Himesh’s technical ability a suspect - Page 2

Originally posted by: N Sinha

RD Burman was son of SD Burman, Kartik Raja is son of Illaiya Raja........why do you think they went for classical training..?
Do you feel any diff. in quality of music in those who are not trained Vs trained...?
It is much more difficult to compose than to sing.
It takes years of training & familiarity with many instruments to compose.
ID has worked for 10 yrs as violinist in JL's band, Panham worked for SD Burman as Asst music director.....list is endless.
TRAINING IS MUST......

very well said..........training is a must.........👏👏

RR (Romeo Reshamiya) is a true capitalist. He has truly capitalized on the "music going around" to develop his beats. The fact that he does not have the classical training truly does not surprise. RR wants vinit to win because He wants RR to win. I had caught on the track fiddling just like AS did on the "Aaja AAja main hoon pyar tera". I agree with AS that the stretch and the lift in the song is really what the song was all about.

RR is a tulip - they come and they go fast - the real classical ones stay on forever. Examples are endless. Sinha jee - enjoyed your write up as always !

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Haha jmn, honestly..some of your comments do make me laugh out loud. You know what....I am going to put all my money on Richard Feynman's grandson to prove the Grand Unified Theory and bring Physics to its pinnacle. Why? Come on yaar...he is family!! He doesn't need to know Physics...it's in his bloody genes.

*sigh*

LMAO

Anybody who knows M of music and has been trained in it would know what HR is made up of..he is not a musician he is a techie...use those machine to put pieces togather and some beats and there is ur song...

Well I feel those who think he is a musician, lack (or have no knowledge or training) in music...

Sinha loved ur post. Excellent points.

you are taking everything to your heart. who cares wheather he is trained in music or not. all i know is that he is doing well in bollywood and is giving hit song after song and that is all matters. His attitude in promoting vinit is extremely annoying and is getting on everyone's nerve including myself. But I cannot discredit him for his hit production of music regardless how he is producing---techi or what ever he is selling it. So don't be so bias in critizing him because it makes one sound quite pathetic. I find it quite silly when people present their opinion from one extreme to other. be balanced that shows once intelligence in giving productive critique.

Originally posted by: Foobar111

Anybody who knows M of music and has been trained in it would know what HR is made up of..he is not a musician he is a techie...use those machine to put pieces togather and some beats and there is ur song...

Well I feel those who think he is a musician, lack (or have no knowledge or training) in music...

Originally posted by: N Sinha

RD Burman was son of SD Burman, Kartik Raja is son of Illaiya Raja........why do you think they went for classical training..?
Do you feel any diff. in quality of music in those who are not trained Vs trained...?
It is much more difficult to compose than to sing.
It takes years of training & familiarity with many instruments to compose.
ID has worked for 10 yrs as violinist in JL's band, Panham worked for SD Burman as Asst music director.....list is endless.
TRAINING IS MUST......

so true...training is a must....

just bcoz gavaskar is a good in cricket..does not mean his son needs no training😆

kd286
Many thanks for compliments......... 😳

jmn7
please dont take anything to heart..no hurting feelings...

Originally posted by: preetie

you are taking everything to your heart. who cares wheather he is trained in music or not. all i know is that he is doing well in bollywood and is giving hit song after song and that is all matters. His attitude in promoting vinit is extremely annoying and is getting on everyone's nerve including myself. But I cannot discredit him for his hit production of music regardless how he is producing---techi or what ever he is selling it. So don't be so bias in critizing him because it makes one sound quite pathetic. I find it quite silly when people present their opinion from one extreme to other. be balanced that shows once intelligence in giving productive critique.

Hello Preeti
Many thanks for reading.
Please chill out ...............