Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

3.7k

Users

18

Frequent Posters

hot_as_ice thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#31
NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI NIHIRA HIMANI ........................................
is a nevr ending debate

but i bet nihira will win
aanand thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#32
Enjoyed reading views. Both of them are talented, Personally i like Nihira more.
free advice thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: N Sinha

If we look at their profile: both singers are fully trained, both are ready to invade bollywood music, I shall try to assess their strengths & weakness.
Nihira: technically awesome :superb range control, sweet voice quality(which appeals to masses), being favourite of all mentors including AS who has given her high scores many times. Possible reasons of being laadli:her technical strength, it is difficult to find a missed sur , fully focussed about singing & has maintained wonderful consistency, this pleases composers immensely.
On the other hand she gets so involved in getting sur right that she closes eyes on & off and in this public voting era stops communicating with people, who vote & matter. Though in play back singing when recording will be done what would matter is sur, flow & expression, because people would be listening & not seeing the song. She is in league of Alkaji, Shreya.......

Himani: her voice maturity belies her age, she has a unique voice which is sought after these days and is fit for item no. though she will also fit into sufi/qawalli/mujra singing very well. She falls in the league of Sunidhi, Richa Sharma, Alisha :her other strengths: good communication & great singing style. She will do very well in live performances.
I think she should be more careful about song selection.

In my opinion it is unwise to compare them because they have totally different singing style and mode and would do well in their genres. Also their fans shouldn't forget that we already have a no. of good singers in both genres, so it is likely that they will face stiff competition.Winner can be only one: but the second would also do well..
Sorry.......if this topic is overdone......

again.........mindblowing, fantastic, superb, outstanding comparison...........but my vote goes to Himani.

N Sinha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#34
anand, hotasice, free advice

Many thanks for reading.......
*salil* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: jmn7


The intresting thing is that both of them have the alphabets n,h,i in their names.Is it a coincidence?



Also both of them have syllables "NI" and "HI" in their names



HIMA-NI NI-HI-RA
HI-MANI MA
RA NI-HIRA
Edited by salilu - 19 years ago
fm_qazi thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: lalit1

there is no competition at all

nihira is the best

Nihira is the best but Himani is not much behind. Nihira has her own niche and Himani has her own. But I appreciate Himani more because she has improved a lot during SRGMP competition, this is shows she is a very good learner. But I still think Nihira has edge over Himani. I like this topic and Nsinha Keep these kind of topic alive.

*salil* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

Nihira is the best but Himani is not much behind. Nihira has her own niche and Himani has her own. But I appreciate Himani more because she has improved a lot during SRGMP competition, this is shows she is a very good learner. But I still think Nihira has edge over Himani. I like this topic and Nsinha Keep these kind of topic alive.



I agree fully. Before the agnipariksha rounds, I was of the opinion that-- "There is this gal Nihira.....and then there are others". But with all those superlative performances in agnipariksha rounds--one after another-- Himani has made me eat my words. So before agnipariksha, I would have rated Nihira as 10 and Himani as 6. Now I would rate Nihira as 10 and Himani as 8.5 or 9.

Nihira was consistent all way through but Himani came from behind and improved a lot over the course. She deserves an appreciation for this.

I think both Nihira and Himani will rock the Hindi music world in coming years. You go Himani...hats off to you!!!
Edited by salilu - 19 years ago
Surpremi thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#38
I must add, like in the real business world, it is your fierce competitor that keeps you on your toes. It is Himani that keeps Nihira improving all the time and taking bigger risks like the HRHK song.

As Mr. Kunal Gangawalla said "Survival of the fitest". Even existing singers are looking at this competition and doing more riaz. Eat ot be eaten is the message of the hour. Cannot get complacent. Jo dar gaya samjho mar gaya.
N Sinha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#39
many thanks for reading.....fmqazi, salilu........
sorry for late reply/no reply.
many thanks........
goody thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: asha rao

In my view nihira is better than himani, The reason behind it, is nihira has prooved that she can sing lataji's song as well as usha uthup. but himani cannot sing like lataji she can sing like richa sharma, sunithi chahvan . moreover melody, comedy, and pop songs all varieties sung by nihira was superb. nobody can sing like her. himani's number follows after nihira but cannot be equal to her.

Totally agree with you asha rao that Nihira is the best....she can sing almost all kind of songs in bollywood whereas Himani can sing only few types of songs....I really hope that Nihira wins.....Go Nihira Go....all the best!!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".