ID ka Naatak? - Page 2

I do agree with all of your opinion that ID is a great musician and because Nihira thrown out of the show he left the stage and very upset. I mentioned several time that this isthe time to scrap the public voting system and let these contestants judged by our own greats like Lataji, Ashaji, veteran music directors, singers like SPB, udit narayan, Alka yagnik because they what music means and they had gone so many years of music.

is anybody agree with me

I think what broke the Camel's back was HR and AS scoring 6 and 6 to Debu, after consistently giving him less points throughout the early SRGMP shows, showing openly they want no competition for Hemu and Venoo.

NJ'a exit pissed him off at GS and his rigged vote counting system;
Debu's scoring pissed him off at his peers;
whar else cpuld a man do yaaar?

Originally posted by: Surpremi

I think what broke the Camel's back was HR and AS scoring 6 and 6 to Debu, after consistently giving him less points throughout the early SRGMP shows, showing openly they want no competition for Hemu and Venoo.

NJ'a exit pissed him off at GS and his rigged vote counting system;
Debu's scoring pissed him off at his peers;
whar else cpuld a man do yaaar?

I couldn't agree more..

I agree -- I respect ID a lot too. He is a great music director and Hope he and SLB get together again. It will be FIRE !!

AS far as HR is concerned, we are having a bornfire in this cold winter and O degree weather to burn some CDs rather than wood .... Humraaz... Tere Naam ..... all up in smoke...

Originally posted by: SpaceCity_fan

I think ID went out the set because he knew if Nihira is out its sure that Debo may be out next week. It will be a defeat for him . So before he goes KHAALI HAATH...he decided to shout and show his anger and protest and wanted a NOTEWORTHY SENDOFF!!

I disagree. Ismail Darbar may be naive enough to believe that the public would actually understand complex melodies, but he is NOT a politico.

If you watch him closely, you will notice that he is the type of person who wears his emotions on his sleeve and not cut out for drame-bazi and false praises.

He did not argue with his co-mentors initially as he knows that he is hot-tempered and did not want to fight with them on National TV. Remember how Jatin-Lalit were initially? Always questioning others' judgement? The public did not like that, which is why DUM was almost always in last position in terms of popularity. (this is just one of the reasons, not the only reason)

Frankly, I am glad he blew up at them. I respect him a 100 times more for storming off the sets.

YALGAAR HO!

Originally posted by: Farfromhome

Ismail Darbar is man of Honour. He even offered Sharib to sing with Lata Ji. Ismail may be upset, because he knew that Nihira deserved to be in Final 3. I don't think he had any problems with Himani winning, that is if she did win the finals. Ismail Darbar may have disappointed some of you guys, but I will always have great respect for the guy, as he has made it clear through his actions, he is not biased and he is very kind man. Well, if you don't agree with me, that's your choice. I will voice my opnion. 😳

Agreed totally.... anybody can upset that People dont understand with the talent and technical perfection. As compared to anybody else Nihira has better flow of singing... much less or no flat notes.. and more over her singing have the perfact .... neat shound ... if this is the way this constant goes.. than I should say that any body will upset with and what ever the ID did is correct... b'cos he tries to give the best and people needs just dumbu sigers.. who sings once and twice and goes.. nobody like to have a singer like, I repeat.... like Lataji or Aashaji whoes singing still rules the market...

I feel sorry for the public who dont voted for Nihira...

Public dont have choice...... b'cos they understood that every shiney thing is Gold or Silver.... but dont understood Diamond is always comes from Cole and shine for ever... now Believe me .. in future Nihira will be big singer and if she will tells that .... Public dont have real choice .. then what will you guys and girls will feel..... right......

thanks.. I am sick of it....