Why Nihira was eliminated ... - Page 2

Adesh too selected a south voice (Hariharan) to Hemu...clever decision at this stage. Whether they sing like Sonu or SP or Kishore or Hariharan or etc...At this stage mentors just want them to sing "MINDBLOWINGLY"

Originally posted by: sindoorfan

Sorry I do not agree to what you are saying. I just watched the episode and I must say that Nihira was awesome to say the least. And so was Himani. Both the girls were favulous today. The songs were both very tough and the girls rendered them beautifully. If India's "aam junta" cannot understand true music its their loss. As far as Nihira's elimination is concerned...well like many others I too believe that its actually a blessing in disguise. Winning this competion may have tied her to ZEE but now she is free to sing songs from other chanels/music directors/audio companies. My best wishes are for them both, and I am sure that they are "lambe race ki ghora" . Challenge 2005 will not and can not deciede their future. They will shine for sure!!!!

if this is the case then may vinit win. good for gajju and vinit. only sad part would be himesh's wishes will get fulfilled. waiting for zee film with himesh music director and vinit singer to flop.

Originally posted by: saregama

Dizzy...........are u crazy....?
just kidding my friend?

But I donot agree with you atall. Ismail's choice was awesome and Nihira was just perfect in that song. It was very difficult song and as ISmail said that "Aaj tak jo bhi yeh gaana gaaye, woh haare hain". Nihira was just mindblowing. What else can I say now?.............

Nihira might have been mindblowing but the choice of song was bad. She sang it so well but the song had not appeal. Ismailji picked that song to test Nihira's singing abilities but he should have thought about the commercial value. The indian audience won't vote for just pure singing talent. ID could have picked another song which was difficult but popular.

Originally posted by: SpaceCity_fan

Adesh too selected a south voice (Hariharan) to Hemu...clever decision at this stage. Whether they sing like Sonu or SP or Kishore or Hariharan or etc...At this stage mentors just want them to sing "MINDBLOWINGLY"

hem can only sound good when he sings with a south voice. any takers for him in hindi films?

Leave Hemachandra please...he is outstanding.Much much better than Vinit.

YOU ARE RIGHT H R GADHA IS VERY CHALU . LATEST NEW FROM INDIA VINIT IS OUT. 😭

Vinit is out now? when ? how?

Is this the truth ?????/ Or mere vengence???????

It's true vinit is out not Nihira,

There was a recount done, and wow! Nihira got 2nd highest votes, Hema maintained his lead.