No tears shed for Twinkle.......?? - Page 4

Originally posted by: jmn7

N sinha,
I think you like ID very much.ID would definitely choose nihira over Twinkle.The results don't matter anymore now.From the beginig his only goal is to make nihira win the contest.But if Twinkle was in AS or HR gharana she would be getting the support and recoginition that ID was giving to nihira.She would have been in a better situation.Nihira is not responsible for this fraud elimination of Twinkle.Zeetv and gajendra singh are responsible.


As far as vinita is concerned.
If greg chappel coaches a newcomer under 19,and he starts criticizing him for not being able to play strokes like sachin tendulkar or virender sehwag,Constantly undermining him,at the same time giving preference to his favourate player,supporting that player everytime saying that he is the best,it is not good mentorship.His favourate player may have already played in ranji trophy matches,may have experience.I think you understood what I am saying.

Dear jmn07
This is possible that what I'm thinking is wrong, after all this is my opinion only. Please don't get me wrong.
Hmmmm..........for any female contestent, to come out of shadow of Nihira whle being in the same Gharana is dificult, very much like Rahul Dravid not getting recognition while playing on the other side of flambuyoant Shewag/Sachin.
All I can say is that you will see more of Twinkle in future thats for sure...

As far as vinita is concerned.
If greg chappel coaches a newcomer under 19,and he starts criticizing him for not being able to play strokes like sachin tendulkar or virender sehwag,Constantly undermining him,at the same time giving preference to his favourate player,supporting that player everytime saying that he is the best,it is not good mentorship.His favourate player may have already played in ranji trophy matches,may have experience.I think you understood what I am saying.

I'll have to agree that his approach should be more shishya friendly, one shouldn't undermine confidence of a new trainee consistently
Still I say he is a very good mentor & very intelligent song selector for his pupils.

Originally posted by: happygolucky

N sinha ji aap apne vichar prakat karen.

sorry for late reply.
Yes she will excell in a private album , also she is beautiful to look at ,this will help in videos as well, which is very important these days.

It is too sad to see her leave.. her performance was on and off good.. but then again it is not that playback singers sing songs the right way the first time.... even they have their flaws...... sad to see her go.. Ismail has been strict with her.. but that is required from a guru i suppose

Twinkle was good in her own way. Not perfect always, but at certain performances, she would blow your breath away. She seemed to concentrate more on performance and dancing rather then Sur and the song itself. That was her mistake in judgement. Otherwise even as a person, she seems to be very nice and encouraging from the short clips that we get to see. Wish you all the best Twinkle !!!

from all the contestants i think she enjoyed every moment to the fullest!

Thanks for opening this topic Nsinha. I too thought you knew Bengali.
Great post Nonny. Great back and forth MrsPetLover and Nsinha.

I too will miss Twinkle. I always feel bad when a trained singer loses to an
untrained one but the truth is that as we are nearing the home stretch, most
of us will probably be sad to each one leave. I think that any one of the
remaining contestants could win without contraversy (not sure about
Paresh).

I think that they are winners and shoudl be rewarded rightly.

Originally posted by: jmn7

According to me Twinkle is always ahead of nihira and third in the girl singers,because nihira is already eliminated earlier but fradulently kept in the contest by zeetv.If nihira was eliminated,then Twinkle would have been at the top Two overtaking ujjaini.

You sure a GREAT FAN of Twinkle....no problem with that. But to say that Nihira is not better than her just does not go down with me. Sorry on that. U have every right to voice ur statements and so do I and all other Nihira fans. So hope u don't mind.

Originally posted by: jmn7

N sinha,
I also wanted to ask about R.D.Burman's music.He used guitar in many films in the early seventies,like yaadon ki baarat.Guitar seems to be the dominant instrument in some films.While conventional music composers used voilin and the drums more.Is it inspired by the rock and roll music,or his own improvisation?

its purely his improvisation, please go through his biography you will get answer to each & every question, Pancham's music is a matter of thesis writting by musicians, its difficult to be understood completely he was simply far away from his times.

Originally posted by: mdroy

Thanks for opening this topic Nsinha. I too thought you knew Bengali.
Great post Nonny. Great back and forth MrsPetLover and Nsinha.

I too will miss Twinkle. I always feel bad when a trained singer loses to an
untrained one but the truth is that as we are nearing the home stretch, most
of us will probably be sad to each one leave. I think that any one of the
remaining contestants could win without contraversy (not sure about
Paresh).

I think that they are winners and shoudl be rewarded rightly.

I could not reply to salyani, sindoorfan, others......& you because of being in & out of work, Im sorry for that.
, may thanx for reading & responding