it is AS and HR. I agree that Debojit did not sing as well as other 3 but he deserved better than what points he got from 2 mentors. AS and HR gave 6 and 7 points to Debojit. It backfired and he got the most votes.
As for one getting votes from a particular place it is bound to happen. Everyone knows it. Himani telling Haryanavasi or Paresh saying in Gujarati etc. They all expect voting to be like that

Pankaj

Too bad very sad.
Questions:
Didnt the 12 contestants know that they would be chosen by the public? Werent they OK with it?
😳 I remember Himani asking for NCR(didnt even know what it meant) votes, Hema asking for South votes, Rajiv appealing in Gorkhali to vote for him and HR asking Paresh to beg for votes in Gujarati.
Dont remember Vinit or Debo asking for regional votes though. But I have heard Debo thanking his vote bank quite a few times.
🤢 Now what is so hue and cry over 80% votes? Take any contestant. Count his/her votes from highest 7 states. Trust me 80% wont be a surprising number. When you talk of NE, its 7 states. Looks like they have their geography screwed up. 😉
Looks to me AS is the mastermind. WHile everyone else were trying to calm the arrogant contestants down, AS was fanning the fire with his vote stats.

SOLUTION: If nothing comes right, declare Debo the winner and ban the 3 from SRGMP forever. Thats in GS's hands. Let them find laurels thru FG or II. GOOD LUCK.

Hi all,

I live in the US and have been enjoying this show for many years now. I was truely disappointed when Sharib lost after singing well, rakhtima lost after singing well and then Nihira. CLearly Nihira sang her song excellently, Himani or for that matter any other female singer could not have done justice to that song, though they are good at what they can sing. But well, she did not get the votes. I personally think contestants should not be allowed to talk about their personal life and troubles. Every one i struggling and has some story to tell. It is a singing competition and should be judged purely on that merit and not on sympathy or caste. I wish the audience was mature enough to support the best vocalist. No doubt all have talent. But who made the least errors and who sang flawlessly ? I think if we all think about it honestly we know the answers. I read that somebody said they would support Debu because he is from NE. Well support him may be post challenge if he releases an album, by buying it. Is it worth winning this challenge and encouraging a contestant to make mistakes? So now more singers from NE will participate, thinking that they can get away with the votes, some may be genuinely good, some may not be! I do not think the trio (Vinit, hema. himani) did anything wrong in voicing their discontent. I do not say that Debu is bad. Well, last time was not his best. Clearly the other three were better. I think that it should not be purely janta. But I think it should also be by some distinguished musicians like Shiv-Hari or Asha Bhonsle. Or the contestants should be made to sing the same song difficiult or easy. That will clearly say who is better.

Apologies if I offend any one!... These are just my views.

-Dee

Hi all,

I live in the US and have been enjoying this show for many years now. I was truely disappointed when Sharib lost after singing well, rakhtima lost after singing well and then Nihira. CLearly Nihira sang her song excellently, Himani or for that matter any other female singer could not have done justice to that song, though they are good at what they can sing. But well, she did not get the votes. I personally think contestants should not be allowed to talk about their personal life and troubles. Every one i struggling and has some story to tell. It is a singing competition and should be judged purely on that merit and not on sympathy or caste. I wish the audience was mature enough to support the best vocalist. No doubt all have talent. But who made the least errors and who sang flawlessly ? I think if we all think about it honestly we know the answers. I read that somebody said they would support Debu because he is from NE. Well support him may be post challenge if he releases an album, by buying it. Is it worth winning this challenge and encouraging a contestant to make mistakes? So now more singers from NE will participate, thinking that they can get away with the votes, some may be genuinely good, some may not be! I do not think the trio (Vinit, hema. himani) did anything wrong in voicing their discontent. I do not say that Debu is bad. Well, last time was not his best. Clearly the other three were better. I think that it should not be purely janta. But I think it should also be by some distinguished musicians like Shiv-Hari or Asha Bhonsle. Or the contestants should be made to sing the same song difficiult or easy. That will clearly say who is better.

Apologies if I offend any one!... These are just my views.

-Dee

Thanx pmahesh for that update..undoubtedly this is the darkest day in the history of this programme..no courage to face public's decision..contestants with such ego do not deserve to win the title of "India ki voice"..The reputation is completely gone..doesn't matter who wins..he /she will never be known for genuine singing ..VERY SAD STATE OF AFFAIRS AND A DARK DAY FOR MUSIC 😭 😭

Without doubt this is all orchestrated by the so called magical mentors..if one can create such drama and force young aspiring singers to opt for dirty politics..they can be nothing but MAGICAL 😊 😊

Priti,
First of all thk for the gr8 update. I m in USA and these news has broke my heart. Gajji and Shaan have to act like a man and put an end to this nonsense. These 3 participants can't team up aginst DEBU. When they got highest votes no one complained.

Public votes can't select a good singer. Mentors can't act in selfish mannor. They should evaluate the singers and HR should be fired from this show for being a cheap beggar. He should marry Vinit. AS needs to stop his cunningness and his fake smile. Why was AS requesting ppl to vote for Debu, after he gave him only 6 points?

They need to bring good judges to determine better singer and all must sing some tough and challenging songs. Vineet sings only famous and easy songs. HR kisses his behind and always criticizes DEBU.

PPL noticed these mind games and that is why they voted for Debu. ID also is some what responsible in praising more Vineet and Himani. These 2 have been pampered so much that they think they are the stars.

If you roll back the tapes and see the old performances, you all will agree that Raktima, NIHIRA and Swananda are far better singers than Himani.
Paresh and Sharib are good singers too. Rajeev was not so great. Hemachandra is good singer also. But now with this latest update I have no respect for Hemu, Himani and Vineet. I enjoyed this show for clean and nice songs.

Atlast, DEBU and NIHIRA should be the winners.

I think since the 3 contestants (Hema my choice , Vinit , Himani) have walked out Debojit should be declared the winner. What say guys ???

Originally posted by: musik05

Hi all,

I live in the US and have been enjoying this show for many years now. I was truely disappointed when Sharib lost after singing well, rakhtima lost after singing well and then Nihira. CLearly Nihira sang her song excellently, Himani or for that matter any other female singer could not have done justice to that song, though they are good at what they can sing. But well, she did not get the votes. I personally think contestants should not be allowed to talk about their personal life and troubles. Every one i struggling and has some story to tell. It is a singing competition and should be judged purely on that merit and not on sympathy or caste. I wish the audience was mature enough to support the best vocalist. No doubt all have talent. But who made the least errors and who sang flawlessly ? I think if we all think about it honestly we know the answers. I read that somebody said they would support Debu because he is from NE. Well support him may be post challenge if he releases an album, by buying it. Is it worth winning this challenge and encouraging a contestant to make mistakes? So now more singers from NE will participate, thinking that they can get away with the votes, some may be genuinely good, some may not be! I do not think the trio (Vinit, hema. himani) did anything wrong in voicing their discontent. I do not say that Debu is bad. Well, last time was not his best. Clearly the other three were better. I think that it should not be purely janta. But I think it should also be by some distinguished musicians like Shiv-Hari or Asha Bhonsle. Or the contestants should be made to sing the same song difficiult or easy. That will clearly say who is better.

Apologies if I offend any one!... These are just my views.

-Dee

i quite agree with you! nicely stated!

Hi simplyskud

Have you heard the saying " Money Talk ".Till now did not you get why Pmahesh is talking his time to update all this to this forum.

Actaully as you have know Hema's family has spent several lakhs of rupees to campaign for Hema.

PMahesh is one of the Hema campaigner in silent mode who received pretty good amount to campaign in this neutral forum.In one of Hema's mother interview she told that she has sept in buying cell phone,hire people for sending SMS and have paid people to campaign in internet.

So do not get surprised if you see many people indirectly forces and praises hema all they are paid tattu.

One more point I like to enlighten you Do you know why all 3 walked out when they are got sure that debu has chances of winning they got shocked as Dwarf Vinit's love trict did not work as he and HR tought people of India are iodit and fall in thier love trap .They spent several lakhs of rupees for cell phone and hiring people to SMS them in their favour..this made them walk out..

All these contestant should be kicked in the ASS and Gajaji should show them the Door and never should allow them to participate in any kind of contest.


I think Gaja Ji sholud call up meeting to all the TV Channel and banned them from participating any reality TV show in any Channel.

At this age who are even to smell test of success how they can be so rude and so over confident.Even people like rafi,Kishore, Lata never done this...

That Dwarf Visit for that he was out paled by Debu in the Sare Gama Fame 2005 in one to one contest none other than Pandit Jasraj..who is the ultimate man in music


Thanks and Regards
Rama

Since 3 of them quit and Debojit is disqualified because he got 80% votes from North East, then its simple: Nihira is the winner. 3 cheers for Nihira, she rocks. I mean she really really rocks.