ID ka Naatak?

I think ID went out the set because he knew if Nihira is out its sure that Debo may be out next week. It will be a defeat for him . So before he goes KHAALI HAATH...he decided to shout and show his anger and protest and wanted a NOTEWORTHY SENDOFF!!

Originally posted by: Farfromhome

Ismail Darbar is man of Honour. He even offered Sharib to sing with Lata Ji. Ismail may be upset, because he knew that Nihira deserved to be in Final 3. I don't think he had any problems with Himani winning, that is if she did win the finals. Ismail Darbar may have disappointed some of you guys, but I will always have great respect for the guy, as he has made it clear through his actions, he is not biased and he is very kind man. Well, if you don't agree with me, that's your choice. I will voice my opnion. 😳

Agreed........you know ID had been one of my favourite mentors among all as his body language clearly showed that he was not jealous of other contestants from other gharana till date. He is definitely not amongst those mentors like JL, AS and HR.

I wish he cud have done some naatak, then Nihira and Debo would not have been in this state, Ismail Darbar is a true musician and not a skewed businessman. Departure of Nihira could and should frustrate any artist. He is very open about his feeelings- he has judged the contest without any bias towards any contestant. Hats off to him for that.

Adesh is a backboneless mentor - pretending to be foolish and trying to play the game hiding behind HR.

HR - the less said the better-a true example of a hideous character, who could suck up to anyone to serve his own purpose- a complete sucker of a human being.

Originally posted by: Farfromhome

Ismail Darbar is man of Honour. He even offered Sharib to sing with Lata Ji. Ismail may be upset, because he knew that Nihira deserved to be in Final 3. I don't think he had any problems with Himani winning, that is if she did win the finals. Ismail Darbar may have disappointed some of you guys, but I will always have great respect for the guy, as he has made it clear through his actions, he is not biased and he is very kind man. Well, if you don't agree with me, that's your choice. I will voice my opnion. 😳

IS sharib singing with Lata Mangeshkar?

agree ID is the best mentor in this show for me..
ID is not biased towards his own contestant like as mentioned the offer for sharib.also he do encourage the contestants of AS n HR...he is really a man of honour despite all this good acts he has to be out as nihira is out it's probably the chance for debo to go next.
personally i think he is not sad towards the exit of debo next but he is rather sad at nihira's elimination as for almost everyone nihira was the star of the chanllenge and a longlasting competitor in the show.so it's a sudden shock to him.beside tht he will have to go next time he is also a bit disappointed at this public voting system n the elimination of true taents if not he won't have cried when sharib was eliminated...
this is just my personal view sorry if i hurt anyone

I think every thing got to him.6/10 from both hr and AS....Idont know if debo deserved only6 (i doubt it)we will have to wait and see.4/10 was unfair and humiliating.other things too. .all the natak- with vinit mentioning his mother and very conveniently lo behold HRs mother present!!!how manipulating is that?vinit jumped from 4th to 1st position!!.I would have quit.

Originally posted by: Farfromhome

Ismail Darbar is man of Honour. He even offered Sharib to sing with Lata Ji. Ismail may be upset, because he knew that Nihira deserved to be in Final 3. I don't think he had any problems with Himani winning, that is if she did win the finals. Ismail Darbar may have disappointed some of you guys, but I will always have great respect for the guy, as he has made it clear through his actions, he is not biased and he is very kind man. Well, if you don't agree with me, that's your choice. I will voice my opnion. 😳

farFromHome

you really touched my heart ,it's no use now blaming Ismail ji.may god give him more success ,name & fame in days to come.

Originally posted by: Knowles

I wish he cud have done some naatak, then Nihira and Debo would not have been in this state, Ismail Darbar is a true musician and not a skewed businessman. Departure of Nihira could and should frustrate any artist. He is very open about his feeelings- he has judged the contest without any bias towards any contestant. Hats off to him for that.

Adesh is a backboneless mentor - pretending to be foolish and trying to play the game hiding behind HR.

HR - the less said the better-a true example of a hideous character, who could suck up to anyone to serve his own purpose- a complete sucker of a human being.

I completely agree with you.

I'm watching SRGMP 2005 Challenge from its very on set. And I firmly believe that what ID has done was inevitable. ID is a perfect mentor amongst all of these existing ones including HR and AS and atleast he has shown that he has the guts to do it.

As for HR ans AS are concerned, they are really really disgusting trying to play cards with their own limited musical knowledge and vested interest !!

Originally posted by: MunnaBhaiMbbs

IS sharib singing with Lata Mangeshkar?

Yes............... Lataji has agreed to also.......... Thats Ismailji.....

Among HR AS & ID , Ismail Darbar is , without a shadow of a doubt , the BEST , both in terms of a Music Composer and as a person.He is a person who is true to himself. But somehow I think he should have changed his style following HR & AS 's tactics as , I feel , the honest ones are not always rewarded in this world. He should have been more supportive of Debojit & not leave him when he needed some guidance the most. All the mentors are playing mindgames with Debu & that is seriously affecting his performances.So I think ID should have given him all the support in the world so that Debu could give his optimum performance & not get caught in the trap set by the other mentors.