Inside Story! Rumor or Truth? - Page 5

If someone like Nihira can be out and if Debo can be given only 6 n 7 for his song,"Na to karwan ki talaash hai....." then anything can happen,it already shows that politics is there,now Hema is also given easy songs by AS,even if he can sing very hard songs like,"Hai Rama"so that he can be out.All that shows.

U all know one thing,I'll tell u a thing,Nazia,is a singer and daughter of a famous singer of Orissa.She is one of the renowned singers in our state.She was there for SAREGAMA.She was told to sing a particular song suggested by GS in her choice round,What does choice means?Can't i sing my choice of song,then they told that if u don't sing the song told by us u'll be out of the competition,She had already gained enough popularity in her state,she walked out?Do u think it was right?Now u think what can happen in Saregamapa.

Originally posted by: shudakhina

Ok guys! Here's a summary of what I came to know from our forum folks!

First Debo was declared Green with a maximum of 41% votes.

Vineet as well as Hema and Himani walked out. Vineet came on the stage and said, he thinks Debo is getting regional votes…so there's no need for further challenge, let's make Debo the winner!!

Why did they not do the same when Nihira was voted out? Was it because they were actually happy to see the best contestant gone? If Debo's getting maximum votes is the main problem, then why was it not a problem when Vineet got the maximum (31%) in a round where Nihira has got eliminated?

At this point, the audience was stunned and silent, and Ismail Darbar re-challenged Vineet to sing the same song live (without any prep) as Debo. Vineet was nervous and denied to take the challenge.

Funny…that proves once again that Vineet knows what he's capable of and who he can beat! I truly wonder why SaReGaMaPa didn't do this before! It would certainly reveal "Dudh ka dudh, aur Pani ka pani" (commented by some1 in the forum). Guys, who do ya think would win such a competition?

At this point, the contestants demanded a recount…and the recount resulted in a change in result: According to these (unbelievable) rumors:
The result before the recount was:

Debo> Vineet> Himani > Hema

The result after the recount was:

Debo> Hema> Himani> Vineet

It's extremely unlikely that Vineet and Hema's positions have interchanged with Himani being in the same position! The most likely thing is the recount resulted Hema to go before Himani.[Debo>Vineet>Hema>Himani]
I believe that's where the manipulation had taken place! GS was planning to eliminate Hema although it was supposed to be Himani! So the recount resulted in actual vote counts and Saving Himani failed!!

What happened next is quite argumentive and questionable. The rumors say- HR was terrified that Vineet is going to be voted out. So he wanted to cut a deal with the other mentors that each mentor will get to keep one of his contestants. So that leaves AS to get rid of one, and he possibly preferred to keep Himani. So he went to Hema's room and asked Hema to agree to be out ??!! There he got into an argument with Hema's mom!?!

HR would not be stupid enough to ask Hema anything like this.

Anyway, HR approached other mentors and they all agreed to save Vinit's ass and cut the deal to keep 1 from each gharana!!

AS can't loose more than one anyway, and ID is already safe. So this deal would be meaningless for them.

Again, would HR be crazy enough to propose sth like this?

So, Himani was offered to leave and she quietly agreed. She's been crying all the time precisely for five hours!

Absolutely impossible! Himani is just not that type. And the show started in a couple of hours of break…so she can't cry for five hours.

A reality show like Saregamapa can't do such manipulation openly. It's just not believable!

WHAT DO U THINK?

'cause she's another singer like Nihira who's now singing best.Every mentor would have decided that it would be easy for audience to chose last one frm three boys rather than a girl in between,again gals r not voted most,we've seen frm beginning,u know people of India don't want a woman at the top.That's it dear.

Originally posted by: desimam

when they recount vinit was at bottom. why did not they vote out vineet ? why poor himani ?

Originally posted by: desimam

when they recount vinit was at bottom. why did not they vote out vineet ? why poor himani ?

I think that's the weakest link of this rumor. Makes no sense, does it? Why would anybody agree to what HR wants?

HR might have wanted to make a deal before he came to know who got the lowest votes. But if he knew that Vineet was not at the bottom, he would strongly protest the idea of a recount.

I would rather go with the alternate idea that Vineet never became last...it was hema first and then himani.

i wld suspect that by now GS himself is sick of the entire affair, assuming its all true. With another assumption that he/ his creation is being held hostage by one or more of the biggies (people ready to walkout/ badmouth the show etc), what does he do? nothing. what can he do? probably nothing. the best course for him then is to allow the biggies to sort things out for themselves. he cedes responsibility. cant blame him because when u've been a small guy for too long u can get bullied by people who obviously r so much more famous n successful. just my spin on events. am willing to be told i m probably wrong (probably, because we can never be sure)

Originally posted by: shudakhina

I think that's the weakest link of this rumor. Makes no sense, does it? Why would anybody agree to what HR wants?

HR might have wanted to make a deal before he came to know who got the lowest votes. But if he knew that Vineet was not at the bottom, he would strongly protest the idea of a recount.

I would rather go with the alternate idea that Vineet never became last...it was hema first and then himani.

it looks saragamap show is now business , lots of deal going on. it is no more singing competion

Please don't blame 'shudakhina', the facts were already flew in this forum during the days when walk-out was hot. If you had seen/read that matter from studio fellows dictated to forum pens, you would have no problem digesting this now. I think 'shudakhina' just tried to summarise the outcome in different aspect but happened to be at wrong time and at wrong thread!
Any way, good to see the final result stood understandable. May God bless to innocence souls.