My take on today's show, what about yours? - Page 4

Originally posted by: citanuzuki16

just finished watching Ali Sher's Piya Ghar Aaya...
First of all, he did a great start to the beautiful qawali....
The harkat with Ni, was fantastic... The way he took Ni to a lil longer extent and then hitting the "Sum"
It was a typical freestyle performance...The alaap of Raaga Ahir Bhairav (i guess) in between was just out of the world...Vivadi Swars were again used there...
After that alaap he came back to the tune with Naad Dhwani..
Like a typical qawal...
Then in the antara, the harkat with Gharihyaal is again very tough to manage...
The ending alaap again was fabulous...
The atmosphere he created, the energy, the soul...in every way the performance was great....He gave this qawali a very different touch...
BUT THE PROBLEM IS ANKIT DIDN'T LIKE IT....SO NOBODY WILL...

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Lotus, dont respond to trouble makers. Their job is to ruin the topic. Tumse is better than them, gaali deta hai seedha munh pe lekin do not ruin each and every topic. They do not give their opinion on but try to ruin the thread using their pseudo-nationalism.

Originally posted by: lotus1963

Precisely my point. I felt as if I was listening to and watching a real qawaali performance, not a competition unlike with the others. He made it a truly natural performance and was totally in it.

So was Kamal and did a stupendous job but in a different more studied manner.

I really liked the way you analyzed the nuances.

Padma

😊 Look at it this way, now Ali Sher will be back home with his family and with his friend Khurram and away from the Zenophobic Indians you mentioned in your earlier post.......He will be totally free to do what he wishes with his talent........😃 Let's see what kind of atmosphere he creates now......Get yourself a ticket on Faislbad local train to see for yourself..........😊

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

😃 blah blah blah and more blah............Ali Sher is out and the world is a better place for it........😊 all the remaining contestants are winners in my book.........Onward and Forward.....😊

PS --- Actually you were right in the other thread, Khali is a much better singer then Ali Sher.......Can't believe Ali Sher used such cheap tactics like crying on stage to garner more votes........It's been done so many times before mostly by female contestants.......but that's just disgusting......didn't work though, guy still got voted out.......😊

Originally posted by: lotus1963

and did not shed a single tear. Took it like a real man (ugghhhh I can't believe I said that yuck!!!!). Right throughout he came across as a team player who stood by his team mates and so felt bad seeing them voted out but took his decision stoically.

I know there is no point explaining anything to you but anyways!!!

😊 Yeah seemed like losing came naturally to him........he had good amount of practice dealing with losing it seemed like........😛

Originally posted by: Summer3

Ha ha plenty of Masala on this thread😆
sometimes casual remarks or a slip of the tongue can ignite a huge fire. Personally I do not take the show seriously like most persons here but it is nice to see passionate support for someone, anyone will do based on personal preferences.
So this year the wild card entries cannot win. But I like the singers this year compared to those in 2009.

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Lotus, dont respond to trouble makers. Their job is to ruin the topic. Tumse is better than them, gaali deta hai seedha munh pe lekin do not ruin each and every topic. They do not give their opinion on but try to ruin the thread using their pseudo-nationalism.

Originally posted by: lotus1963

Yes you are right HB ji. Will no longer answer. But it is a big nuisance and puts you off expressing your opinions and I feel that it is not right.

A forum has to be a democratic place where one can voice one's opinions.

Here even innocuous opinions and healthy opinions just because one felt like sharing become such big issues and the original intent of the post very soon gets lost.

A very sad state of affairs indeed.

But I wont be cowed down. Not after all that I have been through in life!! If I feel like sharing my views I will continue to do so but YES ignoring some people will certainly be of help!!